4 ms·
When can we send the leadership to federal prison instead of slapping them on the wrist with paltry fines? This has been used to inflate and extort advertising
by echelon 5y ago
When can we send the leadership to federal prison instead of slapping them on the wrist with paltry fines?
This has been used to inflate and extort advertising dollars. It has utterly trashed the web, gutted Mozilla, created a corporate tech monoculture controlled by platform giants, and led our social media engagement crisis.
Break up these companies and send the leaders that approved of this to jail.
- devnull3 5y ago> When can we send the leadership to federal prison Yeah, these companies make employees read & sign code-of-conduct, ethics etc. Hell, I was made to attend sessions explaining "values" of the company. The sheer hypocrisy ... only if execs walk the talk, the world would be a better place
- freen 5y agoWell, if Starcom and Omnicom actually represented their clients, they would both sue and file criminal charges for fraud. They don’t. So they won’t. I wonder, to what degree the big agencies are complicit? If I spent any dollars at all on ads on either Facebook or google I would be filing criminal charges.
- matt123456789 5y agoIsn’t this price fixing? That’s a criminal federal offense. The US Government would have to bring the criminal charges, although you (and likely the FTC) could bring charges for damages.
- csee 5y agoYep, jail sentences. Fines are good but don't work that well, even if they're large, because of agency conflict of interest. It's mostly the shareholders who are paying the price. The execs already saw their call option paid off with their 10 years of comp while they were running this scam (among others).
- sokoloff 5y agoThe shareholders reaped a lot of benefit along the way. It doesn’t seem outrageous to have the company (the shareholders in aggregate) pay fines related to the behavior.
- csee 5y agoThat's part of the reason why I said fines were good. They're good both because it recovers some of the ill-gotten gains of shareholders (your point), but also because it incentives better governance. But due to agency problems, jail should be also be added on top for the most egregious violations. As an example, the HSBC execs that banked cartels should have gotten jail sentences.
- lazide 5y agoThe challenge historically was in making fines actually large enough to disincentivize doing it in the future. If G made $100 billion because of this, would the gov’t be successful in getting a $200 billion fine? What if they got $100 billion in revenue, but an additional $400 billion in market cap? Is a $800 billion fine doable? Historically, it seems like the answers to those are solid no’s, and after lawyers have argued it for a decade, the fines look more like $1 billion. Which skews things a lot.
- csee 5y agoSmall fines probably even help them in the long run since they tame popular anger. I'd almost prefer no fines (in contrast to small fines) so people can transparently see how unaccountable they are. Ideally we can get big fines, though.
- yawaworht1978 5y agoI agree, even a hefty personal financial fine which pushes people to the verge of bankruptcy will not impress these people. They will get a new high paying job eventually. The only adequate punishment is a long prison sentence and it would deter other people from doing the same. Btw, also send the "reports" IE management who enforces the project straight to prison with the bosses. Sounds radical, maybe, but all the other laissez-faire and self regulation approaches have not worked. A prison sentence also means not employable in the same salary segment ever again. These people hide behind large legal teams and always remind everyone about their large responsibilities. But when it comes to be responsible and liable to bad things, nothing much happens. Just prison, not like in china, where some executives have simply been executed.