As far as I know, there surprisingly aren't other options. I also assumed they would have something else up their sleeve that was stronger than OTC ibuprofen bu

As far as I know, there surprisingly aren't other options. I also assumed they would have something else up their sleeve that was stronger than OTC ibuprofen but weaker than a morphine analogue. But, the three classes of analgesics really seem to be Tylenol, NSAIDs, and opioids. A few other things are usable for anesthesia but not something you can prescribe as a pill for at-home pain control. There is also some evidence for cannabinoids, but they're stuck in legal limbo. The other thing that comes to mind is that benzodiazepines can also help in some patients. They don't have a direct analgesic effect, but can help people relax or sleep so as to ignore pain (they can also be habit-forming, but probably not to the same extent as opioids).