5 ms·
If Engineers are teached humanities. Why not humanities are teached STEM... Like basics of math, physics, chemistry, engineering and son on... Would in general
by Ekaros 5y ago
If Engineers are teached humanities. Why not humanities are teached STEM... Like basics of math, physics, chemistry, engineering and son on... Would in general make our society better if everyone understood these things.
- notafraudster 5y agoHumanities degrees almost always require both 1-2 mathematics courses and 1-2 science courses, and they're almost always fulfilled with complementary electives e.g. "rocks for jocks" type material, the same way engineers fulfill their complementary electives with blowoff courses that cater to their preferences.
- mywittyname 5y agoMIT had a course called Physics for Future Presidents. Which is basically a primer of the major topics in science.
- ketzu 5y agoAren't those basic high school topics?
- Ekaros 5y agoThey should be. Maybe just need to apply standards to high schools and not allow graduation without certain sufficient baseline... Which currently clearly is too low in many countries.
- rjzzleep 5y agoLast time I interviewed someone in the US, they actually did do that in the first terms in the IT Bachelor because apparently there is no common standard across US high schools. But given how many of the investors in the UK actually study humanities at Oxford I'm not sure what you're trying to accomplish there. Unless you really believe that studying humanities somehow makes you a more moral human being that then doesn't go on to destroy the world, which clearly isn't the case. And for reference Boris Johnson studied classics at Oxford, fucked a dead pig as part of a fraternity initiation ceremony and is now doing his best to dismantle public healthcare in the UK. So I don't think the "make our society better" statement holds any value. EDIT: comment below is right, it was David Cameron, not Boris Johnson. And he studied Philosophy, Politics and Economics. So while the last paragraph is half correct and half mixed in with Boris Johnsons history, both of them have been working hard on selling off the NHS. Boris also hasn't started as many wars. So, I guess Boris is better on a relative scale?
- thedailymail 5y agoNitpicking, but wasn't it David Cameron who fucked a dead pig?
- MadeThisToReply 5y agoWhat wars did David Cameron start? You sure you're not thinking of Tony Blair? Incidentally, Cameron is far from the only UK politician to have studied PPE at Oxford. An alarmingly high number of our leaders are products of that one degree program at one university [0] - which suggests that this program deserves a lot more public scrutiny than it gets, given the shoddy results it seems to produce! [0] https://www.theguardian.com/education/2017/feb/23/ppe-oxford-university-degree-that-rules-britain https://www.theguardian.com/education/2017/feb/23/ppe-oxford...
- throwaway210222 5y agoProbably because most are too dumb to pass it. Before you down-vote: ask what their high school STEM grades are?
- tremon 5y agoAre you suggesting engineers aren't taught the basics of reading, writing, perspective, and so on?
- dbetteridge 5y ago'taught', you can have 'teach' or 'teaches' but not 'teached' And in theory the basics of those should be covered in high-school.
- joeberon 5y agoEngineers are not taught humanities here in the UK, and I'm sure that's also true in many other countries
- ghaff 5y agoDepends what you mean by "taught humanities" I guess. For my engineering degree in the US, I certainly took non-engineering/science courses as part of a distribution requirement and took various other courses and did various other activities as well. Among other things, communications has been a key part of my career track.
- ben_w 5y agoLiterally zero of my degree modules (BEng Software Engineering, Aberystwyth) were non-software engineering. But the UK does all of education differently to the USA, or at least it did when I went thought it: mandatory up to the age of 16 where you got approximately a dozen GCSEs, then two years doing A-levels (3, 3.5, or 4), then you go up to university. The only mandatory requirement to do humanities was in the GCSEs.
- joeberon 5y agoDuring an engineering degree in the UK you will not be required (or even usually have the possibility) of doing a non-engineering module
- randac 5y agoI think the only module I took that was close to this, for CompSci in UK, was on technical writing.
- ericd 5y agoMIT requires it of everyone, but Economics fulfills the requirement (and it’s a popular route, since you get a bit of basic algebra homework instead of paper writing).
- jessriedel 5y agoBased on personal experience, I don't think it's a symmetric deficit. Just as an example: at lots (most?) colleges, you must take (or test out of) a foreign language to graduate, but it's fine to not take calculus. And in any case, a journalist covering a technical subject should have a basic understanding of units. It's really elementary stuff.
- jerf 5y agoPeople are taught the basics of STEM. At least here in the US. It just doesn't stick.