4 ms·
When do gravitational waves actually arrive from distant objects relative to light from those objects? Generally the space between us and distant objects isn't
by tzs 5y ago
When do gravitational waves actually arrive from distant objects relative to light from those objects?
Generally the space between us and distant objects isn't actually a perfect vacuum. It should have an index of refraction greater than 1, and it should vary by frequency. Light from a distant object should arrive here spread out in time by frequency, and the earliest should arrive a little later than something moving at the speed of light would arrive.
Is there something like the index of refraction for gravity waves? If not then we should see gravity waves from an event before we see any light from the event. If there is, then it should be possible for gravity waves to arrive before, at the same time, or after light from the same event depending on the frequency of the gravity wave and the light.
- gizmo686 5y agoDepending on frequency, the vaccumum of space is close enough to a vaccum. If the light needs to travel through something opaque, you generally just don't see it (although it may illuminate the dust) We have measured the relative speed of gravity and light. The difference is constrained to be no more that about 10^-15 times the speed of light. This us based on a signal that travelled 130 million light years. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/GW170817 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/GW170817
- AnotherGoodName 5y agoEvery experiment so far has detected gravitational waves a tiny bit before they detected light based evidence. Consistent with the light being slowed by the refraction in that very small amount of matter that exists in the interstellar medium and gravity passing through that dust more or less unaffected. Of course going faster than light which is being slowed by absorption and re-emission isn't the same as breaking the speed of light since light itself is going slower than the speed of light in this case. So yes you're right that it isn't exactly the same arrival time but we're not talking about curvature differences here, we're talking about physical interactions that the light undergoes that gravity doesn't.
- piyh 5y agoWe need to replace faster than light with faster than gravity
- spsoto 5y agoI don’t have a physics background but I’ve always seen “c” as the speed of causality. The light happens to go at that speed in the absence of gravitational disturbances. Gravity and others fields should also move at this maximum speed. That said, I’m still trying to come to terms with the fact that breaking this speed limit just means that causality would be potentially broken. Isn’t that just something we axiomatically believed based on experience and we just haven’t observed otherwise?
- Twisol 5y agoMy (mostly layperson's) understanding is that our laws of physics demand that causality would be broken; it's not taken as an axiom. Because of how the three dimensions of space and one dimension of time are put together, you can think of there being a balance or trade between motion in space and motion in time. If you aren't moving in space, you're moving through time at the maximum possible "rate". The more rapidly you move through space, the slower you move through time. This trade bottoms out at "c", at which point you're not moving through time at all. (Since motion is impossible without time passing, "c" itself is unachievable; you can only approach it asymptotically. Something about massless particles makes "motion" not a thing in the first place, I think, meaning they can actually propagate at exactly "c" as seen by an observer.) You can visualize this as a dial on an X-Y graph which starts out pointing in the Y direction, and as you speed up, it turns more toward the X direction. When you're pointing completely in the X direction, you're moving "at the speed of light", purely in space and not at all through time. If you turn the dial even further, you're trading some of that speed back for motion in time... but in the opposite direction. Of course, this is all super-handwavey; most importantly, velocity has to be measured relative to an observer, so all of this about rates has to be anchored relative to an observer. (But this is also precisely why massless particles propagate at the same rate regardless of observer -- insert timey-wimey Doctor Who reference.) Greg Egan has a lovely trilogy, Orthogonal, set in a universe where space and time don't have this trade (formally, the sign on the time variable in some critical equation is flipped to match the spatial dimensions). He has some great material on the exact physics of such a world. [0] [0] https://www.gregegan.net/ORTHOGONAL/00/PM.html https://www.gregegan.net/ORTHOGONAL/00/PM.html
- wlesieutre 5y agohttps://arxiv.org/abs/1710.05833 https://arxiv.org/abs/1710.05833 > On 2017 August 17 a binary neutron star coalescence candidate (later designated GW170817) with merger time 12:41:04 UTC was observed through gravitational waves by the Advanced LIGO and Advanced Virgo detectors. The Fermi Gamma-ray Burst Monitor independently detected a gamma-ray burst (GRB 170817A) with a time delay of ∼1.7 s with respect to the merger time. So there is a delay between arrival of gravitational waves and accompanying gamma ray burst, but I couldn't tell you if that's purely because light travels slower than it would in a perfect vacuum, because the gravitational waves are generated before the gamma ray burst, or a bit of both. The GRB being less than two seconds long, I would guess they both happened at close to the same time, and it does have a speed difference. Coming from an object 130 million light years away, 1.7 seconds is a very small difference in speed.