3 ms·
The process described is not new, and has been explored in various forms for 59 years by institutions including Brookhaven National Laboratory, M.I.T., the US N
by dredmorbius 5y ago
The process described is not new, and has been explored in various forms for 59 years by institutions including Brookhaven National Laboratory, M.I.T., the US Naval Research Lab (USNRL), and Google (Alphabet)'s Project Foghorn, an X-project "moonshot" which was cancelled on economic considerations. That is the constant theme for this work, which I'll address after noting research.
Prospects are often announced as "new" and "novel", despite extensive prior science and technology. In numerous cases, this is true not only of press and news releases, but of articles themselves ... as if, say, an evolutionary biology paper failed to credit Darwin and Wallace's original work. Much research has been by or associated with the US Navy, which has a considerable fuel-related logistical problem, especially with its aircraft-carrier-based force-projection capacity and supply-chain vulnerability. Other military branches have similar concerns, though have additional challenges with prospects of in situ fuel synthesis. For all branches, the cost of fuel delivered to combat and operational theatres is many times, often orders of magnitude greater, than the domestic "price at the pump". Given energy and feedstocks, synthesis is absolutely a credible option.
The chemistry works and is proven. Scale, operations, maintenance, logistics, and costs appear to remain hurdles.
I researched this topic fairly extensively in 2014 following release of a number of papers and articles over earlier USNRL studies and reports.
Early history is covered in a history of synthetic fuels roughly 1944--1960, "The Early Days of Coal Research: Wartime Needs Spur Interest in Coal-to-Oil Processes":
http://web.archive.org/web/20120111183405/http://fossil.energy.gov/aboutus/history/syntheticfuels_history.html http://web.archive.org/web/20120111183405/http://fossil.ener...
1962 M. King Hubbert (peak-oil pioneer) mention as an alternative to petroleum fuel, using limestone and hydrolsis-generated hydrogen as feedstocks utilising nuclear power to create a non-carbon-neutral hydrocarbon synfuel: https://web.archive.org/web/20061030044204/www.hubbertpeak.com/hubbert/EnergyResources.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20061030044204/www.hubbertpeak.c...
Meyer Steinberg at Brookhaven picked up research based on Hubbert's suggestion:
Steinberg, M., and Beller, M., "Liquid Fuel Synthesis Using Nuclear Power in a Mobile Energy Depot System," Transactions of the American Nuclear Society, Vol. 8, pg 159, June 1965.
Steinberg, M. et. al., "Methanol as a Fuel in the Urban Energy Economy and Possible Source of Supply", BNL 17800, Brookhaven National Laboratory, April 1973.
Steinberg, M., and Dang, V.D., "Use of Controlled Thermonuclear Reactor Fusion Power for the Production of Synthetic Methanol Fuel from Air and Water", BNL 20016, Brookhaven National Laboratory, April 1975.
Steinberg, M., "Electrolytic Synthesis of Methanol from C02," United States Patent #3,959,059, May, 1976.
Steinberg, M., "Nuclear Power for the Production of Synthetic Fuels and Feedstocks," 11th International Energy Conversion Engineering Conference, American Institute of Chemical Engineering, New York, 1976.
Steinberg, M., "Combined Coal and Nuclear Plants for Power, Heat, and Synthetic Fuels," Transactions of the American Nuclear Society, Vol. 27, November, 1977.
Steinberg, M, Fillo, J.A., and Powell, J., "Synthetic Fuels and Fusion," Nuclear Engineering and Design. Vol. 63, No. 2, February, 1981.
Several Masters theses at M.I.T. listing Michael J. Driscoll as advisor also reported on the prospect, with at least three appearing in 1977, 1992, and 2012.
Robin Paul Bushore, "Synthetic Fuel Generation Capabilities of Nuclear Power Plants with Applications to Naval Ship Technology", 1977
https://calhoun.nps.edu/public/bitstream/handle/10945/18307/syntheticfuelgen00bush.pdf?sequence=1 https://calhoun.nps.edu/public/bitstream/handle/10945/18307/...
