3 ms·
"SpaceX has been landing their rockets for several years now, and are about to take an even bigger step with Starship." From 1940s, in 20 years we invented jet
by ClumsyPilot 5y ago
"SpaceX has been landing their rockets for several years now, and are about to take an even bigger step with Starship."
From 1940s, in 20 years we invented jet planes and rockets, and since then for the next 60 years we are fiddling with the same basic rocket design. Are you seriously pretending that taking 3 generation to learn to land them is as big of an achievement?
If we kept up the pace of progress, we would have skyhooks in service,
nuclear thermal rockers, nuclear electric propultion, fission fragment rocket and dozens of others.
We have arguably regressed, as starship will just take us to where we were before, being able to reach the moon.
- lopis 5y agoIn any field, you will have lower fruit to pick. > We have arguably regressed, as starship will just take us to where we were before, being able to reach the moon. How good were we ever at reaching the moon, though?
- ativzzz 5y agoTurns out we dedicate tons of resources to advanced technology when we are at war (WW2/cold war). Sounds like we need another good war with a power who is actually a threat to rapidly innovate.
- moffkalast 5y agoI think you're making a flawed extrapolation here, because the space race and the cold war overly inflated the pace of progress in space at the time. With the meagre funding that has remained since the end of that there has been pretty good progress so far.
- supernovae 5y agoStarship is designed for mars. They built a new space craft that will be re-usable, at a cost efficiency never seen before that uses technology specially designed because of Mars. It's engines will use Methane - something no other manufacturer was able to master because of specific issues with those styles of engines and they did it in with the purpose of generating methane on mars to be able to fly back. The methane can be synthesized on mars from CO2 in atmosphere and Hydrogen in Ice. They had to invent the largest re-usable rocket platform, the first re-usable and working methane engine and the first flight computer that could take off and land... Not only that, but they invented or invested in massive technology for manufacturing all of this such that the engines are often 3d printed and designed with precision only dreamed of before.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"First flight computer that could tiake off and land" Soviet Buran could do that in the 80's "Starship is designed for mars" Original starship design was 5x larger and could take meaningfull payload to Mars. It had to be scaled down so that it use the ancient Saturn 5 launchpad and other infrastructure and be more affordable. Current starship is in the same weightlifting category as saturn 5. "First engines to use Methane" So what? If it was first one to use Uranium, that would be a revolution. This is just burning a different propellant. Its an incremental step. It is not a 60 -year milestone. Its like saying 'i upgrading home boiler from coal to oil' - so what? You are still stuck will low energy fossil fuels
- supernovae 5y agoLanding a winged aircraft is different than landing a rocket. Starship is designed for mars and its design changes pending mission realities. The fact they're progressing so quick is awesome. First engines to use Methane are great - and it shows a mission profile that is correct for a trip to mars - since they can use science to generate fuel while on mars. Uranium wouldn't be a revolution and there is no way it would ever pass certification for leaving earth orbit beyond small decay batteries that have been used for 60+ years. Just because you don't agree with the cool shit going on, doesn't mean it isn't cool. And if it could have been done 60 years ago, it would have been done 60 years ago.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"Just because you don't agree with the cool shit going on, doesn't mean it isn't cool." Dota is cool shit too, but I am not pretending it's an achievement that will be remembered in 3 generations, like the invention of an airplane. I feel your categorisation is fed by being a fan of SpaceX and fails to put things into proper perspective.
- supernovae 5y agoNo, not a "fan" of spacex, i'm a fan of space in general. my passion is cosmology, where were discovering more about black holes and gravity waves and new kinds of stars and getting closer and closer to possibly figuring out what all the dark matter and dark energy is. But hey, two can play this game, you seem to hate SpaceX so you throw out the sciences and engineering too.. There are multiple space companies sending up tourists now and dropping the cost per kilo of space travel down while creating new tech to do it. Sure, it may look like a rocket is a rocket, but its certainly not the same rockets from the 1960s - these are rockets that can take off, launch multiple payloads and have components return to earth and land from where they started.