8 ms·
Dune 2 is officially happening
- smithmayowa 5y agoAwesome, I really enjoyed Dune, it's one of the best movies ever made. The scenery were so beautiful.
- emptysongglass 5y agoWhen you state it's one of the best movies ever made, do you mean it's up there with Apocalypse Now? Are there lines or performances from Dune you intend to stand next to Brando's? Is it in any way pointing at or making explicit an essential aspect of the human condition in a way that no other film has done before? (You don't have to agree with me this is important for one of the best movies ever made but it helps.) Should it stand shoulder to shoulder with Bergman or--for sci-fi--Alien or Blade Runner? If so, I'd really appreciate an explanation of why you think it's one of the best movies ever made. It's my opinion that Dune is the seal to Villeneuve's fall from grace. His early career was studded with greats like Sicario, which explored the deep vulnerability of a powerless female lead outflanked by the violent potential of the professional men in her company; and Enemy, a psychotic allegory for fear of real intimacy. Villeneuve was a rising star, I couldn't have been more excited for where he was pushing film together with his often companion, Roger Deakins. Dune is nothing more than beautiful scenery with airbrushed beauties vaulting through bedecked spaces. The dialogue could have left the lips of anyone in any scene with as much impact as the platitudes of a college freshman. There is good cinema within our generation but it is startlingly rare. Most of what makes it to the theaters is bloodless, drained of anything to say about anything at all. Villeneuve's new Blade Runner 2049 was a visual feast as equally as bankrupt. The passage from Nabokov's Pale Fire that Gosling was allowed to develop into the film's baseline test appears as a kind of last, bare rebellion from the director against the powers of Hollywood like Sylvan Esso's pop track Radio, 2 seconds longer than the mandated 3.30 of a real radio hit.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- smithmayowa 5y agoI found myself lost in it's world, wondering what it will be like to belong to one of it's great houses, and being able to travel to other planets. I also found myself considering coloring my eyes lol, it's been really long a movie has got me in that state of mind.
- skinnymuch 5y agoYou only chose older films to contrast with Dune (2021). Blade Runner being the newest at nearly 40 years old. It’s a lot easier to bring up old media. Be it music or movies. People revere the old, the classics. Apocalypse Now, which is amazing, in my opinion, didn’t get amazing reviews upon release. Fall from grace means you didn’t like Arrival too much either? I loved Arrival as I loved Sicario and Enemy. > Alien or Blade Runner? I love the concept of time so personally I enjoyed Arrival more than either of these. Same with Ex Machina, Annihilation, Primer, and Upstream Color. I also think these films are better too. I admit I must have a bias against glorifying the classics because of it being done so much. Obviously everyone has biases. > There is good cinema within our generation but it is startlingly rare. Most of what makes it to the theaters is bloodless, drained of anything to say about anything at all. Yes. This is the easy way out. Revering the old is easy. In 40 years people will be saying how new films don’t compare to Dune (2021) or Blade Runner 2049. You said what makes it to theaters. Not wide release films. That would include a lot of indie and other films. In that case, I completely disagree. I believe it has gotten better. I get to see movies with a wider range with the easier access and technology for smaller films that get to be made. Same with music.
- emptysongglass 5y agoYes, Arrival was terrible and bloodless. The central conceit was what I called the sundered triforce but this tropes page calls the Dismantled Macguffin [1]. It was Villeneuve's first real stepping out into becoming whatever Hollywood needed him to be and it shows every step of the way. > This is the easy way out. Revering the old is easy. In 40 years people will be saying how new films don’t compare to Dune (2021) or Blade Runner 2049. Startlingly rare within our generation means what I say. I would expect there to be a strong corpus this round given film history but it defied my own expectations. That doesn't mean I don't think good examples exist just that they're, well, startlingly rare. Upstream Color was courageous I'll give you that. But I think it took real moxy from Carruth to make it happen: he did the music, shot the film, wrote it, directed it, and starred in it and for basically no money just like Primer. And I think directors like Ana Lily Amirpour who did A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night are the courage we need to see. The problem doesn't appear to be a lack of directing talent so much that the media machine takes that talent and corrupts it absolutely. Look what happened to Ridley Scott or Taika Waititi. They became owned and operated by the industries behind them which must ensure a broad appeal for the highest ROI. It's market forces at their most efficient at a global scale we've never seen before. [1] https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/DismantledMacGuffin https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/DismantledMacGuf...
