4 ms·
Dune is so deep I kind of wish they had went the Mandalorian route. Take it slow, shoot for 100 hours of high quality story telling, give people time to enjoy
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
Dune is so deep I kind of wish they had went the Mandalorian route.
Take it slow, shoot for 100 hours of high quality story telling, give people time to enjoy the characters.
- jstx1 5y agoDo you think anything was rushed in the movie? I don't think there is 100 hours of story to tell or maybe you're talking about the whole series not just the first book? (and even then it's a lot)
- wernercd 5y agoI think it'd be a good trilogy... or small series. Dozen hours... not 2. not 100.
- croes 5y agoJust remember they made 3 movies from The Hobbit
- jstx1 5y agoThat's kind of my point - when you stretch the source material too thin you end up with a crappy movie.
- globular-toast 5y agoYeah and there wasn't 9 hours worth of story to tell hence all the completely pointless fluff and endless CGI. Lord of the Rings (the theatrical versions) is still the gold standard for a difficult, large-scale fantasy adaptation as far as I'm concerned.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoThe only way I ever want to watch that one again is a fan edit I heard about that cuts off the excess cruft. Lord of the Rings was a dedicated labor of love and is IMO still the (set of) films ever made. The Hobbit was a cynical attempt to try and cash in on LotR's success and mindshare, but it was doomed to fail from the start for not having the same team and amount of creative control behind it. In hindsight, I wish Peter Jackson was allowed to make The Hobbit first, then the LotR trilogy as we know it. The Hobbit could have been a film that never needed the huge budget it got in the end.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoEntire series.
- wernercd 5y agoI plan on seeing it soon but I was hoping to see the Hobbit... a single book turned into 3 movies. Trilogies seem to be where it's at. Taking a deep book and turning it into a single movie seems to not work. Enders game: I'm looking at you.
- wang_li 5y agoWell, this instance of Dune is two movies. Part two is due in October 2023.
- magikaram 5y agoTime to read the books before the next part.
- wernercd 5y agoI'll be going from WFH Covid to hybrid so I'll be spending time on the roads come January... Dune might have to be the first audiobook I start. The real question is Dune or the Prequels... I do like the expanded universe, personally.
- wernercd 5y agoOh snap! good to hear. I've only started looking forward to Dune 2021 since I really hadn't paid attention... I love the audio books - book books were just too dense when I tried to read them originally. The audio books are among my favorite (Dune, LotR, WoT, Potter, Enderverse, couple others). I've seen some good reviews and look forward to it more now knowing it's not just 2.5 hours lol
- ianai 5y agoExcept Dune doesn’t have the same market history as Star Wars to make funding 100 hours as easy to fund. Though realistically it would be cool if an animated, long version existed. Truthfully though with how abstract the story is it’s just hard to get anyone into the background deeply in a video format.
- croes 5y agoIt's interesting that Star Wars is heavily influenced by Dune.
- drexlspivey 5y agoWorld of Warcraft classic pays a tribute to Dune as well. One of the bosses, Ouro is a giant sandworm and drops an item called Jom Gabbar (a play on Gob Jabbar)
- moffkalast 5y agocoughs up Tatooine sand I don't know what you mean. Also don't walk rhythmically, it attracts Krayt dragons. Though SW does present itself in a more fun and relaxed manner, I'm sure Dune would take itself more seriously if it were possible, but it probably actually isn't by the laws of physics.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoDune's influence on science fiction and storytelling afterwards is undisputed, but it doesn't mean it can actually compete with a franchise like Star Wars. Dune was written with a goal in mind - world building, politics, I'm not going to try and analyze it - whereas Star Wars is a pure entertainment product with a fairly straightforward "good vs evil" plotline - at least that was the initial product at the time. The sequel added plot twists, by the 3rd film it started to become formulaic, and the threequel made it kinda ridiculous. Anyway, there's a few stories and books that had the impact and that influenced a lot of things to follow, but which are difficult to actually translate to a successful movie franchise. I mean one of the advertising slogans or quotes they used in Dune's promotional material was that it would go toe-to-toe with Lord of the Rings and Star Wars both. I think everyone that has read the books knows it wouldn't be able to.
- goldcd 5y agoDune: The Sisterhood (HBO Max TV series) has got Denis listed as a director. Details seem thin on the ground, but so far, so good.
- captn3m0 5y ago> Villeneuve is on board as executive producer and the pilot director, while Diane Ademu-John signed on as showrunner He's only directing the pilot episode.
- MikusR 5y agoThere are the miniseries. Despite the low budget they are much better than Dune (2021)