11 ms·
Banning anonymous social media accounts would only stifle free speech, democracy
- 0des 5y agoTime to use a PURDAH https://lareviewofbooks.org/article/nonexistence-seems-preferable-post-truth-feed-identity-and-the-npc-afterlife-in-neal-stephensons-fall-or-dodge-in-hell/ https://lareviewofbooks.org/article/nonexistence-seems-prefe...
- lvl100 5y agoAnonymity doesn’t mean lack of accountability. There are ways to have both. Not hard.
- Spivak 5y agoUgh I really dislike articles like this. There’s zero nuance and just pandering to people who already agree with the headline. If you can’t argue for and defend in good faith the perspective of the people you disagree with then you don’t really grok the issue and won’t be persuasive. Good gods, I whole heartedly agree with the author that this bill is a bad idea but the argument is so weak that if I came in in support of the bill, after reading this I would walk away with more resolve that I was right. The author paints the opposing view as a misguided emotional reaction to a tragedy, and even if the author’s characterization is correct, that’s not at all how the people in support of this bill see the issue. And rabble rabbling about the free speech and democracy to people who aren’t even thinking about that will just make it another us vs them where both sides talk past one another and believe the other is missing the point. We have to stop this stupid game of framing complex issues in such a way that paints anyone who has different goals priorities than you like “oh so you hate democracy?” If you villianize everyone it loses its weight for the times when someone is truly purposely out to hurt people.
- aww_dang 5y agoThe purely democratic view might be to let the majority choose whatever regulations they see fit for online discourse, our diets or our clothes. Tyranny of the majority, etc. Democracy isn't a value unto itself in my view. I would describe it as a method. Those who object to the premises of democracy in favor of individual agency would also object to bans of online anonymity. But as you say, if you already disagree with the ban, you're more likely to to let it slide.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hirundo 5y agoSocial media makes it cheap and easy to retaliate against speakers who say unpopular things. Anonymity protects from exactly that. If you think such retaliation tends to be a positive/negative force in the long run, you probably dislike/like anonymity. As someone with a wide portfolio of unpopular views who prefers a loosely coupled, bottom up social architecture, I value anonymity as a key value and technology for promoting adaptation. A society with strong anonymity norms can test the fitness of more, and more diverse life algorithms than otherwise. That tends to make it less fragile and more likely to find a variety of local maxima.
- moron4hire 5y ago>> test the fitness of more, and more diverse life algorithms WTF is that even supposed to mean? 4chan commentors aren't some cabal of underground philosophy bad-boys, trying to carve out a New Enlightenment. The only "life algorithm" they seem interested in testing is anti-semetism. They're just assholes.
- bm3719 5y agoI suspect the commenter is borrowing from AI terminology to describe a real life ecology of ideas and solutions to problems. Also this is an incorrect generalization of 4chan. While rare enough that I don't bother going there, thoughtful exchange can and does occur on it. Besides, this is about anonymity in general, not on one specific site. Do we really want an internet where everything you do and interact with is forever attached to your real person?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwoutway 5y agoUsing 4chan to argue against what OP stated seems like the weakest form of strawman you could find. Could you choose something else, like Twitter?
- bmarquez 5y ago
- bruiseralmighty 5y agoSuch a cowardly defense of the pro-privacy position coming from the Guardian, I wonder if they had trouble sourcing anyone at their offices who were authentic advocates for this position. The author rightly points out that there was no connection between the killing of Amess and 'social media anonymity'. So I suppose at least they are doing their part to combat that false narrative set up by Parliament. However, we then launch into one-armed counter attacks about how MPs who cut benefits (ahem Tory ahem) have more of a responsibility to endure vitriole from 'the poors' whose benefits they cut. Yet simultaneously, we should still stomp out 'right-wing-extremists'. Whom I suppose have no legitimate grievances with the government despite the fact that Islamic State can operate within London and kill their political representatives.
- trompetenaccoun 5y agoWell said. The Guardian has become such a rag, the very last time I took them slightly serious was before that Batley Grammar School story with the teacher who's now in hiding and fearing for his life, where they described those issuing the death threats as peaceful and well-liked members of the community whose beliefs should be respected.
