3 ms·
It's not even the just FBI; if the majority of your competitors claim to prevent child-porn from being stored on their servers and you don't, the reputational d
by aidenn0 5y ago
It's not even the just FBI; if the majority of your competitors claim to prevent child-porn from being stored on their servers and you don't, the reputational damage is real. Apple doesn't want to be the "Child Porn friendly cloud service."
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoYou're the customer of a cloud service. Do you want the one that does or does not scan your own files so that a false positive could cause you to be arrested, incur thousands of dollars in legal fees and suffer severe and permanent reputational damage yourself?
- lazide 5y agoConsidering that using a service which is known by all to not scan, and is therefore the place the media says is ‘child molester friendly’ could cause the same reputational damage? Might just throw my phone in a campfire.
- passerby1 5y agoI'm not a lawyer, so may be wrong, but am I the only one to think that the presumption of innocence principle does not exist anymore? As there are areas where is does not, and there are "gray" areas that effectively are the same.
- lazide 5y agoPresumption of innocence never applied to SOCIAL judgement. It would be nice if it did, but that was never what happened. It’s why minors information isn’t supposed to be pasted all over the evening news too, so if they make a mistake it isn’t ‘permanent’ and they have some plausible deniability. It’s always been the case that your neighbors or friends or employers or whatever would judge you as they saw fit for whatever they might see or find out about, or even overhear from the local loudmouth/busybody. Regardless of what was found in a court of law. The challenge now is our ‘neighbors’ are now whichever nosy random person in the entire world that cares to look instead of just the local gossip circle, and the gossip is recorded nearly permanently and is indexed in an easy to find way decades later. :s As to if this means people will stop being less judgmental since everyone is likely to have something shitty posted about them at some point? History or the current circumstances don’t seem to be pointing to ‘yes’ right now. But at some point, either everyone is going to stop sharing the smell of their farts every morning, or folks are going to have to stop caring, or we’ll literally not be able to be friends with or employ anyone.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> Considering that using a service which is known by all to not scan, and is therefore the place the media says is ‘child molester friendly’ could cause the same reputational damage? Even putting aside how much of a stretch that is, how is anybody else supposed to know which service you use? It's your personal files. That nobody else should have access to them is the point. It's not as if Apple or whomever should be providing anyone with a list of their customers, as that should cause you to not use them too. As far as I know they don't currently make their customer list public.
- lazide 5y agoNot equivalent to CSAM - just examples of Apps that get some degree of judgement that can be problematic. What would you think about someone that you were talking to that showed you something on their phone (a restaurant listing you were both thinking of going to, or something on Maps), but then a Parler notification popped up? What if they were married and Grindr or Tinder or whatever notification popped up? Would you judge them? Would you expect many other people to judge them, even if you don’t? Don’t get me wrong, I don’t think Apple’s products would be problematic that way. But a big reason why is because they have and likely will continue to make decisions like the one we are discussing. If they went full end to end super privacy, then got named by the feds repeatedly in whatever the next big csam/terrorist/whatever scandal, that could change, and that is even assuming Congress people don’t join in the action, which they’ve already shown an interest in doing.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoProbably >90% of people with the Parler app are conservatives and a similar percentage of married people with the Grindr or Tinder app are cheating, which is where those assumptions come from. Even if Apple wasn't scanning anyone's files, >99% of their users would not be pedophiles and no one would have any reason to assume that they were. > If they went full end to end super privacy, then got named by the feds repeatedly in whatever the next big csam/terrorist/whatever scandal The main effect from getting put on a list like that is to gain credit with privacy-conscious people for standing up for their users. Nobody says "oh no, I better stop using my favorite full disk encryption because it hasn't got any known backdoors in it." > that is even assuming Congress people don’t join in the action, which they’ve already shown an interest in doing. At which point you have government action and can bring out the constitutional arguments etc.