8 ms·
Walmart Billionaire Marc Lore Is Planning a $500B “City of the Future”
- LurkingPenguin 5y agoThis just proves to me that the weed and coke the ultra-wealthy have access to is not the same weed and coke lowly merely comfortable people like me have access to.
- rocgf 5y agoI appreciate this as a joke, but on a serious note, I'm not sure if I should mock or encourage this project. My intuition is that, if the intention is indeed as they portray it, then this sounds totally doable and commendable. Designing a city from scratch, knowing what we know now about cities, technology, transportation, could be great. It could also be dystopic, of course.
- LurkingPenguin 5y agoThe road to hell is always paved with good intentions. Anytime a billionaire tells you he's working on a "new model for society", watch out. In this case, his comment about creating "a new model for society, where wealth is created in a fair way" is especially curious. I mean, does he believe that his wealth was not created in a fair way?
- llamaimperative 5y agoHe’s probably a Georgist, which is basically capitalism with the exclusion of unearned wealth from land ownership. Returns from labor = legitimate, returns from capital = legitimate, returns from just claiming a slice of nature as your own and charging others for access to it = illegitimate. I.e. In its most extreme form, keep 100% of what you create and none of what you don’t. Land owners do not create land, so should not get any upside from it. Whatever is built on the land is their creation, so whoever created it shouldn’t be taxed on any of its investment or returns. This applies even if the landlord and the developer are the same person. Note it’s not actually that new. Lots of places with extreme natural wealth (like Alaska’s oil) create systems like this. The only “innovation” here is recognizing that urban growth also generates obscene amounts of wealth “in the ground.”
- bloopernova 5y agoWill it be called Delta City, will it be built on the ruins of Old Detroit, and will it be patrolled by a new generation of law-enforcement robots? Or maybe he can call it "Rapture", and build it underwater. More seriously: I wonder how much city 500 billion dollars could really build? Given a blank slate of no planning or zoning conflicts.
- moonchrome 5y agoI'm actually sad nobody is building moonshots like Rapture. If we could build deep undersea cities we would basically have a template to mitigate all climate instability for future (even on land). We either have super far out (basically marketing BS) projects talking about Mars colonisation or things like this that's basically more of the same just another iteration. Building something that could withstand a couple of atmospheres of pressure, in a hostile environment (seawater) with currents, with full reliance on artificial air filtration, etc. - solve that and it doesn't matter what happens with climate change, super volcano eruptions, meteors, nuclear catastrophes, pollution etc. not to mention you have hard borders to prevent global pandemic outbreaks.
- akudha 5y agoIf we could build deep undersea cities we would basically have a template to mitigate all climate instability for future (even on land). We have ruined our land and air. We have polluted the oceans to an insane level. What makes you think that we'll do a good job with deep undersea cities? We are even polluting space with debris, are we not?
- crowbahr 5y agoNobody builds moonshots like rapture because there's low hanging fruit with easy and quick returns with nowhere near the risk.
- moonchrome 5y agoSure but that means nobody is building for tail risks. Also these kind of projects require solving problems nobody even tackled so far and they often shake out things that bring industries out of local minimum, providing long term value. Sort of like the space race.
- ourmandave 5y agoWhen will Branson, Bezos, and Musk be tweeting their plans for a Utopian Society?
- Skyy93 5y agoA rich business man founding his own city to show the state how this is done right... sounds like Night City from Cyberpunk.
- f00zz 5y agoNever played that game but from the screenshots it looks like it would be a pretty cool place to live. I see mass transit and high density, not sure why it's supposed to be a dystopia.
- dismalpedigree 5y agoAll it takes is mass transit and high density to not be a dystopia?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- f00zz 5y agoNo, but places that have those tend to be more livable in my experience.
- Skyy93 5y agoIn a Night City-like city, almost no animals exist anymore, not even pets. Life in Night City is even more designed for speed and get rich or die trying lifestyle. In addition, cyber augmentations provide help with jobs and the like, but in the end you can't pay for them without getting into debt, which makes you a slave to the big companies that have de facto state power. I have never understood why high density is considered good or desirable.
- f00zz 5y ago> I have never understood why high density is considered good or desirable. Higher productivity, shorter commutes, easier access to private services (restaurants, etc), lower carbon footprint.
- goinfar 5y agoSounds like some kid with an inferiority complex playing the banker role in Monopoly.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 5y ago> He’s devised a “reformed version of capitalism” with Telosa he calls “equitism,” where anyone can build and sell homes, but the city retains ownership of the land underneath. And who owns the city? Is it, by any chance, Lore or his arms-length foundation? > Exactly where this 21st-century Eden will be located is still to be determined: Developers are hoping to find inexpensive desert land in the Midwest or Appalachia. In other words, a place nowhere near economic activity or water supplies?