- hoppyhoppy2 5y agoSee also https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28943782 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28943782 4 days ago
- mcguire 5y agoAs well as https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28946349 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28946349.
- spicybright 5y agoNo kidding. Should we have been taping our ID's too our foreheads when protesting the whole time if that wasn't the case?
- mcguire 5y agoWhat is your position on police officers covering their badge numbers at protests?
- spicybright 5y agoDisgusting, but I've never any incidents of this. Almost every state requires them to state their name, badge number, and department if requested. If I'm paying them with taxes, and allowing them the ability to use a massive amount of force taht non-officers are not allowed to, you can be sure I'd want their info in case they make a big mistake. I'm not working for anyone but myself when I'm protesting.
- mcguire 5y agohttps://www.cnn.com/2020/06/05/politics/law-enforcement-badges-protests/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/06/05/politics/law-enforcement-badg... https://www.adn.com/nation-world/2020/06/05/seattle-police-chief-orders-officers-to-show-badge-numbers-after-reports-some-were-covering-them/ https://www.adn.com/nation-world/2020/06/05/seattle-police-c... https://www.opb.org/news/article/portland-police-cover-name-tag-badge/ https://www.opb.org/news/article/portland-police-cover-name-... https://www.chicagoreporter.com/chicago-police-investigating-78-complaints-of-officers-removing-or-covering-badges-during-protests/ https://www.chicagoreporter.com/chicago-police-investigating... https://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/nyc-crime/ny-nypd-cops-accused-covering-shield-numbers-protests-20200604-rje2krqecfcrdcex2p2fdy3c5i-story.html https://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/nyc-crime/ny-nypd-cops-... https://i2.wp.com/www.chicagoreporter.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/crop_george-floyd-protest-police-caravia.png https://i2.wp.com/www.chicagoreporter.com/wp-content/uploads...
- wolverine876 5y agoAre you suggesting that an action by the state is equivalent to actions by private citizens?
- sysadm1n 5y agohttps://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Dickwad_theory https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Dickwad_theory
- trident5000 5y agoPseudonymity is where its at if it can be done well...where its verified that this is an actual person and not a sovereign or political party troll farm. But at the same time protecting ones true identity. Platforms right now are in charge of that vetting process and try their best but its really just not working well.
- phillipseamore 5y agoAgree. I also feel there is a big difference between being anonymous and someone using multiple anonymous accounts to amplify their expression.
- readflaggedcomm 5y agoWhy? Identity does not make an argument. Numbers of posts don't prove me wrong. A preponderance of quacks doesn't inform me of my baking skills when I toss bread to ducks. The impulse to identity, by law or platform-specific reputation system, is useful for other ends, but the end of judging books by covers should not be one to strive toward.
- renewiltord 5y agoThat’s because going from premises to conclusions is the rarest and trivially followable argument and the complexity of discussion arises from concluding on facts. For instance, is it true that you couldn’t get a COVID test in SF around Jul 4? With provenance of information, people start trusting trusted sources for facts. With fixed identity, people can evaluate what the preponderant view is. If you’re in a room with ten of your friends and you could get toilet paper in Jan and all of them couldn’t, you would judge yourself lucky and that there was an availability problem. If I go online and I see one thousand posts saying the opposite of what I’m seeing, I’m going to ignore them. Primarily because of the identity problem.
- readflaggedcomm 5y agoAttesting to facts requires more than identity. There are billions of nobodies with identities whom I don't trust to attest to anything. Verifiable events can be attested to (like the availability of testing) with trustworthy data, like from a reliable reporter or the test providers or some reliable surveillance mechanisms. Using a identity as a proxy for accountability, in furtherance of reputation management -- as the social media web largely treats all this -- is an error. People aren't reliable just because we know they're people, as Facebook-provided comments on third-party sites demonstrate.