Kevin B. Terry, "Synthetic Fuels for Naval Applications Produced Using Shipboard Nuclear Power", 1995
https://archive.org/details/syntheticfuelsfo00terr https://archive.org/details/syntheticfuelsfo00terr
John Michael Galle-Bishop, "Nuclear Tanker Producing Liquid Fuels From Air and Water", 2011
http://dspace.mit.edu/handle/1721.1/76359 http://dspace.mit.edu/handle/1721.1/76359
Terry's thesis includes multiple citations of Meyer Steinberg. Sadly none of these appear to be generally available online, though some (and a few other papers) appear in Google Scholar. I've listed these above.
US NRL research ran from 2010--2013 (it may have continued though I've seen no further announcements). Conspicuously, Willauer cited no research prior to the 1990s IIRC, an exceedingly misleading practice.
"The Feasibility and Current Estimated Capital Costs of Producing Jet Fuel at Sea Using Carbon Dioxide and Hydrogen". Heather D. Willauer, Dennis R. Hardy, Frederick W. Williams. Navy Technology Center for Safety and Survivability, Chemistry Division. September 29, 2010. NRL/MRi6180--10-9300
https://web.archive.org/web/20131031050117/http://www.dtic.mil/get-tr-doc/pdf?AD=ADA539765 https://web.archive.org/web/20131031050117/http://www.dtic.m...
"Extraction of Carbon Dioxide from Seawater by an Electrochemical Acidification Cell Part I--Initial Feasibility Studies". Felice DiMascio, Heather D. Willauer, Dennis R. Hardy, M. Kathleen Lewis, Frederick W. Williams. Navy Technology Center for Safety and Survivability, Chemistry Division. July 23, 2010. NRL/MR/6180--10-9274
https://web.archive.org/web/20201031083322/https://apps.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a544002.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20201031083322/https://apps.dtic...
"Extraction of Carbon Dioxide from Seawater by an Electrochemical Acidification Cell Part II--Laboratory Scaling Studies eather D. Willauer". Heather D. Willauer, Felice DiMascio, Dennis R. Hardy, M. Kathleen Lewis, Frederick W. Williams. Navy Technology Center for Safety and Survivability, Chemistry Division. April 11, 2011. NRL/MR/6180--11-9329
https://web.archive.org/web/20140427044107/http://www.dtic.mil/get-tr-doc/pdf?AD=ADA565466 https://web.archive.org/web/20140427044107/http://www.dtic.m...
"Extraction of Carbon Dioxide and Hydrogen from Seawater by an Electrochemical Acidification Cell Part III: Scaled-up Mobile Unit Studies (Calendar Year 2011)". Heather D. Willauer, Dennis R. Hardy, Frederick W. Williams, Felice DiMascio. May 30, 2012. NRL/MR/6300--12-9414
https://web.archive.org/web/20140427044107/http://www.dtic.mil/get-tr-doc/pdf?AD=ADA565466 https://web.archive.org/web/20140427044107/http://www.dtic.m...
"Extraction of Carbon Dioxide and Hydrogen from Seawater by an Electrochemical Acidification Cell Part IV: Electrode Compartments of Cell Modified and Tested in Scaled-Up Mobile Unit". Heather D. Willauer, Dennis R. Hardy, Frederick W. Williams, Felice DiMascio. September 3, 2013. NRL/MR/6300--13-9463
https://web.archive.org/web/20140427001947/http://www.dtic.mil/get-tr-doc/pdf?AD=ADA589263 https://web.archive.org/web/20140427001947/http://www.dtic.m...
These references and some additional discussion are noted here:
https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/28nqoz/electrical_fuel_synthesis_from_seawater_older/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/28nqoz/electri...
And I've posted a number of additional items about related research which can be found through subreddit search:
https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/search?q=fischer-tropsch+seawater&restrict_sr=on https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/search?q=fischer-tropsc...
Project Foghorn is noted here: https://x.company/projects/foghorn/ https://x.company/projects/foghorn/
Again, the chemistry works, the economics do not. However that is due to a mis-pricing of fossil fuel resources that may well prove fatal to civilisation.
