4 ms·
Once more, I don't understand how advertising revenue keeps growing. Once people install ad blockers, they don't typically remove them. And ad-blockers keep gro
by HWR_14 5y ago
Once more, I don't understand how advertising revenue keeps growing. Once people install ad blockers, they don't typically remove them. And ad-blockers keep growing.
So who is actually seeing these ads? How can those numbers be going up?
I understand, intellectually, that not everyone thinks like me. But I don't fundamentally understand why people allow ads on their devices when they can prevent it. Then again, I don't understand a lot of behaviors people exhibit.
- pcurve 5y agoI also think there's a lot of negative ROI on ad campaigns, with no shortage of new players queuing out the door to try their luck in digital space.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe price of the ads could be going up at a quicker rate, especially as more and more viewers from previous ad spending channels (such as TV channels) move to online options (such as Youtube). Also, the number of people using ad blockers must be extremely low. Even crazier, most people who I talk to about content blockers on iOS zone out of the conversation before I can even get to how easy it is. They do not even care that much about the ads or notice how annoying they are. Then again, many or most people still watch live sports and old school TV channels, which are chock full of ads. I cannot even stand too obvious product placement, much less ad breaks. So while I will go out of my way to remove ads from my life, there are probably 9 others who will not spend a single second thinking about it.
- simfree 5y agoSounds like a bad pitch then. Shorten it up, better not to overdo a sales pitch than to do too short a pitch. I don't pitch Signal, but when I do see it pitched those that are most successful pitch 1 directly useful feature as why you should install it. Eg: Get Signal, our videos won't look like a fuzzy potato lens image Remember, your reason should be a problem the person your pitching to has faced and would like to see fixed. If they are having trouble with a different issue, pitch that instead!
- stathibus 5y ago"Get Signal, it _probably_ won't send random pictures to your friends."
- Kafkish 5y ago> Then again, many or most people still watch live sports and old school TV channels, which are chock full of ads. I cannot even stand too obvious product placement, much less ad breaks. Everybody is different. Back in the early 2000s when I used to watch TV, I actually enjoyed ads, because they tended to be more entertaining than the TV shows themselves (remember the Budweizer lizards and eTrade babies). Even when online ads because popular, when they were still contextual, I really did not mind. It was only when ads began to follow people around online that I put an end to it. But I still watch live sports - only online, since I no longer have TV service. I get around ads on NFL games by having more than one game streaming on different tabs, then switch to the one that's not in an ad break. Online, there are no ads during football (the real one), tennis and volleyball matches, so I have very little to complain about.
- HWR_14 5y agoOut of curiosity, which ad-blocker/content-blocker on iOS do you try to steer people towards? Or do you propose a DNS based solution?
- antisthenes 5y ago> So who is actually seeing these ads? How can those numbers be going up? Advertising spend could be going up without more people seeing the ads. Since businesses compete for limited advertising space, they are likely to keep increasing the size of their bids for click. Alphabet's revenue could be growing as a result of eroding the margins of other businesses, who are now forced to spend more money for the same amount of clicks. I don't claim this to be the exact scenario that reflects reality, but it is a very plausible scenario nonetheless. A nice little lesson in why lots of things are zero-sum (even though we'd like to pretend they aren't)
- vlovich123 5y agoAssuming Google has a good handle on click fraud and the growth is real: * Some % of people install adblockers, but that number doesn't grow that much. * There are more people being reached by advertising than ever before. 7.7 billion people in the world & still only about half are online. So overall the number of users they're reaching is growing even if they lose some to adblockers. * You currently have to install an adblocker per device or even application (unless you are in the minority putting it on your router at home). This means that adblock rates vary and a user installing an adblock somewhere doesn't mean that user is globally lost from advertising reaching them somehow. * There are multiple modalities for ad networks (app, web pages, etc etc). Google is involved in all of them. Ad blocking has variable performance across those networks unless you really know what you're doing (e.g. in-app advertising is very hard to block on iOS). * The price of ads can vary driving up revenues. Not all ads are priced equivalently so Google can drive value that way by making the ads more valuable to advertisers or making more expensive ads more appealing. * Inflation will naturally increase total dollar amounts even if everything else remained constant.
- flyinglizard 5y agoAds become more expensive, conversions and ROI keep sliding down, but Google and Facebook are almost the only game in town for online advertising. Where would you go that’s not one of their properties?
