3 ms·
400GB/s is very high for a CPU bandwidth, but is less than of NVidia's GTX 3080 760GB/s bandwidth. Assuming you care about 32-bit of course. I don't expect the
by dragontamer 5y ago
400GB/s is very high for a CPU bandwidth, but is less than of NVidia's GTX 3080 760GB/s bandwidth. Assuming you care about 32-bit of course.
I don't expect the M1 Pro to have very good double-precision GPU-speeds.
- saberience 5y ago> I don't expect the M1 Pro to have very good double-precision GPU-speeds. Compared to what? There are no laptops quite like these new Apple laptops. Anything with faster graphics also uses LOADS more power and runs WAY hotter.
- dragontamer 5y ago> Compared to what? There are no laptops quite like these new Apple laptops. Anything with faster graphics also uses LOADS more power and runs WAY hotter. Using 2x the power for 2x the bandwidth (on top of significantly more compute power) is a good tradeoff, when the NVidia chip is 8nm Samsung vs Apple's 5nm TSMC. In any case, the actual video game performance is much much worse on the M1 Pro. The benchmarks show that the chip has potential, but games need to come to the system first before Apple can decidedly claim a victory.
- GeekyBear 5y ago> the actual video game performance is much much worse on the M1 Pro Well, no. The emulated x86 gaming performance is. They didn't test a game with a native version.
- dragontamer 5y ago> They didn't test a game with a native version. If the native version doesn't exist then... gamers don't care? Gotta get those games ported over
- GeekyBear 5y agoHave you seen how terrible the x86 emulated performance is on a Surface Pro X? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OhESSZIXvCA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OhESSZIXvCA
- dragontamer 5y agoAnd that's why gamers are buying the Surface Book instead? The "gamer" community (or really, community-of-communities) only cares if their particular game runs quickly on a particular platform. Gamers don't really care about the advanced technology details, aside from the underlying "which system will run my game faster, with higher-quality images" (4k / raytracing / etc. etc.)?
- GeekyBear 5y agoNo, that's why having x86 emulation performance be this good is a minor miracle. Native performance would be expected to be inline with what the benchmarks are showing. The MacBook Pro Max would beat the 100 watt mobile variant of the 3080, especially if you unplug both laptops from the wall where the 3080 has to throttle down and the MacBook does not.
- dragontamer 5y ago> No, that's why having x86 emulation performance be this good is a minor miracle. No gamer is going to pay $3000+ for a laptop with emulation when $2000+ gamer laptops are faster at the task (aka: video games are faster on the $2000 laptop). ------ Look, gamers don't care about all games. They only care about that one or two games that they play. If you want to attract Call of Duty players, you need to port Call-of-Duty over to the Mac, native, so that the game actually runs faster on the system. It doesn't need to be an all-or-nothing deal. Emulation is probably good enough for casuals / non-gamers who maybe put in 20 hours or less into any particular game. But anyone putting 100-hours or more into a game will probably want the better experience.
- rbanffy 5y ago> the actual video game performance is much much worse on the M1 Pro This is a workstation. For games one should look for a Playstation ;-) 2x power also means half the battery life. Remember this is a portable computer that's thin and light beyond what would be reasonable considering its performance. Also, remember the GPU has full 400GBps access to all of the RAM, which means models of up to 64GB won't need to pass over the PCIe bus.
- Siira 5y ago(The GPU probably can’t saturate the 400GPps.)
- defaultname 5y agoIt's pretty remarkable that now we're not only comparing Apple's SoC to the best CPUs from dedicated makers, we're comparing it to the best GPUs. Could you qualify what you mean regarding double precision, though? nvidia consumer GPUs have pretty terrible double precision (usually in the range of 1/64th single precision). And FWIW, the normal cores in the M1 (Max|Pro) have fantastic double precision performance, and comprise the bulk of the SPECfp dominance.
- dragontamer 5y ago> It's pretty remarkable that now we're not only comparing Apple's SoC to the best CPUs from dedicated makers, we're comparing it to the best GPUs. Is it? Apple has 5nm on lockdown right now. Process is nearly everything in performance/watt. If you want to compare architectures, you compare it on the same process. 5nm vs 5nm is only fair. 5nm vs 7nm is going to be 2x more power efficient from a process level. When every transistor uses 1/2 the power at the same speed, of course you're going to have a performance/watt advantage. That's almost... not a surprise at all. It is this process advantage that Intel wielded for so long over its rivals. Now that TSMC owns the process advantage, and now that Apple is the only one rich enough to get "first dibs" on the leading node, its no small surprise to me that Apple has the most power efficient chips. If anything, it shows off how efficient the 7nm designs are that they can compete against a 5nm design.
- GeekyBear 5y ago> Process is nearly everything in performance/watt. Not really. Apple's A15 and A14 phone chips are on the same process node. >Apple A15 performance cores are extremely impressive here – usually increases in performance always come with some sort of deficit in efficiency, or at least flat efficiency. Apple here instead has managed to reduce power whilst increasing performance, meaning energy efficiency is improved by 17% The efficiency cores of the A15 have also seen massive gains, this time around with Apple mostly investing them back into performance, with the new cores showcasing +23-28% absolute performance improvements https://www.anandtech.com/print/16983/the-apple-a15-soc-performance-review-faster-more-efficient https://www.anandtech.com/print/16983/the-apple-a15-soc-perf...
- Veedrac 5y agoA 3080 Mobile only has a bandwidth of 448 GB/s. You quoted the desktop number (which also has a different die).
- fomine3 5y ago3080 mobile is confusing brand name. It also uses GA104 rather than GA102, so it isn't totally equivalent to 3080 desktop.