2 ms·
> People don't have the slightest clue how traditional vote counting and recount procedures work until sometimes goes wrong and it makes the news Is that reall
by acdha 5y ago
> People don't have the slightest clue how traditional vote counting and recount procedures work until sometimes goes wrong and it makes the news
Is that really the case? It seems far more common that the problem isn’t that people don’t understand how it works but is rather that they don’t like the result and pick that as an excuse.
When evaluating a proposed new system, we have to think about it outside of contexts where everyone is acting in good faith — the current system survived hundreds of challenges because it’s simple, robust, and anyone can understand how it works and that cheating would require moving millions of pieces of paper in locations around the country, which is very hard to conceal. Try to think about how a complex digital system would offer new avenues for complaint to the same well-funded attackers whose claims are not constrained by facts or reason. As we’ve already seen, even if the new part was perfectly implemented all they’d do is shift to where it interfaces with the real world (“I hit A and it changed it to B!”, “These people weren’t eligible to vote and I just know they voted for the other guy”, etc.). Since it wouldn’t be perfect, it would just afford new angles for misrepresenting things to a willing audience – as we saw with those fake “pcaps” or claims that China was connecting to the voting machine servers.