- Barrin92 5y agodisagree with this take. It might stifle free speech but in my book it does not stifle democracy, and reducing the latter to the former is a mistake. I think the basic unit of democracy is the citizen, and the citizen is not a private person. Being a citizen means participating in public life, and public life brings with it, trust, accountability and reputation. I do not belief at all that such a thing as an anonymous democracy can exist. Anonymity might be a useful tool against certain forms of authority, that is to say it can guard certain negative rights, but i think it is an absolutely wrong tool to build a community in any active sense, because to be part of a community means to have an identity and be accountable. I think anonymity is appropriate for whistleblowers or transparency activists, but not for ordinary people who wish to participate in public and political life or discourse. I also don't buy the argument of the article that power imbalance justifies anonymity. People in power are not wrong just because they are in power. They should have the same recourse against say, vile attacks or defamation that anyone else has. This 'stick it to the man' impulse that allows viciousness in discourse just because there are imbalances in power is i think a form of misguided egalitarianism. HN is I think a good example. Quite a lot of people here have their real names attached to their accounts, those that don't at least comment under a consistent pseudonym, the site is quite harsh when it comes to avoiding bans. This elevates the discussions here compared to completely anonymous websites which are effectively a toxic swamp. If I had to pick between the HN democracy and the 4chan democracy, I knew what I would pick.
- chmod775 5y ago> I think anonymity is appropriate for whistleblowers or transparency activists, I guess the state should get to decide who qualifies? That'll work out swimmingly.
- notriddle 5y agoNo, it obviously should not be the state that decides something like this. This is journalists' work. The most difficult part of whistleblowing is proving that any of this stuff is happening. If I started posting on HN about a black market for human baby meat, you probably wouldn't even see it: pg would ban me almost immediately as a troll, and he'd be right to do so. But what if there actually is one? (and I'm not even really anonymous; if you want to, you can find my real name) A journalist who knows the real identity of an anonymous informant has the ability to prove that they are who they say they are, and that the stuff they're trying to blow the cover of is actually happening. You don't know the identity of the informant, but there is still a real-world identity and reputation tied to the information, which is at least supposed to mean that if they're full of crap, you don't listen to them next time. There is, simply put, a chain of custody for reliable information.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ashtonkem 5y agoIt’s extremely suspect that they’re moving to ban anonymity and “legal but harmful”[0] speech as part of the response to an attack that doesn’t appear to have anything to do with online activity. It’s interesting how the tabloids that regularly call people incredibly vile things don’t get singled out… Frankly, I think this is politicians getting tired of being heckled by the citizenry, and this is a convenient crisis to take advantage of. Must not be a lot of fun to go from giving speeches in parliament to being called a wanker or ratio’d online, but that seems like something they should get over rather than curtailing our rights. 0 - Part of the Online Harms bill, being debated now.
- Veen 5y agoAs many UK media organisations have pointed out, linking David Amess’ murder to online speech and incivility allows politicians to be seen to do something without having to address the politically awkward problem of Islamic extremism in the UK. Naturally, Owen Jones chooses not to mention that too.
- ashtonkem 5y agoFrankly, I still smell a rat. Islamic terrorism is a problem, therefore everyone in the UK must use their real name when calling their MP a wanker on Twitter? Even if you acknowledge that the problem is real, the proposed solution does not follow. No, it seems far better targeted at getting people to stop saying mean things about them on Twitter more than anything else.
- throwaway472927 5y agoIt doesn't need to work for politicians to successfully "be seen to do something". But I see your point.
- BitwiseFool 5y agoThey say it is to protect us, but I suspect it is actually to protect themselves.
- 5y ago
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoBanning anonymous social media accounts and trying to strike down Section 230 are both obvious attempts at returning the power of disseminating information to the powerful. Rush Limbaugh spent most of his adult life being a racist misogynist and getting paid handsomely for it. He found his niche and his audience. Bob Limbaugh, just a dude at Acme, would find it hard to retain a job making similar statements, even if they were less incendiary. Yet Bob would almost certainly be silenced if his online presence were tied to his actual identity, out of fear for his livelihood. And because Bob doesn't have a team of people to filter out confrontations, you're more likely to get an honest debate on the merits of ideas from Bob than you would have ever gotten from Rush even if it won't reach as many people. Most people just want to live their lives, even if some of the things they believe are stupid or ridiculous.
