4 ms·
Note, the EV revolution and Tesla being the winner of the EV revolution are different outcomes. They're certainly winning the EV race now, but it's possible tha
by HWR_14 5y ago
Note, the EV revolution and Tesla being the winner of the EV revolution are different outcomes. They're certainly winning the EV race now, but it's possible that some of the other car companies can overtake them.
- FeepingCreature 5y agoOn the other hand, if you want the EV revolution for its own sake, investing in Tesla as a generator of hype can make instrumental sense.
- HWR_14 5y agoI mean, if "Make the richest man on earth richer, so a few more news stories will be written about him, because that might lead people to look into EVs" is how you want to spend your hard-earned dollars, I'm not going to stop you. I'd suggest there are far more efficient ways to bring about social change, both in terms of fewer negative side effects and more bang for your buck.
- FeepingCreature 5y agoI mean, phrasing aside, it seems to be working? Recommend some of those better ways to promote EV?
- jlmorton 5y agoThe bear thesis for Tesla has been something like, "Tesla might have an innovative EV-first design, but when the major manufacturers with a century of manufacturing know-how wake up to EVs, they will drown Tesla in vehicles." I think part of what's driving the increase in Tesla's value is the realization that this thesis was wrong. Tesla is now beating all the established manufacturers at gross automotive margins, and it's really not close. Toyota is around 18%, Ford and GM around 15%. Tesla is up at 27%. Part of that might be demand-driven higher prices. But Tesla continues to reduce their cost of goods, and Tesla has emerged as the most innovative manufacturer, which we already see in teardowns of the Model Y, with huge sections cast as one piece, but particularly in the design of Cybertruck, and Gigafactory. Tesla is far out in the lead on software. They appear to be rapidly improving on manufacturing. Tesla has paid down its debt with stock issuances, the company has $16 billion cash on hand, and the ability to go get a lot more nearly for free. If the major manufacturers aren't going to catch Tesla with manufacturing prowess, or capital, what are they going to catch them with?
- alphabettsy 5y agoI wonder how much of the margin is made up of the $10,000 FSD option?
- _ph_ 5y agoVery little. First of all, a lot of cars are sold without this option, but most importantly, a large part the money isn't recognized as revenue yet, as the FSD isn't ready yet. A part of it is recognized due features like "summon" and "navigate on autopilot". But the large part of that money is still unrecognized revenue. There will be a boost to the revenue, when they can recognize the remaining part of the FSD payments in the future, but this will be a one-time effect.
- HWR_14 5y agoThis is interesting. You're claiming that the FSD money they collect isn't recognized yet? Can I ask you what leads to you thinking that? I'm sure it's in one of their financial disclosures, but you may be able to narrow it down for me.
- _ph_ 5y agoThere were statements made when they recognized parts of the FSD money.
- HWR_14 5y agoI'm sure they were. I don't disbelieve you. I just don't quite get what to search for (or where) to find out how that policy works and what percentage of income they've already recognized.
- _ph_ 5y agoHere is one link I found: https://www.tesmanian.com/blogs/tesmanian-blog/tesla-autopilot-full-self-driving-fsd-revenue https://www.tesmanian.com/blogs/tesmanian-blog/tesla-autopil...
- m0zg 5y agoThis line of reasoning reminds me the time when Android came out and people were predicting the imminent death of then-newborn iOS. Tesla is Apple of car manufacturing. That much is pretty obvious if you drive one of their cars. They seemingly deliberately depart from what everyone else is doing. And my bet would be that they'll continue to do so, and continue building out technological capabilities that no other manufacturer would even be able to imagine, let alone build, such as e.g. their own AI training silicon, new battery tech, material science stuff, deeper automation of manufacturing, etc, etc. That said, I don't understand their stock price either, even in the light of all that, so I don't own any of their stock. But my next car will be a Cybertruck. Once you go electric there's really no going back. And that's how it ought to be in general: green options _must_ be better all around (perhaps with the exception of price, though I'm sure price differential will go down over time), not a fucking "tofurky" style garbage that no one would buy if it wasn't "green". Because you can make people tolerate things "for the greater good", but you can't make them like things that suck, at least not for long.
- HWR_14 5y ago> Tesla is Apple of car manufacturing. Can you explain what on earth that means? Apple makes good use of their device ecosystem, purchased app lockin and network effects to maintain an excellent position. Tesla has none of those benefits, other than their US (not EU etc. which is required to be open) supercharger network (which they promised to open to all EVs). When I read your post (e.g. it's obvious as soon as you drive one, once you go electric you never go back) and both of those sound like arguments for EVs, not Tesla. Tesla may have made those two synonymous for a while, but I cannot believe it will last. I will ask, are their departures from traditional manufacturing good? Even people I know with a Tesla that mostly has sat in a garage for its life (no need to commute during WFH because of COVID) say it's already showing extreme wear.
- m0zg 5y agoIt means they bet on vertical integration, and they make product decisions no other manufacturer has the balls to make, and win because of it. Observe how _nobody_ can make a laptop that's better than MBP in spite of having several _decades_ to observe what Apple does. The same is the case here. Tesla has insurmountable avantage in this regard simply because they are not a "traditional" car manufacturer and have no "legacy" they have to maintain. But the best explanation is to just go to a Tesla dealership and take one of their cars for a spin. It _feels_ like iPhone.
- Thlom 5y agoNorway is the most mature EV market in the world and it's not clear from the sales statistics that Tesla is winning. They sell a lot of vehicles, but not the most (might be winning in profits though).
- opinion-is-bad 5y agoIsn’t this due to supply constraints, at least in part? There simply are not enough teslas available to meet current demand, so they end up buying other brands to avoid waiting a few months.
- fomine3 5y agoIsn't it applied for most EVs?