2 ms·
Ugh I really dislike articles like this. There’s zero nuance and just pandering to people who already agree with the headline. If you can’t argue for and defend
by Spivak 5y ago
Ugh I really dislike articles like this. There’s zero nuance and just pandering to people who already agree with the headline. If you can’t argue for and defend in good faith the perspective of the people you disagree with then you don’t really grok the issue and won’t be persuasive.
Good gods, I whole heartedly agree with the author that this bill is a bad idea but the argument is so weak that if I came in in support of the bill, after reading this I would walk away with more resolve that I was right.
The author paints the opposing view as a misguided emotional reaction to a tragedy, and even if the author’s characterization is correct, that’s not at all how the people in support of this bill see the issue. And rabble rabbling about the free speech and democracy to people who aren’t even thinking about that will just make it another us vs them where both sides talk past one another and believe the other is missing the point.
We have to stop this stupid game of framing complex issues in such a way that paints anyone who has different goals priorities than you like “oh so you hate democracy?” If you villianize everyone it loses its weight for the times when someone is truly purposely out to hurt people.
- aww_dang 5y agoThe purely democratic view might be to let the majority choose whatever regulations they see fit for online discourse, our diets or our clothes. Tyranny of the majority, etc. Democracy isn't a value unto itself in my view. I would describe it as a method. Those who object to the premises of democracy in favor of individual agency would also object to bans of online anonymity. But as you say, if you already disagree with the ban, you're more likely to to let it slide.