4 ms·
Energy is lost in the process. Flexibility and utility are gained, in the form of a high-enegy-density (by both volume and mass) energy store with excellent s
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Energy is lost in the process.
Flexibility and utility are gained, in the form of a high-enegy-density (by both volume and mass) energy store with excellent storage capabilities, a widely-developed extant handling and utilisation infrastructure and knowledge, and, considering the capabilities, extremely positive safety and interactions properties: hydrocarbon fuels are non-explosive, non-toxic with incidental exposure, and do not erode metallic or polymer components of fuel and power systems.
Net energy loss is at least 40% of input (hydrolysis to produce hydrogen), as well as the energy cost of carbon capture (this varies by methods). For seawater-based carbon sourcing, net synthesis costs of about 50% are what I've seen (see my earlier long comment on sources and references).
For seawater extraction: "CO2 extraction from seawater using bipolar membrane electrodialysis", Matthew D. Eisaman et al is a 2011 paper discussing CO2 extraction via a "BPMED" (bipolar membrane electrodialysis) process. It delivers CO2 at 1.52 kWh/kg, vs. a value of 0.54 kWh/kg cited by Terry, though it's not clear on first reading if Terry performed actual experiments or used theoretical values.
http://talknicer.com/co2extraction.pdf http://talknicer.com/co2extraction.pdf
My recollection is that atmospheric extraction costs are 1.5--3x higher, though I'm uncertain of that precise figure.
Recovered energy through Carnot and Rankin-cycle engines is on the order of 20--40%. The round-trip energy recovery from input electricity to delivered motive power is about 10--20%. Those are inherent to the processes and cannot be improved on.
Note that electric generation itself converts only about 30--40% of input thermal energy (from a nuclear reactor in the US Navy's scenario). Again, this is an unavoidable energy loss given the physics of thermal-to-mechanical energy conversion
Military aircraft and marine vessels can make at best limited use of direct electrical power given limitations of batteries, extension cords, and transmission lines, particularly with regard to energy and power demands. Any fuel, even
- bobthepanda 5y agoAnd as far as flexibility goes, there are military bases in hostile territory with fuel demands far exceeding what the normal supply chain demands even if it were reliable.
- dredmorbius 5y agoLand-based synthesis strikes me as more problematic. There's a lot of gain in offsetting fuel use entirely (solar and wind generation, both of which see fairly extensive use). For a large established base there might be some benefit. But there's also the last-mile problem. Aircraft are effectively addressing the last-mile fuel delivery problem directly (by carrying it with them). They tend not to loiter long over the engagement area. Long-mission drones might be an exception to this. If sufficiently lightweighted and dedicated largely to surveillance, these could benefit by solar + battery electric power. Personnel risks would be low, and aircraft flight dynamics improve as scale is decreased (square-cube law of lift (square) vs. mass (cube) relation. This is the inverse of aerostats, which are more efficient at providing lift with size.
- bobthepanda 5y agoWhy would there be a last mile problem if you were directly generating on base for synthesis? Solar and wind have the issue of land usage, in that the large land requirements of renewables mean more land to secure. That and military bases do not have the luxury of being conveniently sited next to the best places for such things. It would hardly be the first environmental disaster happening on a military base. Even as recently as Iraq and Afghanistan: https://www.military.com/benefits/veteran-benefits/what-burn-pit-registry.html https://www.military.com/benefits/veteran-benefits/what-burn...
- voakbasda 5y agoI expect the military will be the among the first to deploy portable nuclear generation in containers. Then this process becomes an obvious win for these bases.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThat's been tried. Even in non-combat environments (McMurdo Station, Project Iceworm), proved nuclear power solutions (adaptations of naval reactors used successfully in submarines) have proved nonviable. The risks of a reactor in a live-fire zone are ... considerable.
- throwawaysea 5y agoSince you seem knowledgeable about this process - can it be miniaturized for personal production? I realize it is a net loss but storable high density energy is useful for various applications like off grid use or home generators. For example, people who need refrigerated insulin but live in remote areas (where they often get delayed fixes when a weather event disrupts utilities).
- dredmorbius 5y agoI've read and/or skimmed a few papers. I can point people to the literature, I don't claim to understand much of it well myself. That said: - The pilot projects are essentially small-scale deployments. The principles are being developed at what's effectively "personal scale", plus or minus. - I expect that there would probably be economies of scale in several regards, including in operations, maintenance, and training. - At small scale, if you want fuel, growing it may be the more robust and reliable option. This gets back to the fundamental problem that fuels require considerable energy inputs. For an off-grid site, a firewood-fueled stove, possibly driving a generator through some mechanism (turbine, steam engine) or a biomass-based oil (olive, corn, canola, algae, ...) or alcohol (via fermentation) production serving needs for which liquid fuels were absolutely essential might be more reliable. Keep in mind that a little over a century ago, the US was effectively biofuel powered, with a principle prime mover in the form of the horse. Horsefeed consumed roughly 20% of total US agricultural output at the time. When I first started looking into alternatives to a fossil-fuel based world, my assumption was that biomass would be a readily-viable substitute. In reality, there simply is not enough net primary production (plant growth) to reasonbly support present levels of human energy consumption, let alone projected growth through economic advancement and population increase through the 21st century. If humans are to live on biomass (as we once did), either standards of living, or population, or both, will have to decrease quite considerably. (This give rise to some of the more modest suggestions of a maximum viable long-term human population, ranging from about 500 million to 2 billion, suggested by some experts on the topic.) One of the prime positie attributes of hydrocarbon fuels, especially the slightly heavier grades (kerosene, diesel, fuel oil, etc.) is that they travel and store exceedingly well. So long as 1) a synfuel capability exists and 2) your off-grid site has some commerce with the outside world, trading for fuel would likely be your best bet.