4 ms·
This chap sounds like an outstanding functional programmer. I am not a functional programmer. I'm also not an imperative programmer. I'm more of a "craftsman,"
by ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago
This chap sounds like an outstanding functional programmer.
I am not a functional programmer. I'm also not an imperative programmer. I'm more of a "craftsman," and I use a lot of tools (including the dreaded OO) to write shipping software that ends up in the ungentle hands of The Great Unwashed. I've been doing that my entire adult life, and I'm 59, so that's been a minute. I've outlasted most of the tools and fads that have come and gone, during my time, and I've learned not to let the tools dictate the craft.
It's a bit discouraging to see how some people look down on folks like me, but I really like getting my hands dirty, and making stuff that people use.
- cafard 5y agoIn the book named Binding Time, Mark Halpern wrote of Backus's Turing Award lecture ("Can Programming Be Liberated From the Von Neumann Style")that Backus seemed to be embarrassed that a computer worked by changing its internal states.
- guerrilla 5y agoIf computations are not instantaneous then how else would it work? I thought his thesis was rather the same as this blog post- that programs should be composable mathematical expressions rather than bit-twiddling word-shoveling statements- but it's been forever since I read that and I probably didn't appreciate it at the time.
- alfiedotwtf 5y agoWe should yell the computer what we want, and let the computer figure it out. This is the promise of declarative languages
- pwm 5y agoWhy do you feel that OP is looking down on you? That's not at all what I took away from his post.
- SamBam 5y agoWell, it describes people like GP as "writing a recipe for a horrendously unimaginative cook." It's telling them that they're writing clunky, minutia-obsessed instructions, instead of elegantly orchestrating a collection of mathematical functions.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoNot me, specifically, although it does, occasionally, get personal. It’s basic human nature. We always reinforce that the way we do things (in this case, FP), is The One, True Way, and all who do otherwise are to be pitied/scorned. I’m a real slob. I mix my peanut butter and chocolate all the time. I may use 35-year-old techniques, and mix them with just-published-brand-spanking-new stuff. I get stuff done. It may be a sausage-and-laws thing, but the end results seem to make people fairly happy. A great deal of the time, I’m constrained by the context of my work. For example, I write software for Apple devices, and am still one of the poor, unenlightened that writes using UIKit. I haven’t written my first shipping product with SwiftUI. If we write in UIKit, we can use different patterns, but UIKit was designed to be implemented, using classic MVC, and lots of OO. Attempting to circumvent these design considerations is a “kludge,” at best. If we want to write good, performant, maintainable software for Apple devices, we need to hold our noses, and use the tool the way it was designed. Apple is refining SwiftUI, which I’m really looking forward to learning and shipping, but I am not there, yet, personally. I assume that SwiftUI will also end up using a pattern that will become “obsolete,” even while SwiftUI is still the dominant development tool, much as is the case with UIKit. Also, SV (or it could just be this community, specifically) seems to be focused on “going big.” I think there was a post, a day or two ago, entitled something like “I don't know how to count that low,” or whatnot. The work I do is “small.” It may actually be fairly intense, “under the hood,” but I write stuff for small demographics, and spend a great deal of time, “polishing the fenders.” This is doing things like ensuring a smooth and intuitive UI workflow, presenting data in as simple and attractive a manner as possible, affording localization and accessibility, etc. These are all about the individual end-user. They are not “big picture” things, and I have limited tools and venues at my disposal. I need to be practical, and make compromises and concessions to achieve my goals. I have nothing but awe for some of the technology and technologists out there. It’s a great time to be alive. Cool stuff is happening. It’s just that a lot of it doesn’t really reach me, down in the trenches, and it’s discouraging to see the mindset that what folks like me do, “doesn’t matter.”