3 ms·
Foundation (on Apple TV) seems to be trying to GoT-ify the books, and not for the better in some cases (characters are less thoughtful, more action-hero, kind o
by Jtsummers 5y ago
Foundation (on Apple TV) seems to be trying to GoT-ify the books, and not for the better in some cases (characters are less thoughtful, more action-hero, kind of weird choices). Dune (2021) at least avoided that, but it really needed more dialog. There are a lot of ponderous and beautiful scenes and soundscapes + landscapes, what Villeneuve is great at (it's in all of his movies that I've seen, and an element I greatly enjoy). However, watching it with a friend he had more questions than answers by the end, and not just because it was the first half of the book (and the first of the original 6 books). More dialog with a bit more explanation, which could easily have fit into the movie with its long scenes just watching people stand there and look contemplative or worried without extending the total runtime. The pair of movies may work well as a whole, but this movie is not a terribly good standalone film.
- Zababa 5y agoThat might be a personal preference but I don't mind movies that take more investment to really get. Some things you'll understand by watching it a few more times, some things you'll get by reading the book, some things you'll get by learning about the movie itself. Some things also take time to digest.
- Jtsummers 5y agoI liked the time spent on the visuals and music. It was dialogue that was missing. Long scenes that would not have been any cheaper or more expensive if characters had just spoken. Shadout, for instance, never got to be a real character. One scene of dialog, I think. Others suffered similarly.
- Zababa 5y agoA long scene with dialogue is not the same as a long scene without it though.
- imbnwa 5y agoFoundation is verging on CW-level sci-fi writing
- jordanthoms 5y ago2001: A Space Odyssey is (imo) the greatest film of all time, and it's just about incomprehensible on first viewing and explains nothing. So while it might not be the best commercial move I'm personally very happy with telling the story with less dialogue.
- Jtsummers 5y agoDune was good, it wasn’t 2001 good. But even 2001 did a better job (up to the trippy end at least) of storytelling.