- TheDong 5y ago> Once people install ad blockers, they don't typically remove them. And ad-blockers keep growing > don't fundamentally understand why people allow ads on their devices when they can prevent it The market share of iOS also has increased a bit, and iOS does not allow ad blocking very easily. You have to configure some sorta DNS-based ad blocking, which is harder than the traditional desktop firefox/chrome adblockers to install. Usage of computers has also shifted towards phone/tablet apps, away from desktop browsers... And ad-blocking in apps is hard to impossible compared to on desktops. I'm not surprised people continue to see a lot of ads as we move from the web, where mature ad-blockers exist, to apps, where ad-blocking is harder and less mature. Even very technical people usually don't bother with pi-hole and see ads in free android apps. Oh, and also, there are occasionally cases of an ad-blocker removing itself somewhat, i.e. adblock plus used to be the go to recommendation for ad-blocking, but they started allowing google ads through in an update (https://adblockplus.org/en/acceptable-ads https://adblockplus.org/en/acceptable-ads)... so maybe someone installed adblock plus because that's what they remembered from 10 years ago (and adblock plus has better SEO than ublock origin too), and thus still gets google ads now.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago>The market share of iOS also has increased a bit, and iOS does not allow ad blocking very easily. You have to configure some sorta DNS-based ad blocking, which is harder than the traditional desktop firefox/chrome adblockers to install. Are you considering installing a content blocker not easy? Or not ad blocking? Firefox Focus is free and a few taps away from the app store. Seems easier to me than installing ublock origin on desktops. Which people can easily be misled into installing ublock, or adblocker, or any the other scammy ones that do not really block ads or do something else nefarious. It is harder for a non technical user to get fooled by an iOS content blocker.
- TheDong 5y ago> Are you considering installing a content blocker not easy? Or not ad blocking? If you google how to install an adblocker on iOS, you get garbage results which will mostly only work for safari, and will mostly not block google's ads ("acceptable ads"). If I google 'ios ad blocker' and install the apps in the order recommended, I think I'd have to go through ~10 garbage apps before I got to firefox focus. ... And I think for a lot of people, firefox focus isn't viable because they want their chrome bookmarks to sync etc. When I said "DNS-based ad blocking, which is harder than the traditional desktop firefox/chrome adblockers to install.", I was mostly thinking of installing pi-hole since that's the reliable way to block stuff on iOS, since otherwise the matrix of content blockers is a total mess. I'll stand by pi-hole being too much for most people.
- vgeek 5y agoThey can adjust Quality Score parameters or bid floors to increase the CPC and/or make ads look more like organic results to increase the ad CTR. Both will increase their earnings per pageview. More auction participants mean higher bids. Removing match types such as phrase, while automatically shifting phrase to broad modified helps increase their fill rate & number of participants per auction. Eliminating second price proxy auctions in display ads (search likely soon to follow?) will likely yield measurable increases in CPC. A few years back they went from up to 10 ads to 7 on most-- they have that dial to adjust if necessary. Products like Google Shopping take up more and more space on the SERPs and are typically pay to play. They have higher CTR due to carousel images & once you click into that ecosystem, nearly every click yields ad revenue. Chrome behavior with URLs is conditioning users to search for brands (versus typing in the full domain name), who then have to pay to defend their brand terms from brand poachers.
- bduerst 5y ago>adjust Quality Score parameters or bid floors to increase the CPC and/or make ads look more like organic results to increase the ad CTR. That's not really how auctions work. Raising the price floor would just exclude ads with CPCs below the floor from paying, and since they're already getting paid for the maximum CPC bid at the time anyways they would just make less revenue. If they messed with quality score discounts in an exploitative way, the entire billion-dollar SEO industry watching it would notice and cry foul.
- vgeek 5y agoAd Rank is a function of bid and QS (heavily weighted towards CTR). Adjusting weighting of any of the three public components of QS will impact all participants, ignoring cases of exceeding max bids, all bids should increase proportionately-- with some participants having different impacts, but overall a net increase. Bid floors will exclude ads from showing unless a certain ad rank is met. If users want to continue (or start) receiving impressions, they need to meet the adjusted threshold. This won't be as common on terms like "chicago movers", but when you get into the longtail and use an Alpha/Beta structure, it can be relatively common to get a "bids below threshold" for lower volume terms that have less (think <5) auction participants as shown in search insights & sampling the SERPs manually. When you get into these niche terms, you assume terms will be cheap due to lack of participants, but that isn't typically the case.