- MrBuddyCasino 5y agoIf they do it right, might be an experimental verification of the principles of Georgism: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism Which would be cool.
- dismalpedigree 5y agoSo everything is public invest then? I fail to see any incentive for private investment. It seems like this would lead to a dull and monoclonal existence. Not to mention putting all the power in a single governing body. What am I missing?
- ethanbond 5y agoYep. Equitism seems like a rebranded Georgism/Geoism. To answer GP’s question, the land would be owned by a fund held by the residents of the city. Similar to Singapore. Unsurprisingly it has massive public infrastructure budgets because the public captures the return on its investments, instead of whatever random landowners happen to have land near those investments. See: the value of land near a new subway station or school.
- LurkingPenguin 5y agoI'm surprised he hasn't looked at California City. https://allthatsinteresting.com/california-city https://allthatsinteresting.com/california-city
- top_sigrid 5y agoIt's funny how this shall be a city of the future, when obviously it can only be built with technology from the present. Claiming that in the city there will be self driving cars, when this technology clearly isn't ready yet seems like an odd bet on what the future will be more than anything.
- moonchrome 5y agoSelf driving becomes much easier if you build it into the infrastructure
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoSomething like this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ULTra_(rapid_transit) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ULTra_(rapid_transit)
- anemoiac 5y agoWouldn’t it make more sense to build the “City of the Future” in a place with more of a future, I.e. not in the middle of a desert?
- Dracophoenix 5y agoIf the more pessimistic of climate oracles are to believed, deserts are the future.
- walterbell 5y agoGovernance Handbook for charter cities (Sept 2021, 280 pages), https://www.chartercitiesinstitute.org/post/governance-handbook https://www.chartercitiesinstitute.org/post/governance-handb... > Charter cities are new cities with new rules. The Governance Handbook is the most comprehensive undertaking to date that lays out what these new rules should be and how they should be structured to promote inclusive economic growth ... Building specifically on land with little or no existing development or population ensures that settling in a charter city is voluntary and that the rents enjoyed by local elites are not sufficiently altered to entice efforts to curtail critical reforms. What's more, these new cities are already being built—more than 120 new cities in more than 40 countries —and will continue to be built as urbanization continues apace." https://www.cnn.com/style/article/telosa-marc-lore-blake-ingels-new-city/index.html https://www.cnn.com/style/article/telosa-marc-lore-blake-ing... > A so-called "15-minute city design" will allow residents to access their workplaces, schools and amenities within a quarter-hour commute of their homes. Although planners are still scouting for locations, possible targets include Nevada, Utah, Idaho, Arizona, Texas and the Appalachian region, according to the project's official website. Marketing site: https://cityoftelosa.com https://cityoftelosa.com
- postsantum 5y agoSo many billionaires wanted to build they paradise city/state of the future. I wonder if there is some books or blogs tracking their progress
- akudha 5y agoI have only heard of this in the U.S. Does this happen in other countries?
- postsantum 5y agoNEOM of Saudi Arabia, for example
- galgot 5y agoDeveloped by a billionaire ? I smell something more like a Elysium on earth, an ultra-rich ghetto with all the latest gadgets... With a big fence around for protecting from the plebeians when all starts falling appart elsewhere . But sure, inside they will be all equal.
- radmuzom 5y agoGenerally people have vision of a lot of "tech" in a futuristic city. To me, the following conditions are sufficient - Free healthcare - Free high quality education - Everything else is free market (which includes legal but controlled access to drugs, prostitution, etc.) - No private ownership of vehicles; everyone MUST use public transportation which should be accessible - clean air - walkable - diversity of culture (so for example it should be as easy to find a Bible reading club as a psytrance nighclub)
- throwaway210222 5y ago- Free healthcare - Free high quality education There is no free anything. Perhaps if you called it 'free-at-the-point-of-use-but-definately-paid-for-by-someone-else' it would clarify why such nice things are difficult to achieve in the real world.
- mandmandam 5y agoLaughs in 'rest of the developed world'. Free education and free healthcare more than pay for themselves; not just psychologically and morally but economically.
- throwaway210222 5y ago> Laughs in 'rest of the developed world'. Don't be a dick. > Free education and free healthcare more than pay for themselves… I didn't say they didn't. But they do require someone to pay for it. And those someone's aren't normally the kind of people attracted to a frontier, libertarian concept like building a new city.
