3 ms·
There's arguments over whether the CDC was politicized under Trump [1]. It's possible this was career bureaucracy failures of course and the Biden administratio
by vlovich123 5y ago
There's arguments over whether the CDC was politicized under Trump [1]. It's possible this was career bureaucracy failures of course and the Biden administration is just trying to whitewash that failure by blaming the previous administration. For me however, the fact that right wing politicians appear to consistently exert pressure on scientific agencies [2] to toe the party line gives me a prior that scientific agencies under right wing governments are less trustworthy because they are subject to undue influence.
[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/jackbrewster/2021/01/24/cdc-director-agency-was-muzzled-under-trump/?sh=21d8fc606fed https://www.forbes.com/sites/jackbrewster/2021/01/24/cdc-dir...
[2] This is based on my observations of Canada and the USA where "politically sensitive" topics like global warming, reproductive rights, & gun rights (in the USA) are decidedly marked by publication and public speaking bans on the parts of scientists. These kinds of actions generally do not appear to be present under left-leaning administrations which seem to tolerate dissenting opinions and politically inconvenient statements/papers better. This does not necessarily imply a similar action for something like the CDC/pandemic, but I worry there may be unofficial indirect signalling effects from scientists observing what happens if you cross the current political power base.
- pdonis 5y ago> There's arguments over whether the CDC was politicized under Trump As far as I can tell, Trump had little if anything to do with public pronouncements by health officials about mask wearing. He did tend to discount mask effectiveness in his tweets and random public statements, but I think it's pretty well established that no government health officials gave any weight to his statements about that, or about anything else for that matter. I would agree that the Federal government's failure to take obvious steps like using eminent domain power to ensure adequate supplies of PPE to health care workers was Trump's failure while he was President, since the President is the one who has the final say on the Federal government's eminent domain power.
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoBoth Fauci and Birx have stated that they had to moderate their language while speaking under Trump because they didn't want to anger him or be banished from giving information to the public.
- pdonis 5y ago> It's possible this was career bureaucracy failures The mindset of public health officials where they are willing to prevaricate with the public because of some claimed concern like "there won't be enough PPE for health care workers", instead of just recommending to the President to use the authority the government already has to address such concerns, goes back decades, so it cannot be blamed on any particular administration or political party. I think it's just part of a general tendency on the part of all governments to become less efficient and more protective of their power over time.
- pdonis 5y ago> left-leaning administrations which seem to tolerate dissenting opinions and politically inconvenient statements/papers better I don't know where you're getting that from. Both parties in the US consistently politicize science. The only reason it seems to be more prevalent when Republicans are in office is that the US media reports on the two parties very differently, so there's a huge selection bias in what is made visible to the average person.
- vlovich123 5y agoI don't think this is a "both sides" issue or biased media coverage (& note I specifically said Canada and USA because I am making observations about both countries and they have extremely different media profiles). I'm not talking about general low-level politicization (although I still think the right generally wins here). I'm talking about expressly restricting the kinds of topics scientists are allowed to speak about with media, the conclusions of the research being altered by political appointees, etc. Please feel free to present counter examples. The Canadian right wing was specifically trying to help the Albertan government which is heavily dependent on oil (but in general the right seems to hogtie themselves to the oil and gas industry generally). Contemporary news reports: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2012/jul/09/canada-stephen-harper-revolt-scientists https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2012/jul/09/canada-s... https://www.policyalternatives.ca/publications/monitor/harper-governments-war-science https://www.policyalternatives.ca/publications/monitor/harpe... https://www.straight.com/news/385761/canadian-war-science-long-unexaggerated-devastating-chronological-indictment https://www.straight.com/news/385761/canadian-war-science-lo... News reports after the fact (note that the National Post is the equivalent of Fox News in Canada): https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/canadian-scientists-open-about-how-their-government-silenced-science-180961942/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/canadian-scien... https://www.cbc.ca/news/health/second-opinion-scientists-muzzled-1.4588913 https://www.cbc.ca/news/health/second-opinion-scientists-muz... https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/canadian-scientists-were-followed-threatened-and-censored-by-harper-staff-they-warn-that-president-trump-could-do-the-same https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/canadian-scientists-wer... The Bush administration doing the same thing: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/rewriting-the-science/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/rewriting-the-science/ Here's the follow-up government report acknowledging it happened: https://archive.md/SJk1v https://archive.md/SJk1v That it absolved NASA leadership and the administration itself is questionable (kind of a "we investigated ourselves and found that we didn't do anything wrong" kind of thing). The oversight powers of IGs in the US are laughable so I generally trust their conclusions less (right or left). If you fill the public affairs office full of your lackeys and let them run amok, then you can claim ignorance and the investigator can't really conclude you directly directed any action.