3 ms·
> I could audit an election in the blockchain tomorrow. No, you could confirm that a set of electronic records was internally consistent. That is only a small
by acdha 5y ago
> I could audit an election in the blockchain tomorrow.
No, you could confirm that a set of electronic records was internally consistent. That is only a small part of an election audit: you'd also need to confirm that only eligible voters voted a single time each and that their vote was recorded the way they intended.
Needing a multitude of people is a security advantage of the current system: it means that any attempts at cheating need a ton of people, from both parties and the local government, to collude together because there's no way to automate changing thousands of paper ballots and the corresponding seals — the real world doesn't have an “UPDATE votes SET …” shortcut.
Contrast that with a blockchain system: when it's challenged, you're in one of two situations. If all you have are electronic records, you've just reinvented the Diebold scandals of the 2000s where you're trying to assess how much you can believe that a complex software system does not contain a bug or exploitable flaw because there's no solid proof. If you use voter-validated paper ballots, you do a standard hand recount — and you don't need a blockchain at all because the thing providing security is the robust well-tested paper balloting system.