4 ms·
I’m a pretty pro-criminal justice reform guy, but most folks in that camp really don’t understand how very guilty most people in prison are. From first hand exp
by rayiner 5y ago
I’m a pretty pro-criminal justice reform guy, but most folks in that camp really don’t understand how very guilty most people in prison are. From first hand experience, the system is already inundated with meritless litigation, appeals, etc. People in person don’t exactly have a lot of better things to do. Innocence Project and similar organizations have to screen hundreds of cases to find the one or two meritorious ones. Ending prosecutorial immunity would mean 99 completely frivolous lawsuits for every one worth considering.
- brazzy 5y agoWhat alternative solution do you propose? Because leaving things as they are is clearly worse than the scenario you describe, especially since those hypotheyical 99 frivolous lawsuits could be dismissed with very little effort. Police do not have this immunity and yet somehow they can do their job without being paralyzed by frivolous lawsuits.
- rainworld 5y agohave to screen hundreds of cases to find the one or two meritorious ones And even then, legal merit, long after conviction, brought forward by a team of highly motivated activists, against an indifferent (or often enough even sympathetic) legal system does not equate innocence. Peculiarities of the American legal system and political pressures exacerbate this.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoIt's also a matter of what you can prove. If you find DNA evidence or a video recording to exonerate you, that's great. But if you're in prison because a cop planted drugs on you, there is no DNA evidence. There may not be a video recording of the events. How can you prove your innocence? Sometimes you can't, even when you are.
- aaomidi 5y agoPeople who are pro criminal justice reform understand people are guilty. But they're trying to solve the actual systemic issues that lead to crime, not just say crime doesn't happen. Excessive policing, not spending money on social services, etc etc are all making it worse. https://ips-dc.org/three-felonies-day/ https://ips-dc.org/three-felonies-day/ So yeah, we've over criminalized shit and we're spending money on mercs instead of investing in society.
- rayiner 5y agoPolicing doesn’t cause crime and any more than umbrellas cause rain. Systemic issues exist but those issues are more about circumstances that produce criminals (breakdown of family structures, etc.) not policing.
- aaomidi 5y agoDo you really think the comparison of umbrellas in the face of rain and police in the face of crime is logical?
- rayiner 5y agoYes absolutely—people buy umbrellas because of rain, and voters employ police because of crime. It’s a logical error to infer that the presence of umbrellas causes rain, or that the presence of police causes crime.
- policecrimehypo 5y agoIn this metaphor, rain that doesn't happen to land on an umbrella just isn't observed. The presence of police increases crime statistics, because some marginally illegal activity that happens all the time and is mostly unenforced would be acted on.
- rayiner 5y agoPolice cost money. Cities don’t deploy them to places unless significant criminal activity causes demand for a police presence.
- dredmorbius 5y agoProsecuting the wrong person for a crime means the criminal is still at large. And that justice has not been served. Abusing the police and courts to serve some ends other than justice ... is not justice.
- danShumway 5y ago> Innocence Project and similar organizations have to screen hundreds of cases to find the one or two meritorious ones. Ending prosecutorial immunity would mean 99 completely frivolous lawsuits for every one worth considering. This is interesting phrasing. It was an often-repeated statement during American history that, "it's better 100 guilty people should escape than that one innocent person should suffer." Prosecutorial immunity removes State consequences for violating citizen rights. Lawsuits against the officers/prosecutors/states are some of the lowest consequences we could impose; as another commenter has mentioned often they just result in the State paying out money and little to no individual consequences for bad actors. But even that is at least some discouragement against violating Constitutional rights. John Adams commented on this by saying, "It is of more importance to the community that innocence should be protected, than it is, that guilt should be punished; for guilt and crimes are so frequent in this world, that all of them cannot be punished....when innocence itself, is brought to the bar and condemned, especially to die, the subject will exclaim, 'it is immaterial to me whether I behave well or ill, for virtue itself is no security.' And if such a sentiment as this were to take hold in the mind of the subject that would be the end of all security whatsoever." He argued that without strong protections from the State for people's rights, that people would stop depending on or trusting the State to secure their rights, and that society would start to slip into extralegal chaos. Citizens would stop looking to the law as a protective force, and instead consider it to be something to avoid and subvert since "virtue itself is no security." This is a particularly prescient idea today. We tell people to trust the legal system to protect their rights. But prosecutorial immunity undermines that message, because people see that their rights can be violated by the State itself and they will have no legal recourse to fix the situation. When they see that, we run the risk of making them disregard the entire legal system. Why cooperate with the State at all in any capacity; why trust the process when the process doesn't hold itself accountable to its own standards? We live in a system with double standards, where citizens can be prosecuted, penalized, and even jailed for lying to the police or the FBI under extremely broad criteria, but where prosecutors and the State suffer no personal penalty for withholding evidence from the defense during a trial. How much damage does this do to our institutions? How can we possibly hope to convince ordinary people that an institution with those standards is trustworthy?
- 5y ago
- giantg2 5y agoLiterally, 2-10% of the incarcerated are fully innocent. If those 99 are truly frivolous, than a petition to dismiss to or request for summary judgement should have them thrown out based on a lack of evidence/standing.
- FpUser 5y ago>"Ending prosecutorial immunity would mean 99 completely frivolous lawsuits for every one worth considering." We are a nation of laws. NOT.