3 ms·
Its important to realize what this "response" actually is. Nature isn't actively doing anything. You have 100 elephants, maybe 5 are typically born without tusk
by asdff 5y ago
Its important to realize what this "response" actually is. Nature isn't actively doing anything. You have 100 elephants, maybe 5 are typically born without tusks. Suddenly you kill the other 95 for their tusks, leaving behind those 5 to survive and reproduce and next generation, 33 of your 100 elephants are without tusks or something like that. Over time, humans are acting as a predator in the environment, driving a selective pressure that reduces the fitness of the tusk trait relative to the no tusk trait
- croes 5y agoNature is never doing anything.
- elwell 5y agoThis is both true and false.
- lowkey_ 5y agoI think the above commenter recognized that; that's exactly how these evolutions pretty much always work in nature, not unique to this case.
- ehsankia 5y agoRight, but "natural selection" generally doesn't include human influence, but that's semantics. Would you also say that fruits that are selectively bred to be bigger and juicier are also under the influence of "natural selection"?
- lowkey_ 5y agoI wouldn't, because a fruit bred to be bigger and juicier is engineered by humans for their own benefit, while an elephant evolving to not have tusks is evolution going against human benefit. I believe natural selection includes the influence of any species related to the species in question as predator or prey, and humans in this case are predators. We may historically be responsible for far more processes of natural selection than we're aware of! You're right that it's exceedingly rare to see us so directly play a role in natural selection today (as opposed to indirectly through affecting the environment), which makes this very interesting.
- isoskeles 5y agoI’m not sure where the distinction between “natural” or “artificial” selection is, or if it matters. But it seems clear that humans and our technology are capable of creating far more pressure for other species to either evolve or die if we target them for some reason. If it weren’t for us hunting these elephants for their tusks, there isn’t a reason they’d evolve in this manner. So I just wouldn’t call that evolution by natural selection. Same thing if we set off to exterminate all mosquitoes. But I do get your point. I’m conflicted if we can count ourselves as any other predator species when discussing evolution.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoHumans aren't some supernatural force. We're very much a part of nature as well.
- ehsankia 5y agoI agree, but we also make the very language we're using to describe stuff, and sometimes it's useful to differentiate some things. Very often, it's useful to separate human-caused and non-human caused impacts, such as with climate change.
- evolution_1 5y ago> "natural selection" generally doesn't include human influence It absolutely can. Artificial selection is just a form of natural selection where the environmental pressure is human breeding.
- xwdv 5y agoOf course, because “nature” doesn’t actually exist, it is a concept in the human mind. There is only matter and physical law. What we are simply witnessing is individuals with certain genetic traits surviving in far greater numbers than those who lack them in the current environment, and thus passing those same genes to offspring, propagating them exponentially.
- jrochkind1 5y agoI mean, "nature" never "actively" does anything, there is no active entity that is "nature". It's a metaphor, in all cases.