3 ms·
> You can't verify that a particular ballot was ever cast, only that you have it now. You also can't verify that a ballot that was genuinely cast was cast by th
by acdha 5y ago
> You can't verify that a particular ballot was ever cast, only that you have it now. You also can't verify that a ballot that was genuinely cast was cast by the same person listed on the voter roll.
There’s only one part of this which isn’t wrong. You can verify that the ballots were given to registered voters at a particular polling station where they were sealed, transported securely, and tallied without the seals being broken – these days, all with video surveillance except for the actual person filling out the ballot. The current system does that with a mix of bipartisan volunteers and government workers, making it hard to tamper with unless you have a truly massive conspiracy which manages to avoid revealing any trace of its existence.
The only thing you can’t do is say that person A voted for candidate B, because that would guarantee attempts at coercion.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> You can verify that the ballots were given to registered voters at a particular polling station where they were sealed, transported securely, and tallied without the seals being broken – these days, all with video surveillance except for the actual person filling out the ballot. This is not even a requirement of a legitimate ballot. How are you supposed to "verify" something that isn't true?
- acdha 5y agoWhat part do you not think is true? What I described is the common situation in the United States where you have observers confirming that people are checked against the voter registration lists, the ballots are collected in sealed boxes, transported securely, etc. At every stage they verify seals so they can confirm that while they don't know _how_ you voted there's no serious question that the ballot being tallied is the one you dropped in the box at your polling station. This is one of the major reasons why all of those election lawsuits failed: an alleged tampering scheme would need hundreds of people altering many thousands of records, and it would need to involve members of both parties and city employees without leaking any trace of its existence. One very nice property of physical seals and paper ballots is that you can't alter them without doing a lot of manual work which would obviously be different from normal activities. The conspiracy theorists tried but they couldn't come up with a remotely plausible way that people could have been shifting truck-loads of ballots around in perfect secrecy.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoA ballot need not be given to a voter at a polling station. There is no such requirement, and in fact this is not true of many ballots. They can be received elsewhere and filled out elsewhere.