The principle problem with synfuel economics is that the process pays full energy costs of the actual creation of hydrocarbons. By contrast, petroleum and other fossil-fuel extraction supports present utilisation at millions of times the rate of initial formation. Whilst we often hear of carbon taxes and similar costs for the output consequences of this activity, economics is completely silent on the question of total resource input costs of hydrocarbons, which includes the time factor at a rate five million times current extraction. If I were to spend money at five million times my level of income ... I could live extravagently. For a short time. Geologically, this is precisely what the current fossil-fuel-powered economy has been doing for roughly 250 years. That gravy train will run out shortly (presuming we don't choke ourselves, or flood ourselves, or experience other as-yet-undetermined unanticipated consequences first).
An excellent analysis of the particulars of fossil fuel formation inputs (including also the very considerable biomass inputs) is Jeffrey S. Dukes, "Burning Buried Sunshine". I cannot recommend the PDF highly enough, despite its awkwardness on many mobile devices. There's a short HTML summary as well:
HTML summary: https://plus.maths.org/content/burning-buried-sunshine https://plus.maths.org/content/burning-buried-sunshine
Full PDF: https://www-legacy.dge.carnegiescience.edu/DGE/Dukes/Dukes_ClimChange1.pdf https://www-legacy.dge.carnegiescience.edu/DGE/Dukes/Dukes_C...
(I believe I've checked all URLs and swapped in archive links where necessary, please comment if any are still missing or are misdirected.)
- DrJones1098 5y agoVery cool. What are your thoughts on peak oil?
- dredmorbius 5y agoIt has occurred. Traditional (nonenhanced) extraction of liquid petroleum peaked in the early 2010s, largely as forecast. The peak was delayed a few years possibly due to both economic slowdowns and efficiency measures (the late 1990s Asian financial crisis, the post-9/11 crash, the 2007-12 global financial crisis), though China and India's meteoric growth compensated in the other direction. I'd have to dig into US DOE (EIA) and IEA data and charts, but enhanced and nontraditional recovery (deepwater drilling, which presents its own risks, fracking, heavy crudes as from Venezuela, and tar sands) have held up to demand, but at extreme cost and with huge impacts on prices and volatility. The industry itself is highly sensitive to both demand increases (surging prices and leading to political instability) and decreases (bankrupting extractors and their fianciers, and leading to financial instability). It's a tightrope walk. Swing producers (low-cost with excess capacity) such as KSA remain hugely influential globally, even for markets to which they do not ship directly. A tankerfull of oil can move across the globe for 1% of the realised energy capacity of that cargo. Oil markets remain global due to the commodity's extreme liquidity, in both physical and financial senses.
- nickthemagicman 5y agoInteresting. That sounds a little ominous. Are there projections that predict time frames with any precision until we finish the remaining supplies? Are we talking a century or a few decades?
- dredmorbius 5y agoThat's a hard question in large part because the specific timeframe depends on responses, reactions, and potential disruptive events. There's been a lot of ink and pixels spilled. Much of it comes from those wanting to deny the problem, those looking to sell you something, and those who poorly understand the problem. I hope I'm in the last camp and not the first two.... Economically, the most significant issue is that the marginal cost of oil under supply constraints varies greatly, and that's what has been seen in price history since 1973. You'll find a price history of oil dating to 1861 in BP's Annual Review of Energy, I'm looking at the 2021 report's graph on page 28. Those swings have increased in amplitude since, resulting from and leading to political, financial, and economic disruptions --- causality seemst to go in both directions. Remaining fossil fuel reserves will be increasingly expensive and difficult to extract. There will be "some" oil in the ground, in the same sense that after you've poured a beverage or eaten a tub of yoghurt, there is "some" food still left in the container, but 1) it's a finite amount and 2) you've got to work harder to get it. At some point it's simply not worth the effort. Total geological deposits, recoverable deposits, and the rate of effective extraction, all differ, though the latter two depend on the first. Those factors are insignificant, if we're lucky, next to the likelihood that further consumption of fossil fuels will be curtailed due to their output effects --- carbon emissions --- rather than supply limitations. Coal, oil, and gas that remain will have to be locked in the ground because we cannot afford the consequences of further use. Unfortunately, trends toward net zero carbon have greatly lagged what's necessary to avoid catastrophic consequences. Which in the absence of either resource exhaustion or effective regulation could possibly end large-scale global technological civilization reliance on fossil fuels.