5 ms·

If you want something more restricted then just use RSS. It’s not centralized like AMP.

• mavhc 5y ago
  How centralised is AMP in theory and in practise?
  • dmw_ng 5y ago
    Every client everywhere donates Referrer: logs to ampproject.org, which Google run. It's another centralized web log in disguise
    • jeffbee 5y ago
      So it's not centralized at all in other words? Because it's an open standard that anyone can implement, both client and server, right? 100% totally decentralized.
      • dmw_ng 5y ago
        AMP requires you load all JS assets from cdnproject.org, which is owned by Google. It is as centralized as it comes
        • jeffbee 5y ago
          AMP does not require any such thing. Anyone can implement the AMP cache, there are multiple existing AMP caches, and you can serve AMP without a cache, without in any way impairing the function of an AMP page. https://github.com/ampproject/amphtml/blob/main/docs/spec/amp-cache-guidelines.md https://github.com/ampproject/amphtml/blob/main/docs/spec/am...
          • dmw_ng 5y ago
            https://github.com/ampproject/amphtml/issues/27546 https://github.com/ampproject/amphtml/issues/27546 Perhaps I'm wrong, but my interpretation of this ticket is that Google's AMP validator currently does not validate self-hosted JS, which means no special handling ("acceleration") on their search results.
  • whalabi 5y ago
    4/9 of the technical steering committee are Google employees, and 3 others are from big tech platforms (Pinterest, Microsoft, Twitter) https://github.com/ampproject/meta-tsc/blob/master/README.md https://github.com/ampproject/meta-tsc/blob/master/README.md
• KaiserPro 5y ago
  RSS only gave/gives me a headline. Its fairly rare that the entire article is available via RSS. Also is doesn't help for dynamic search. The main situation I'm thinking of is I'm on moble searching for something thats hosted by a local news site. the AMP page generally loads in <2 seconds. The original page will take 5 megs of data, and ages to load.