3 ms·
I've been using a ThinkPad X1-Carbon that came with Linux pre-installed straight from Lenovo, and I've really had no major issues with it. If someone's looking
by shadowgovt 5y ago
I've been using a ThinkPad X1-Carbon that came with Linux pre-installed straight from Lenovo, and I've really had no major issues with it. If someone's looking for a solid Linux laptop experience, that's where I'd steer them these days.
Author appears to be complaining (among many other things) that attempting to retrofit machines that came pre-installed with Windows to run GNU/Linux doesn't work well, and... It never has. Not once. I can name zero experiences in my lifetime doing that where it was relatively painless. I perceive this to be not a "machines aren't flexible" problem, but a "machines come out of the factory with ten thousand complex configurations tuned to work correctly with each other, and when you rip out a piece as large as 'the operating system,' half those configurations are now tuned wrong (and the OS was holding another half of them)" problem.
On this ThinkPad, the only time I've run into issues is when I switched out the window manager. Turns out, the WM's configuration is implicitly tied to a half-dozen features (audio selection power management, etc.) that don't "just keep working" if you replace it. Should I be blaming Ubuntu for that, or should I accept that some pieces of the OS are big enough to be disruptive if you swap them out?
Nobody is optimizing for the "get some hardware and retrofit an entirely new OS into it" use case; that way will forever be a gravel-strewn road. If you want a smooth road, get the OS you want from the factory.
- mythrwy 5y agoI haven't had any issues installing Ubuntu based Linux on Thinkpads that came with Windows and I've been doing it for over a decade. Maybe the fingerprint scanners didn't work, I never tried those. But otherwise seamless near as I can tell. Granted it's mostly older Thinkpads but still. 0 problems.
- zibzab 5y agoThe fingerprint scanner almost never work in Windows either. A recent win10 update for some reason removed fingerprint drivers for me and I didn't even notice it.
- kiwijamo 5y agoI bought a ThinkPad X1 that came with Windows. Had no trouble changing that to a dual boot arrangement with Debian. Kept that for a few months until I realized I was going weeks without booting into Windows. Ended up making the switch to a full Arch Linux installation with no Windows. Has worked well. I have a fingerprint scanner but haven't bothered with it—that worked poorly under Windows anyway so never used even under Windows.
- shadowgovt 5y agoThe most common problem I run into is power management. About 50% of the laptops I've installed Ubuntu on that were originally configured for Windows will correctly sleep or suspend when the lid is closed. Of the distros I've used, Ubuntu is the one that works most reliably if I throw it on random PCs.
- symlinkk 5y agoExactly. Would you install macOS on a Lenovo and expect it to work? No? Then why are you doing the same with Linux? Buy hardware that your software supports.
- bluedays 5y agoYes, I’ve done it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- southerntofu 5y ago> Buy hardware that your software supports That was the author's point. Hardware manufacturers should sell hardware and provide detailed specs. If they're not providing specs, they're failing their mission and just releasing crappy binary drivers for Windows which may or may not work in the future, and require reverse engineering for other systems to support. Just respect standards and/or publish your datasheets. That should be a requirement to sell any kind of hardware. I can't believe it's legal for a company to sell a washing machine without schematics, even less so an entire computer! If the hardware manufacturers don't publish docs/schematics, then systems can't support the hardware and we end up in this special hell-hole that IT hardware industry has been stuck in for about two decades now.
- mmu_man 5y agoAh, thanks so much! I was under the impression nobody got my point. Maybe because it was written under stress and emotion, or it's missing some arguments, I don't know.
- southerntofu 5y agoThank you so much for writing it. I could feel your pain, and it was really liberating for me to read it. Often i feel very disconnected from people's seemingly pleasant experiences with modern hardware, it's always reassuring to read other people's detailed thoughts and feelings about why everything is wrong and broken.
- kovac 5y agoJust a few days ago I installed Arch Linux on a ThinkPad P15 Gen 1 with X Server and i3wm for wm, disk encryption, multiple displays and it works very well. Heck, even the touch screen is working OOB without any special configuration. I've always been installing Arch Linux on ThinkPads that came with Windows pre installed. There are minor issues at times with backlight control or sound system which is mostly due to my minimal setup but overall I don't feel that ThinkPads don't play well with Linux.
- pimeys 5y agoRunning NixOS unstable on a ThinkPad X1 Carbon 7th gen. Sway tiling wm, Wayland, fractional scaling, damn long battery life, hardware acceleration on Firefox, fingerprint reader all work 100%. I'm surprised how good this is, and I've been using ThinkPads for a long time. This model works way better even compared to the mighty X230 I still love and adore as a great product from the past. Config: https://github.com/pimeys/nixos https://github.com/pimeys/nixos
- guerrilla 5y ago> GNU/Linux doesn't work well, and... It never has. Not once. Those from the past didn't fall under a Linux certification program though. That seems to be a main point of the rant: > And you take risks too. When you sell “certified” ThinkPads with Linux, do you understand you are actually certifying that this machine will run correctly with drivers written by people who had to guess how the hardware should be used because vendors like you didn’t properly document it in the first place? Isn’t this mind-boggling?
- shadowgovt 5y agoAre the ones that come out of the factory with Windows pre-installed also certified? I'm unclear on that aspect.
- guerrilla 5y agoI'm not sure, it seems like only a certain series is certified and some on that series do come with Windows.
- vladvasiliu 5y ago> Author appears to be complaining (among many other things) that attempting to retrofit machines that came pre-installed with Windows to run GNU/Linux doesn't work well, and... It never has. Not once. I can name zero experiences in my lifetime doing that where it was relatively painless. As usual, YMMV, but I've been running Linux with almost no issues on an HP ProBook. The only thing that doesn't work is the fingerprint reader. Bluetooth, custom secure boot keys, Wi-Fi, great battery life [0], sleep, hibernation, etc. worked without any fiddling on Arch Linux. As far as I know HP doesn't offer these computers with Linux. I'm not even sure you can get them without Windows. --- [0] Great as in "comparable to what Windows gets on the same hardware".
- einpoklum 5y agoIt was painless for me on an X201. True, I never got the resolution switch function keys to work properly, but an Lubuntu installation went just fine (my first one was in 2015 IIANM).
- yuuu 5y agoSo this is a little funny, but I just got my Thinkpad X1 Carbon a few days ago with Fedora preinstalled. I booted it up to the Fedora installation, then the machine rebooted. After it rebooted, a Windows loading screen appeared, followed by a pop-up DOS prompt that entered some commands, followed by another reboot into the Fedora installation. I haven't seen any evidence of Windows since, but that creeped me out. Can anyone explain what was going on, there? Also, of course, I had to completely wipe the hard drive and install my own version of Fedora to be totally comfortable after that.