4 ms·
Russia. Saved you a click.
by criddell 5y ago
Russia. Saved you a click.
- emkoemko 5y agomore likely its NSA/CIA... i mean how can anyone even know, look at NSA/CIA program "Marble" its designed to do this make their hacks look like Russians are doing it etc.
- skjhhhhhhhnnn 5y ago>which the U.S. government and others have identified as being part of Russia Microsoft is not making their own determination of who the state actor is and is just letting the three letter agencies' finger pointing fly with no evidence. There is however significant evidence indicating a country other than Russia in the FBI's Solarwinds report that contradicts the headlines if you read the body of the report.
- Ansil849 5y ago> There is however significant evidence indicating a country other than Russia Such as?
- emkoemko 5y agoCIA? look at Vault 7 "Marble" program.... and you really think hackers don't do what the CIA does? could be anyone basically... China etc etc and are probably doing the same crap as the CIA with their "Marble" program attributing the hacks to another state.
- mrRandomGuy 5y agoLess than 1 hour old account created to say that there's significant evidence that Russia isn't behind this without saying what evidence....
- rvnx 5y agoWell it's not really right to censor his answer. The narrative US = good, Russia = bad is true but only if you are in the US. In Russia you see the complete opposite. Both US and Russian intelligence have lied in the past, it's part of their job. For example, the intelligence agencies don't have the right to spy or attack their own population (as far as I know), but there is nothing that forbids them to ask an ally to do it and put the blame on someone else. Russia denies doing it, and both US and Russia have interest into collecting this data, so starting from there, it's important to keep an open mind that the interactions between countries are not black & white.
- 369548684892826 5y agoWeird because Russia isn't really a nation-state.
- kube-system 5y agoIt has somehow become common for people to use "nation-state" almost interchangeably with "state" without fully considering the connotations it implies. Regardless, there's not a clearly agreed upon threshold of how much national identity must be shared to qualify as a nation-state, nor was Microsoft intending to make any sort of commentary on national identity.
- whatshisface 5y ago>there's not a clearly agreed upon threshold of how much national identity must be shared to qualify as a nation-state The best place to draw the line is Texas. More national identity than Texas and you're a nation-state, less and you're a state. The nationality of Texas is undefined in this scheme, which is just as they would have it. P.S. people call extremely well-funded cybersecurity adversaries "nation-state adversaries" because those three words start with the letters NSA. It's a joke about US national security being the greatest threat to US private security.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The best place to draw the line is Texas. More national identity than Texas and you're a nation-state, less and you're a state. When used in the politico-social sense that invokes national identity, nation-state still takes as a minimum requirement the functional sense of Westphalian sovereignty, which Texas lacks. Texas would probably be considered a nation-state in both senses if it was a nation-state in the functional sense; but as a subordinate unit of a Westphalian sovereignty it is not a nation-state in the functional sense, much less the narrower social sense.
- tptacek 5y agoThe "nation-" at the beginning of the term also doesn't add any context that is useful to understanding the story. People should just try not to use that term unless they're making some kind of sociological point. It's "state-level adversary", or something similar.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]