6 ms·
Morality doesn't presuppose religion, faith or belief in the supernatural. The religious can be amoral and selfish, atheists can be moral and selfless.
by krapp 5y ago
Morality doesn't presuppose religion, faith or belief in the supernatural. The religious can be amoral and selfish, atheists can be moral and selfless.
- azth 5y agoYou can't have morality without religion, it's a senseless question to pose.
- nkmnz 5y agoYou can have religion without esotericism, mythicism and spirituality - then it’s called morality.
- azth 5y agoWithout an ultimate authority (God), it doesn't make sense.
- nkmnz 5y agoIt doesn’t make sense _to you_. You’re welcome.
- azth 5y agoNo, it's objective. See my reply here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28977485 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28977485
- nkmnz 5y agoThank God he staffed you with all the objectivity he had left after creating the objective universe so that you can enlighten us with such third grader logic.
- azth 5y agoGive me a moral basis on why we can't destroy Earth when at the end of the day, from an atheistic materialistic point of view, nothing matters since we're all "chemical scum". Suffering or pleasure, it doesn't matter one bit. This isn't controversial, this is what atheist heads and philosophers say because it's the only logical conclusion to arrive at from their world view: https://youtu.be/EqK_JPts26k?t=183 https://youtu.be/EqK_JPts26k?t=183
- nkmnz 5y agoIs it you or your God who thinks other people think of other people as „chemical scum“? What if that same God that allows you to think of other people as people who think of other people as „chemical scum“ also allows for subjective morality rather than your objective version of it? What if I told you God himself has sent me to bring you this very message? Would it confuse you?
- azth 5y agoI think you're not understanding the point. Stephen Hawking is on record for saying that humans are "a chemical scum on a moderately sized planet". From the atheistic materialistic point of view, that's the only logical conclusion to reach. If you're claiming that God sent you with a message, you're going to have to bring evidence, claiming is not enough.
- krapp 5y ago>If you're claiming that God sent you with a message, you're going to have to bring evidence, claiming is not enough. You're the one making that claim, you bring the evidence, since you ignored mine. You can start by proving, objectively, the existence of your God.
- azth 5y agoWe have our overwhelming evidence. Just a few very quick examples: * https://www.provingislam.com/proofs/fire-of-hijaz https://www.provingislam.com/proofs/fire-of-hijaz * https://www.provingislam.com/proofs/green-arabia https://www.provingislam.com/proofs/green-arabia * https://www.provingislam.com/proofs/bedouins-prophecy https://www.provingislam.com/proofs/bedouins-prophecy * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k3FmcWR1M-0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k3FmcWR1M-0 You diverted the discussion to prove the existence of God. The original discussion was that it is not possible to have objective morality without a Creator. That is fact as per the atheist figures and philosophers, so no need to argue that point.
- krapp 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secular_morality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secular_morality https://theconversation.com/religion-does-not-determine-your-morality-97895 https://theconversation.com/religion-does-not-determine-your... https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/homo-consumericus/201204/morality-exists-despite-religion https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/homo-consumericus/20...
- azth 5y agoIt's very straightforward to debunk the above: atheists don't believe in God. The implication is that everyone is "chemical scum", that there is no purpose to life, and that ultimately nothing matters. Therefore, it doesn't matter if we blow up the entire world, or make everyone suffer to please a handful of people, there are no consequences and nothing matters at the end of the day.
- recursiveturtle 5y agoThen I suppose we're lucky the entirety of secular history and also the natural world -- godless as it is -- has not played this Two Shell Monte.
- azth 5y ago[flagged]