3 ms·
I dislike AGPL for 2 reasons. 1. Every major free software license I can think of before AGPL triggered its source provisions on distribution. (I said "major"
by tzs 5y ago
I dislike AGPL for 2 reasons.
1. Every major free software license I can think of before AGPL triggered its source provisions on distribution. (I said "major" because I haven't examined every free software license, but I don't actually know of any that weren't triggered solely by distribution).
Placing conditions in your license on what you did with the software other than distributing it were usually considered to make your license a non-free license.
2. I can't think of a principled way to justify AGPL's triggering specifically on "remote interaction through a computer network".
Say I take a weather model program that is under AGPL, modify it to work better for forecasting weather in my region, and start a service to provide local forecasts. Users provide their address, and for a fee I provide them with a local forecast for that location.
There are several different ways I might offer this service.
A. They can stop by my kiosk in the mall, where I have several PCs running the model. They can enter their information on one of the PCs and it prints their forecast on a printer connected directly to the PC.
B. They can send me a mail via the post office asking for a forecast. I mail one back via the post office.
C. They can send me an email asking for a forecast. I email one back.
D. Same as A, except the printer is not connected directly to the PC. It is connected via a WiFi network.
E. I have one PC in the kiosk, with several terminals connected to it via WiFi. The customers use the terminals.
F. Similar to E, but I have the terminals spread out at several convenient locations throughout the mall, all communicating via WiFi with the PC running the model.
G. The PC serves a web page via a public WiFi network I offer in the mall. This network has no internet connectivity.
H. The PC serves a web page over the internet, but you have to be at the kiosk to actually order and receive a forecast.
I. The PC serves a web page over the internet, on which you can order and receive you forecast from anywhere.
J. The call me on the phone, give me their address, and I read the results to them. This is really 3 cases. J1, they and I are using modern cell phones. J2, they and I are using modern land lines. J3, we are both in an area with a very old all analog phone system (so while the phone system may be a network, it is not a "computer network").
Under AGPL I definitely have to provide source for case I.
It is not clear for cases C, D, E, F, G, H, or J. They all raise questions of what is an interaction, what is remote, what is a computer, what is a network, and what is a computer network.
I do not have to provide source in cases A and B.
In all cases the same overall thing is being accomplished: people ask for a forecast using the modified AGPL program running on my computer, the program runs, and the output is given to the person.
I find it aesthetically displeasing and philosophically ridiculous to have a license depend so much on the minutia of exactly how the information between the user and the program is transmitted.
- pabs3 5y agoFTR AGPL source provisions are triggered on modification, not on interaction with the software.
- tzs 5y agoAGPLv3 contains two kinds of source provision. 1. It contains all the source provisions of GPLv3, which are triggered on distribution (both of modified and unmodified versions). 2. A provision that is not in GPLv3 that is triggered on users interacting remotely through a computer network with modified versions. This is section 13 of AGPLv3: > 13. Remote Network Interaction; Use with the GNU General Public License. > Notwithstanding any other provision of this License, if you modify the Program, your modified version must prominently offer all users interacting with it remotely through a computer network (if your version supports such interaction) an opportunity to receive the Corresponding Source of your version by providing access to the Corresponding Source from a network server at no charge, through some standard or customary means of facilitating copying of software. This Corresponding Source shall include the Corresponding Source for any work covered by version 3 of the GNU General Public License that is incorporated pursuant to the following paragraph. > Notwithstanding any other provision of this License, you have permission to link or combine any covered work with a work licensed under version 3 of the GNU General Public License into a single combined work, and to convey the resulting work. The terms of this License will continue to apply to the part which is the covered work, but the work with which it is combined will remain governed by version 3 of the GNU General Public License.
- pabs3 5y agoThe trigger is "if you modify the Program".