3 ms·
Maybe Emetrol is placebo, but it has worked for me in the past on a couple of occasions. This included 8 hours of vomiting no mater how hard I willed it to stop
by giantg2 5y ago
Maybe Emetrol is placebo, but it has worked for me in the past on a couple of occasions. This included 8 hours of vomiting no mater how hard I willed it to stop or other remedies I tried, and it didn't work on the first dose. It didn't seem like placebo to me, but I am grateful it worked either way.
One thing to note that isn't in the article, is that concentration can matter, so comparing one can to a 30ml dose of medication might not be a great comparison (although this still supports for the author's position that phosphoric acid is not added to cola to prevent vomiting).
Is the placebo effect applicable in infants? I would think that infants would not be capable of the understanding that something will make them better, and thus placebo wouldn't apply to them. Unfortunately this paper is pay-walled so we dont have details about the methods used, but the summary seems relevant.
https://www.jpeds.com/article/S0022-3476(51)80084-2/pdf https://www.jpeds.com/article/S0022-3476(51)80084-2/pdf
- silviot 5y agoApparently placebo works even with dogs: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19912522/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19912522/ Given that I would not find surprising if it worked for infants too
- giantg2 5y agoThat's interesting. Yeah, I couldn't find anything about it for infants. I wouldn't put too much stock in this study you linked. It's a meta analysis of other studies. These other studies were not designed to test placebo effect. The P value also seems quite large to me (.17). Seems to me like any benefit may have been the conventional drugs they were on... "In each study, the treatment group received the experimental therapeutic intervention in addition to conventional antiepileptic drug treatment, and the control group received a matching placebo in addition to conventional antiepileptic drug treatment."
- ushakov 5y ago> Unfortunately this paper is pay-walled not when you use sci-hub https://sci.bban.top/pdf/10.1016/s0022-3476%252851%252980084-2.pdf?download=true https://sci.bban.top/pdf/10.1016/s0022-3476%252851%252980084...
- jrmg 5y agoThis included 8 hours of vomiting no mater how hard I willed it to stop or other remedies I tried, and it didn't work on the first dose It seems very plausible that after 8 hours vomiting would stop without intervention.
- giantg2 5y agoWhy? One could say that about any duration, right?
- jrmg 5y agoTotally. And it would be more probable as time goes on, since you couldn’t really go on vomiting for ever (unless the illness was way more serious!) 8 hours seems pretty ‘normal’ from the few times I’ve been ill like this though - would basically feel like ‘most of a day’ or ‘most of a night’.
- giantg2 5y agoI think we are thinking of different things. Continuously vomiting every 5-15 minutes for 8 hours to the point of just green bile coming up is pretty serious (dehydration is a huge concern), in my opinion. This sort of vomiting seems to be an uncontrollable involuntary response.
- daveguy 5y agoYes. You would have to have a placebo controlled test to confirm placebo vs "just happens to last 8 hours". This is what placebo controls are for.
- giantg2 5y agoI generally agree. The secondary (and more interesting) question is whether placebo effect is applicable to infants. Based on the theory of how placebo works, it seems it might not be. It seems there are no studies on that. At least I couldn't find any.