- imbnwa 5y agoAm I wrong to find it hard to believe they haven't filmed any of Part II? They were just sitting there on-location and going "nope, not gonna shoot any Part II material"? They've been talking up this ultimatum of "see it in theatre or else" for months, and I'm supposed to believe the studio would actually sit here and re-negotiate/re-budget cast/crew/locations? What am I missing? Edit: For the record, I really liked Part I. How many people here watched it and were expecting to here people's mental dialogue jump on the sound track at a few points?
- GekkePrutser 5y agoI think there's a lot of work to be done before you can start shooting scenes. Screenplay, set design etc. Since the project wasn't officially greenlit they would have had to be creative to pay for all that. I doubt it would have happened. But I'm not in the film industry so perhaps I'm wrong!
- atoav 5y agoAs someone in films myself I suspect they shot a ton of material they can reuse in part II. Maybe Villeneuve even came with the argument ("Part II is basically half in the box as we shot aome of the stuff already"). However it is hard to say if they really didn't have it planned from the start. Both is possible and likely. Villeneuve's film definitly was a risk from a film producers standpoint. The director is not known for compromises and the material he worked with is not known to automatically lend itself to be filmed easily — historically these have been the key ingridients for catastrophic productions. So given the risk I wouldn't be surprised if they really didn't plan for part II from the start. But my feeling is that they already decided for part II to exist before the movie hit the box office (which is why the movie feels like it needs a part II)
- imbnwa 5y agoThanks for the explanation, I'd assumed execs have access to the material and can tell what they have on their hands as it comes along (further assuming that this is the whole point of their job aside from telling if a screenplay is any good).
- michaelcampbell 5y agoI quite enjoyed it. I was joking with my wife that the first 3 minutes before the title roll was better than the Lynch version. The effects certainly helped; the sheer size of things was amazing.
- mythrwy 5y agoYes, but not soon enough!
- alanwreath 5y agoWhile I agree with all the people who appreciate Dunes special effects, scenery, and actor choices…can we all agree that the directing is lack luster? The story isn’t being explained well. Emotions are being expressed with little or no back story and really fail to engage the audience emotionally. It really seems as if this would have been better done in GoT style. I mean I have to watch part two, but not because part 1 was good story telling or even acting. It wasn’t.
- Zababa 5y agoI don't really agree, I think it was great. I'm really glad it's not GoT style, and that it's more austere, cold in a way, as I think it's a better fit for the story. I don't think it failed to engage the audience emotionally, but rather that you personally failed to engage with it. Same thing with the lack of backstory, I don't have many memories of the Lynch one and had no trouble following. I think maybe you are used to a certain style of movie that Dune differs from, and thus have a hard time with it?
- robbedpeter 5y agoYes. A better style of movie, that engages in storytelling, and not shallow highlights riffing off the experience of the book, with sufficient razzle dazzle to make people who haven't read the book follow along. The power of Dune is the interwoven plots, not the linear narrative the movie attempts. It wasn't bad, but it certainly wasn't good.
- Zababa 5y agoI think trying to find the book in the movie is useless, there's already the book for that, and the movie can't really be better at being a book than the book. I don't have many memories of Dune, but I have still strong ones of Hyperion, and I don't think I would ever be satisfied by a movie that attemps to be just the book. On the other hand, I would be fine with Villeneuve adapting it with his usual style (though maybe Hyperion is a bit too organic for his style? It's hard to say). > A better style of movie > It wasn't bad, but it certainly wasn't good. I think it was great.
- thevagrant 5y agoI hoped the announcement was related to a modern remake of the classic RTS game Dune II from Westwood Studios (1993?). Although I do look forward to watching Dune.
- dddw 5y agoYou mean Super Dune? ;) https://www.moddb.com/mods/super-dune-ii-classic https://www.moddb.com/mods/super-dune-ii-classic