- saurik 5y ago> ...trying to strike down Section 230 are both obvious attempts at returning the power of disseminating information to the powerful. (We agree on anonymity, so I've elided that part; but as for Section 230...) I think this depends on whether you believe that removing Section 230 will cause social networks to filter more stuff or less stuff. It is worth remembering that the people who drafted Section 230 absolutely believed it would cause more content to be filtered by smaller numbers of more controllable companies: the reason it exists in the first place was not to defend the right to publish content, but to allow companies to filter content--as part of the Communications Decency Act, where the government wasn't sure it would have the power to regulate speech and so was examining the problem of how to draft the large media organizations into their cause--without becoming responsible for the other content... to create a carve-out safe haven for anyone who helps filter the world from "indecent" communication. As it stands, disseminating information is only at the grace of the powerful: Facebook, Twitter, Google, etc.; as they change their policies of what is "acceptable content", people gain and lose their ability to disseminate information. If you disagree with the authors of Section 230 and instead believe that removing it will cause social media companies to filter even more content and take back even more control over communication, then sure: that's bad; but, if you agree with the people who drafted it... that, without protection from prosecution over their editorial decisions, they will fall back to "I'm just a dumb platform" (like a telephone company, which does not need Section 230 to operate without content filters, and which is absolutely enough to build a social network such as the original Instagram on top of), then this would be a big boon to deconstructing currently-centralized control over information.
- philjohn 5y agoIt's worth bearing in mind that just over the last few days we've seen Conservative MP's respond to genuine questions and being held to account over a recent vote (against preventing the dumping of untreated sewage) respond that this is anonymous abuse, would lead to another murder like that very sad death of David Amess, to try and shut down any scrutiny. Banning anonymous accounts is not to prevent harm, but it's being sold that way.
- mcguire 5y ago"...we've seen Conservative MP's respond to genuine questions and being held to account over a recent vote." The United States Congress uses anonymous voting to explicitly avoid that sort of thing.
- philjohn 5y agoAnonymous voting of your representatives should never be a thing - you need to know their record to see if their values align with yours when going to the ballot box.
- wolverine876 5y agoUS Congress voting is not anonymous. You can lookup each members vote on every bill (though maybe there is a rare exception I'm unaware of).
- mcguire 5y ago"All voting in Congress is a matter of public record. However, not all floor votes are roll call votes. There are voice votes (“aye” or “no”) and division or standing votes (where the presiding officer counts Members), and these types of votes do not indicate by name how a member voted." (https://www.senate.gov/legislative/HowTo/how_to_votes.htm https://www.senate.gov/legislative/HowTo/how_to_votes.htm) I am having a difficult time finding data on the number of roll-call votes vs. others; general descriptions go between "very often" and "the majority". "Very often, when a vote is called for passage of a particular bill, a voice vote is the usual procedure. Equally often, a bill is often declared "passed" even when the voices of a measure's supporters are not obviously louder. Also, a voice vote does not allow a member's constituents to know how he or she voted on a particular bill. If a clear-cut winner of a voice vote is not recognized, then a request for a recorded vote is made." (https://www.legion.org/legislative/thomas/17797/part-11-roll-call-votes-voice-votes-and-unanimous-consent https://www.legion.org/legislative/thomas/17797/part-11-roll...)
- PaybackTony 5y agoThis is a very complicated topic that seems to see a lot of conflation, as it does in this article. It's really hard for a social network to maintain a balance, especially with how many try flooding them with very hard to verify, false information from misleading sources. On our network, our plan moving forward is to allow our users to verify their identity privately with the platform to earn an "ID Verified" badge while still maintaining an anonymous public pseudonym if they choose. The idea being that others can trust the user is a real person and not some troll (paid or otherwise) while also allowing those that wish to have it to maintain anonymity publicly. Just to give some insight into how this anonymity becomes a problem. On our platform, I watch in real-time people / actors from outside the U.S. posing as seemingly real people in the United States and posting propaganda. Not the obviously false stuff either. Carefully crafted political BS that is meant to simply move the needle ever so slightly on the desired targets -- arguably a case where anonymity is negatively affecting democracy. There is so much to this I could probably write an entire blog on it, it's ever irritating as someone running a platform but also quite interesting.
- bryan_w 5y agoI've seen the same on various other forums and have been surprised/impressed how far their operations have improved over the years.
