3 ms·
> I’m sorry, but perhaps I’m the only person who believes Facebook should just follow the laws and that’s it. No, you are far from alone. The problem with that
by sofixa 5y ago
> I’m sorry, but perhaps I’m the only person who believes Facebook should just follow the laws and that’s it.
No, you are far from alone. The problem with that viewpoint is that IMHO it's far too naive and assumes good intentions. The metric shittons of mis and disinformation that have been spread on platforms such as Facebook, with real world consequences ( be it genocides, very questionable people getting popular and elected, or outright batshit insane conspiracy theories with real life people dying because of them), show that it just doesn't work.
There's some margin between the wild west being exploited to spread and amplify dangerous false information, and burning anyone who disagrees with anything.
- zionic 5y ago> dangerous false information I have zero faith in some faceless megacorp deciding for me what is and is not “dangerous misinformation”. Your argument is essentially stating that people are cattle and require benevolent dictators filtering their media consumption for their own benefit.
- 2pEXgD0fZ5cF 5y ago> I have zero faith in some faceless megacorp deciding for me They are already deciding way more for you than just what is "dangerous misinformation".
- sofixa 5y agoNope, my argument is that too many people are having a hard time separating emotions and facts, and Facebook amplifies and makes this worse. They aren't a good arbiter of truth, but they are a terrible amplifier of falsehoods as well.
- lettergram 5y agoI turn on cnn every day and have seen more disinformation than I can discuss here. Just look at the “horse paste” story with Joe Rogan or the “Russian disinformation” hunter Biden laptop. You do realize YouTube promotes that content? “Disinformation” is a Marxist / Soviet / Maoist term used to discredit the truth that hurts them. There may be legitimate “disinformation”, but who determines that? That’s why we have free speech, the US entrusted people to decide. Generally, people can, what’s currently being censored are often not lies.
- sofixa 5y agoPlease don't whatabout this. Unless CNN also amplify genocidal speech, those are really not the same. And as the GP said, Facebook is kind of a town square - you don't agree with CNN, you don't watch it. Many people need to use Facebook to interact with family, friends, community. > Generally, people can, what’s currently being censored are often not lies Really? Covid being a hoax, Pizzagate, QAnon, Earth being flat, the horse paste / HCQ debacles, etc. There were QAnon related protests in Germany. If people were capable of deciding, how is that possible?
- lettergram 5y ago> Unless CNN also amplify genocidal speech That would be against the law if it was directed, no? Also, QAnon actually promoted “doing nothing and waiting” it wasn’t genocidal at all. CNN, MANBC and the like have been demonizing half the US for years. Some people on their programs have called for re-education camps — https://twitter.com/tomselliott/status/1348974982483894276 https://twitter.com/tomselliott/status/1348974982483894276 Other programs blame the “unvaccinated” for getting the “vaccinated” sick, etc. this is all pretty bad.. Regardless, the following statement from yourself, is why it’s the town square: > Many people need to use Facebook to interact with family, friends, community. If you’re compelled to use it and it’s the only way to interact, it has become the town square.
- 287324234234 5y ago> blame the “unvaccinated” for getting the “vaccinated” sick This is accurate though.