2 ms·
>I mean, “why did [they] do it like this” is one of the most harmless questions to ever exist as far as I can see (provided there’s enough context to figure out
by pydry 5y ago
>I mean, “why did [they] do it like this” is one of the most harmless questions to ever exist as far as I can see (provided there’s enough context to figure out what “it” refers to and what “this” specifically is supposed to be surprising, so that it is not disproportionately low-effort or bad-faith obstructive, but that equally applies to spoken interaction).
I'm pretty sure I could change the meaning of that sentence wildly using intonation and body language. I could certainly make it an offensive statement intended to undermine the listener.
One problem with textual discourse is that people just fill in the body language themselves. Often wrongly. Especially if they let their insecurities fill in the gaps. Which developers with imposter syndrome (i.e. most) will often do.
Emojis help fill in this gap somewhat for some kinds of written discourse (e.g. to intonate sarcasm, "only joking", etc) but on a PR i've never really seen them put to good use.
I think on a PR it might help if the user gets somewhat railroaded into a set of default replies that precisely convey what would otherwise be unstated feeling, emotiom and intent but I'm not totally sure that's how to fix the problem.
It also wouldnt stop wanton dicks from being dicks (not that i think that it's githubs job to fix that).
I do know it is a problem though and i dont think it's on githubs radar at all.
To be fair it used to be much worse before they had comments and every PR comment got treated as a FIXME.