- ACow_Adonis 5y agoon the flipside, like with my Facebook account, i hold and use it purely so that i can control what other people say about me and so i can stop them tagging me in photos, and i can track what information the network has on me. but I'm never going to engage on the site, and I'm sure as hell never going to speak or share my true opinions on there or ever link them to my true name. here on hacker news i try to politely limit myself to certain topics and positions. in my country (Australia), there's some irony that i think our biggest problem with "foreign influence" isn't Russian or Chinese troll accounts, but genuine American accounts, media and American social media companies talking absolute crap and spreading the general phenomenon and quality of American politics worldwide. anonymity and Russian trolls aren't the problem when your mainstream spread so much FUD worldwide and largely serves the same purpose as those trolls but in a "legitimate" form. American media has far more reach, both in absolute power, influence and damage, than any subtle espionage agent or internet troll, and its personalities and commenters are happy to use their real names because their medium of influence is "legitimate" and they're commercially/socially rewarded for doing so. It seems, given the state of things, that the obsession with "Russian trolls and foreign actors" is prima facie absurd, and the limited influence they actually have compared to the elimination of sane discussion or valid analysis and criticism that will similarly be removed if forced to link back to real identification is something that should be considered in any cost benefit, as well as their relative effect compared to the bullshit consumerism/ partisanship/culture-war/ racist/religious/lobbyists/violent material that's seen as somehow "legitimate".
- beebmam 5y agoI miss people being decent to each other. I'd be good with experimenting with removing anonymity in certain contexts to see how different online spaces can be. I genuinely think it would lead to some interesting (and unexpected) results.
- merpnderp 5y agoIt will never work. While your online words aren't ephemeral, the context is. So 10 years from now your rational, heart felt, and good intentioned argument will be used to show what a horrible person you are, simply because the context is gone. It would be perfectly fine to get rid of anonymity (in some situations) if those words weren't there forever to haunt you.
- beebeepka 5y agoYou don't even need to wait 10 days, let one years. He who controls the media, controls the narrative. Also "Give me six lines written by the most honest man, and I will find something in them which will hang him." And so on. I'd bet some animals do this kind of shit to each to each other. We humans are not the only assholes.
- seoulmetro 5y agoPeople are already decent to each other. The problem is that your definition of decent is becoming warped. It would just lead to anyone with an idea they're not sure is agreed upon already not being able to voice that idea. Scary world.
- onychomys 5y agoOne of the lessons of facebook comment sections is that people are totally willing to say absolutely vile things to one another under their own names and photos.
- Pyramus 5y agoThat's a logical fallacy - just because people exist that are non-anonymous and vile doesn't invalidate parent's point. The question is whether non-anonymity might lead to less vileness and I agree it's certainly worth trying.
- PontifexMinimus 5y agoYes, that's why governments want to do it.
- 1cvmask 5y ago[flagged]
- self_buddliea 5y agoIf they pass this legislation, my bottom will lose its precious anonymity.
- mmastrac 5y agoFacebook clearly demonstrated that people will say terrible things under their own name.
- LatteLazy 5y agoThis is the same government that have been about to ban pornography for 5+ years. They're going to do nothing. They just want a different subject to discuss since right now the UK has shortages of everything from natural gas and electricity to doctors to computer chips to kids toys.
- olivermarks 5y agoIt's not hard to get a fake id. It's not hard to spoof being someone else. It's not hard for criminals to get hold of weapons. Given that your every move and utterance is tracked and logged online and geo by countless entities your @penpal name is a pretty trivial detail anyway...
- Zigurd 5y agoBanning anonymity by law is bad, but it is a valid choice for platforms. Some people like to go to Disney World, some like to go to New Orleans.
- spywaregorilla 5y agoI see three issues here: * Are you a real person or a bot / shill * Are others able to know who you are when you post things * Are you able to support others' opinions without any personal stake And I think the answer to all of them is that it depends on scale, although I don't see any particular reason to believe (1) isn't always preferred.
- Ekaros 5y agoI wonder if we should extend this to real world. Ban anonymity there too maybe make it mandatory to have name and serial number tattooed to forehead and make it illegal to cover it.
- 4AoZqrH2fsk5UB 5y agoThomas Paine published common sense anonymously. I think there needs to be a way to publish anonymously where the people are.