4 ms·
I think the bigger offense with the displays isn't the ads (the subway is already plastered with them, and the new screens will pay for themselves in that manne
by woodruffw 5y ago
I think the bigger offense with the displays isn't the ads (the subway is already plastered with them, and the new screens will pay for themselves in that manner) but how remarkably crappy the panels are.
I have corrective lenses that give me normal vision, and I have to really squint to make out station names and bullets on the digitized system maps that the panels display. I feel terrible for anyone whose vision is even slightly worse than mine, much less tourists who have enough trouble with the printed maps.
- afavour 5y agoI have fine vision and the maps are still terrible for me. If I get close I can see that the text labels for the stations are barely legible because the panel resolution is so poor. If only it were feasible to install high DPI eink panels instead. But then those ads wouldn’t be anywhere near as attention grabbing, would they?
- JulianWasTaken 5y agoThere was a post I can't find at the minute by someone whose core point was "digital displays aren't always better than paper maps MTA, the displays are really hard to read and much lower resolution". It was a good design article to my recollection, but yeah I can't find it unfortunately. But: > I think the bigger offense with the displays isn't the ads (the subway is already plastered with them, and the new screens will pay for themselves in that manner) Of course seeing ads isn't new -- the point is the displays were put in at least partially to serve as station info. c.f. https://new.mta.info/accessibility/stationlab/CICs https://new.mta.info/accessibility/stationlab/CICs In my experience, they literally do not function that way, they don't give information in a timely manner such that you can decide whether to wait or not without standing there waiting till it finally shifts to the screen with service info, which can take minutes. But maybe we can agree both are big issues :) -- the map thing is certainly something I sympathize with -- all in all, I think the displays are a failure other than for making ad revenue, so we the transiters have lost again.