4 ms·
Why are stingrays missing from the guide? Aren't they the most useful tool in the toolbox?
by 1970-01-01 5y ago
Why are stingrays missing from the guide? Aren't they the most useful tool in the toolbox?
- fractal618 5y agoClearly they are ubiquitous at this point, and I bet their data goes back to inception.
- kjaftaedi 5y agoThis is an interesting point. My guess is that this looks like training material for low-level desk jockeys to help do all of the legwork gathering evidence that would be presented in court cases. Stingrays you would think would be more of a targeted operation and likely handled by a different group of people.
- gzer0 5y agoMy claims are without evidence, but it certainly seems as if this document was created with the intentions/hope that it would be eventually leaked. The second slide seems rather suspicous in its placement of "CAST members are not qualified to testify after reading this"; almost as if they were not speaking to an audience of CAST members, but rather, the public. Perhaps a decoy? to draw attention away from STINGRAY and other intricacies?
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The second slide seems rather suspicous in its placement of "CAST members are not qualified to testify after reading this"; almost as if they were not speaking to an audience of CAST members, but rather, the public. Sounds like they are doing advance witness tampering by trying to get CAST members to evade calls to testify on material facts known to them should they receive such, not lobbying the public via anticipated future leak. (I’m not even sure how the statement about testimony would be expected to manipulate the public.)
- gzer0 5y agoThat is a valid consideration. Touché.
- Spooky23 5y agoIt’s pretty obvious the audience are consumers of the service. (ie other FBI agents) If you’ve ever had to testify as an expert, it’s an art and a science. You need a lot of training to be able to respond to the traps attorneys will set for you.
- imroot 5y agoAlso, wasn't US Cellular bought by Sprint in 2012? I did some work on their compliance team in 2010/2011 and the merger was one of the reasons why I left.
- selectodude 5y agoUSCC offloaded a bunch of spectrum and customers to Sprint awhile back but they're still independent. Funny enough, US Cellular divested their Chicago holdings back in 2012 to Sprint but never moved their HQ. None of their HQ employees have cell service through them.
- jauer 5y agoI'd consider stingrays one of the least useful tools since they require logistics: you need to have one installed somewhere or have logistics to deploy them quickly to an area. If you aren't careful, your target could become aware of their presence. If you are pulling data from the carrier, there's less logistics involved and your target shouldn't notice unless someone screws up.