- ericmay 5y agoEh I’m not sure on the education piece of healthcare even. For education I mean that’s a no-brainer controversial one. Is it worth it for society to spend resources to train more writers or art history majors? Not sure it is. At least it isn’t obvious to me. While I’m a proponent of UHC as well I think we do have to look at why people need healthcare. Is it because they are obese and just don’t care? If so more healthcare isn’t a good thing unless they also change underlying habits which lead to the need for healthcare in the first place. And also obviously someone is paying for these things. “Laughs in the rest of the developed world” is a really immature comment, especially as we start to see universities in that developed world start to sneak back in fees for things. There is no free lunch. Everything costs something. Maybe we are taxing billionaires or w/e is in vogue right now but it still costs money. By making it “free” we also separate out useful market elements - like instead of going to school to be an art history major maybe for free, maybe you should bear some of the burden for a less useful degree than say computer science where there is a need, or plumbing or electricians. “Liberal arts educations are valuable etc” yea read a book or use the Internet. If you’re not willing to do that freely on your own a university isn’t helping you there and I really doubt the costs are justified.
- bradfa 5y agoI don't see any sports fields in any of the pictures. Sports are a great way to get exercise but most sports inherently have winners and losers. Not only in each game played, but also for the best players. It's not equal. Will sports not be allowed?
- mathverse 5y agoI am looking forward to it.We dont build enough new large cities and I suspect this is mainly because there just is not a place to build them. Building a new city in some american desert and making it high tech and sustainable is a nice dream to have and it could work but... You are still subject to american regulations and laws (the good and the bad ones of course). I think a truly new city to rival cities like Singapore has to be very open and accepting, in a good climate and looking forward rather than sticking to just things that work (trying to compete on infrastructure (bike, public transit with cities that already have that is just foolish).
- zeronine 5y agoi cannot take this seriously, even fiction has more believable backstories for futute dystopias.
- dugmartin 5y agoFrom the article: > Developers are hoping to find inexpensive desert land in the Midwest or Appalachia I'm thinking Architectural Digest needs to hire authors that have left NYC at least once in their lives. In case you are wondering there is not much desert land is available in either of those places.
- christophilus 5y agoThey probably mean deserted / empty.
- LatteLazy 5y agoNot now, but with global warming and a decade?
- bradfa 5y agoHow will this be prevented from just becoming a retirement community? Will they only allow certain people to move here? How will the city avoid criticisms of ageism if most of the people who want to move here are old people looking for a nice place to retire with free healthcare?
- postsantum 5y agoI don't really think it's possible to avoid a blizzard of accussations in your face when you're rolling out your own social policies. You have to be a certified teflon politician to touch this - I mean how are you going to fight the twitter mob demanding racial quotas?
- decremental 5y agoReminds me of Walt Disney's original idea for what Epcot was going to be. His lawyers eventually dissuaded him from the original concept because they told him the citizens would want representation and Walt didn't want people muddying up his vision for a perfect society. If anyone could have pulled it off it would have been him. It's good that the original plans were changed, though. I couldn't imagine what it would be like living under what The Walt Disney Company became after his death.
- 14 5y agoYou would be singing “it’s a small world after all” in your head all day long.
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoYou can get a taste of it at Celebration: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celebration,_Florida https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celebration,_Florida I've never been there but browsing around on Google maps it just looks like yet another car dependent suburb.
- dugmartin 5y agoDisney (the company) did go on to found/develop Celebration, Florida: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celebration,_Florida https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celebration,_Florida The unwashed masses voting problem seems to be a non-issue there: > The area is organized under state law as a community development district. As a result, voting is restricted to local landowners. The largest landowners are entities controlled by The Walt Disney Company.
- BBC-vs-neolibs 5y agoSo, like City of London.
- boh 5y agoHow is Lore raising $500B to engage in a project he has zero experience in? So far it seems like a website full of future speak is his only selling point. I foresee an underfunded, overstretched attempt coming under federal inquiry to account for "lost" funds.
- LatteLazy 5y agoMost US cities seem to just be ultra short term, under resourced, clones of each other. I understand why, free movement of people, capitalism, unengaged electorates and short-termism are facts in western (english speaking) society. Meanwhile anywhere with a bit more soul, from NYC to San Fran, from Austin to Denver see huge demand. I doubt his plans will work because building cities is hard. But at least whatever results won't just be another underfunded, grid pattern of ultra low cost ghettos specializing in nothing but cutting taxes for the next quarter...
- neverminder 5y ago> He’s devised a “reformed version of capitalism” with Telosa he calls “equitism,” where anyone can build and sell homes, but the city retains ownership of the land underneath. Yeah, I currently rent in one of those modern private estates or "resorts" even as they are marketed in London. Apartment leaseholders are being held hostage by the landowner, in some cases paying more in service charge than mortgage. They are struggling to sell, because they would have to find bigger idiots than themselves and those are getting hard to come by. Never in my life would I agree to that.