3 ms·
It is not mobile + cloud that ended up here. It is lack of symmetric fiber to the home connections. People do not have upload capacity at home, so there is no
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
It is not mobile + cloud that ended up here. It is lack of symmetric fiber to the home connections. People do not have upload capacity at home, so there is no choice but to depend on large cloud providers. If people had upload capacity, then it could have been possible to host your own backup solutions or media or personal websites.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoI have symmetric gigabit fiber at home, a lot of experience managing tech and servers, and absolutely zero desire to host important things at my house. For less than $10/month I can get a cloud server plenty powerful for anything I want to host with power and bandwidth that are orders of magnitude more reliable than what I can get at my home. Plus I don't have to worry about floods, fires, or theft causing me to lose all of my data and backups stored at home.
- whoisthemachine 5y agoAgreed, and to add to your comment, the cost of securely hosting makes it not worthwhile to host at home.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoIf fiber to the home was widespread, then the market for people who might buy a self hosted solutions would be big enough to be addressable? Also, it is not an either or scenario. You can still backup to a different location in someone else’s computers. Fiber to the home just gives people the option to not solely depend on others’ computers.
- jasode 5y ago>If people had upload capacity, then it could have been possible to host your own backup solutions or media or personal websites. But a lot of us techies here have 1 Gbit dl+ul symmetric bandwidth and yet most of us would rather put source code on Github instead of self-hosting Gitlab at home. Why? Because most of us would rather do something else in our lives that's more high-priority than babysitting a git server (or self-hosted email server, or self-hosted NNTP USENET server instead of discussing stuff here on HN, etc). If (most) techies don't want to self-host, why would it be realistic to expect the mass population to self-host media or personal websites? There's another underlying reason other than upload bandwidth limitation.
- maccolgan 5y agoI self-host my own git server, and I imagine many others do too. But I also publish all my repositories on GitHub (my git server syncs one way to GH) too, you know why? Because discovery is entirely fucking broken for self-hosted stuff. Nobody would ever fucking see your self-hosted content. Search engines are broken for code discovery because of sheer inaccuracy and SEO spam. And that aside my git server is IPv6-only.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoPerhaps at this very moment in time there is another reason, but lack of upload bandwidth is a structural reason, a necessary but not sufficient parameter. Without that, we cannot move forward. It is possible for me to envision a past or future where 90%+ percent of people have fiber to the home and we would have developed hardware and software to be able to route around the major cloud providers, including peer to peer software and hardware that works like appliances. We started with computers that only people invested a lot of time into understanding could use, and now we have iPads and iPhones that people generally cannot break and are much simpler and can be swapped out. I do not see why that type of future would not be possible if everyone had significant upload capacity at home (and having ipv6 and not being stuck behind CGNAT).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- FFRefresh 5y agoI'm very skeptical of this take. I don't think that bandwidth is the limiting factor for self-hosting. The limiting factor is that it's not easy/convenient enough to setup such a system, and most users don't care enough where their files sit (or comprehend the potential externalities). If you thought upload capacity was the limiting factor for self-hosting, why wouldn't those same upload capacity constraints negatively impact cloud adoption? You still have to upload your files to a cloud server.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago>If you thought upload capacity was the limiting factor for self-hosting, why wouldn't those same upload capacity constraints negatively impact cloud adoption? You still have to upload your files to a cloud server. Those uploads are happening at varying speeds at varying times of day, as the capacity allows it. And the constraints do negatively impact cloud adoption, as families that were stuck at home found out trying to have multiple video calls and quality is degraded. There can be more than one limiting factor, but obviously bandwidth is a fundamental limiting factor. Without it, you are not even going to see companies explore the options of selling self hosted solutions, hence we do not even know what advancements in easy/convenient self hosted systems might have been. What peer to peer capabilities we may have had. Societies with home connections heavily allocated for download and minimal upload are just asking to be controlled by gatekeepers.