3 ms·
I'm not sure I trust the social media companies' own claims about how much reach and engagement they have. I suspect there are a lot more people who aren't capt
by cratermoon 5y ago
I'm not sure I trust the social media companies' own claims about how much reach and engagement they have. I suspect there are a lot more people who aren't captured than is believed in tech circles. This is almost certainly ignoring the vast areas of the world where the reach of technology is nothing like urban areas of the developed world.
But if the amount of attention captured is correct, approximately, and some substantial majority of the world's attention is captured, then we may have an "engagement bubble", and soon to face a crash in the value of attention, which could result in the major social media and adtech companies losing billions in value. I would expect to see ever-more predatory and manipulative strategies put in place to maximize the revenue extracted from engagement. There is already considerable effort being put into expanding the reach of the internet, for example StarLink, Facebook subsidizing "free internet"[1], and so forth.
1 https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2018/09/how-facebooks-free-internet-helped-elect-a-dictator.html https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2018/09/how-facebooks-free-i...
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoI agree that it's going to get more predatory, manipulative, and frantic as they can't grow metrics any more. The next step is going to be fractionalized attention. If I'm looking at my phone while you're playing an ad in the video I'm watching on my PC, then how much is my "attention" on the PC worth? About zero, because the ad doesn't actually have my attention. If I call up a web page, and it auto-plays five ad videos, how much is my view worth? Not much, because my attention is split five ways (six, if you count my attempts to stop all the auto-play videos so I can look at what I actually came to the page for). So they may grow the metrics by increasingly desperate measures, but they're going to cheapen what attention is worth by doing so. On the other hand, actual, real, full, willing attention is valuable, and becoming more so. (Supply and demand, if nothing else - the demand for peoples' attention is increasing, the supply isn't.) In fact (digression), it's so valuable that you should consider it as a Christmas present. Give your actual, full, willing, undivided attention to the people you care about. It's a rare and valuable gift.
- cratermoon 5y agoA radical idea is to acknowledge that the user's attention has monetary value and pay them. Even a thousandth of a unit of the local currency per "like", comment, or share, to users would, if the actual reach and activity of social media is approximately accurate (~4 billion likes/day, ~4.7 billion shares) might generate enough backpressure on so-called engagement metrics to make the ad-revenue-driven social media consider how much their profits depend on the free work of their users. Remember the adage, "if you're not paying for the service, you're the product" and understand that the services that users (the product) provide in the service of ad sales deserve real compensation. Either that, or tax the revenues of social media and its investors and put the money into actually improving the lives of ordinary people. Or, most radically, consider the absolute absurdity, to put it mildly, of a business that makes a profit off the free labor of individuals and simply abolish the practice.
- Gtex555 5y agoWell false claims of reach should be useless ideally, let me walk you through an example with a banner ad. If I claim your ad on my website reaches 10,000 people but only 1000 click it then my 10,000 reach only has a clickthrough rate of 10 percent, so even I lie to someone else and say it has a reach of 100,000 but the same 1000 click then it will only have a 1 percent clickthrough rate. So the ultimate metric can not be fooled , maybe for a few months sure but I`ll be found out , in a perfect/rational world lol.
- cratermoon 5y agoThere are dozens of metrics[1], and few of them are tied to clickthrough. In the adtech business uses clickthrough rates for online advertising aren't considered a useful metric any more. Make what you will of that. 1 https://instapage.com/blog/key-advertising-metrics https://instapage.com/blog/key-advertising-metrics
- Gtex555 5y agodamn, seems like the only way to verify the reach. CPC (cost per click) is still a think in ad though so that's good.
- cratermoon 5y agoSocial media and adtech have a vested interest in keeping advertisers thinking they are getting value, and ignoring the execrable click-through rates. There was a time when it was genuinely believed that all this technology would let advertisers know that spending $X in ads would get Y sales for $Z revenue, and therefore know exactly what it costs to get a potential customer to buy something. This is probably a pipe dream.
- Gtex555 5y agoWhy do the companies paying for said ads fall for it if its so blatantly obvious, personally I think its either they have a way of checking the value of the ads (clickthrough rates/ conversions) or they are just stopping their competition from monopolizing the ad space.