- sahadeva 5y ago1. More people are getting on the internet all the time, especially new markets like India (who likely don't use ad blockers). 2. We're still early internet, and people rely on the internet more and more (and therefore search more). E.g. in Covid, people are likely transitioning more of their life online, which is good for Google. 3. As companies and the broader economy do better, companies will invest more in growing themselves, often by buying more ads. Companies are doing very well right now (see stock market), so there are more ads being bought AND the price per ad will likely go up because there is more competition. 4. There is still plenty of untapped ad real estate for Google to monetize as well (searches that could generate ad revenue, and web pages that can surface better ads). This combination is great for Google.
- HWR_14 5y agoI would say, with regard to (1), that the people getting on the internet now have to have far less disposable income (at least on average). I mean, sure it's 1/2 of humanity, but it's not 1/2 of the ad audience value.
- summerlight 5y ago1. There's a sizable amount of budget in a process of migrating away from offline advertising market, partially thanks to COVID. This increases auction competition. 2. Online advertising still have a room for better optimization in many ways. You'll be surprised on how primitive bidding systems are for a large fraction of advertisers. Better bidding means ads more likely to convert. Also note that HN readers are extreme outliers compared to usual people who actually spend money on ads. My gut feeling is that perhaps >90% of people don't care much about whether it's ads or not if it seems relevant enough for them.
- jarek83 5y agoPlease mind that google started to show search results in a fashion that if search "A company" then the first link is the ad pointing to the "A company" website and only next is the same exact link to that company website. This is pure cheating and I'm amazed how they can both: laugh at advertisers face and keep it legal.
- slownews45 5y agoDon't advertise that way if you don't want to? I'm failing to see what the issue is. If you don't mind and advertiser saying, hey, look at me instead, then don't pay google to advertise.
- idiotsecant 5y agoBecause google has created a market you can't possibly ignore now since your competitors will buy your brand name as a search term. Say I want to buy a widget from Joe's widget barn so I type in "Joes widget barn" into my computer machine and the first link that comes up is an ad for "Jims Cheap Widgets". That is because Jim outbid Joe for his own name. If google didn't exist that customer would have come to my shop or called me or whatever, but because it does that customer went to Joe. Google has built a nice perpetual money machine by creating a shadow copyright system where you don't need to own the rights to someone's name, you just need to have more money than them.
- ur-whale 5y ago> when they can prevent it. Most people wouldn't know where to start to install an ad blocker. They don't even understand the concept, much less know that it even exists.
- jeswin 5y agoSearch ads and Youtube ads are unaffected by ad-blockers, and that's a big chunk of their revenue.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ChrisArchitect 5y agoYour impression of ad blockers and the market for them is a bubble/wildly off. Likely drop in bucket compared to rest of real world out there! c'mon. (aside: what ads? why are you surfing so many sites with ads where they're a nuissance? I don't even notice them on the few sites I come across them/what I do see is manageable, no plugins or extensions needed ever) Search is the key - so many listings intermixed with search results, and search is a major part of everyone's life. And whether people are clicking them or noticing them is another thing but alot of ad sales are on the page impressions alone, so that's not nothing based on billions of daily searches.
- HWR_14 5y agoI mean, if you don't use YouTube, go to any search engine or go to any news site you can avoid ads. But I'm hardpressed to think of a major website that lacks them. Then again, I block most ads, so ads could disappear from the internet and I wouldn't notice for a while.
- wdr1 5y ago> So who is actually seeing these ads? Hacker News isn't representative of mainstream society. ~27% of Internet users block ads.[1] > How can those numbers be going up? People continue to shift various activities online. Against, HN isn't representative here -- most of us probably already do most things online. There's still a very large chunk of time watching broadcast television, reading printed (offline) media, etc. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/804008/ad-blocking-reach-usage-us/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/804008/ad-blocking-reach...
- ksec 5y agoOnly on HN will you see All Ads = Bad or Evil. The reality is vast majority of people are fine with some ads. Not to mention Ads are not just on the Web, but also In-App as well. In App Ads works way better than on the Web as it function more like TV ads. Especially as newer generation trends towards online media consumption vs old TV box. These are just Ads revenue shifting from TV to Youtube. I dont think the Fundamental of Ads has changed much at all. It might have changed medium, but ads, from a marketing and product strategic perspective remains pretty much the same as in the 80s. But then again, this is HN, defending Ads is contrarian.