3 ms·
- effectiveness. The COVID vaccines are 95%+ effective against the original COVID virus. This is better than some of the vaccines we routinely give out, and
by bryanlarsen 5y ago
- effectiveness.
The COVID vaccines are 95%+ effective against the original COVID virus. This is better than some of the vaccines we routinely give out, and worse than some.
- lifelong immunity
One of our routine vaccinations (tetanus) needs booster shots every ten years. Some routine vaccinations need 4 doses before effectiveness. And this is for diseases that aren't mutating.
The COVID "waning immunity" story is a red herring. All vaccinations only produce antibodies for a few months -- B cells etc provide immunity after a few months for COVID and every other viral vaccine.
- target a disease which is not that dangerous
COVID has a fatality rate between 0.2 and 1.0 %. This is higher than the death rate for measles and many other diseases we routinely vaccinate for.
- and is particularly not-dangerous for children
700 dead children in the US would disagree. It's not a high rate of death but is similar to other causes (https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejmsr1804754 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejmsr1804754)
If we had to live with that rate of childhood death we could, but vaccines are so cheap and side-effect free we shouldn't have to.
- _dain_ 5y agoThe original COVID virus is practically defunct. It was outcompeted by other strains. Effectiveness is sharply declining. Ten years is much longer than ten months, which is how long the corona vaccines have been around. Waning immunity is not a red herring. The entire mass vaccination strategy was predicated on the idea that everyone would get one or two doses and the virus would be defeated and we go back to normal. Spare me this motte/bailey sophistry. Measles: again you conflate a disease that attacks children with a disease that does not. The 0.2-1% mortality figure for measles is almost entirely concentrated among children. Rate of child death from corona is negligible. You bring up 700 dead children from corona -- yes this is a tragedy, but it is comparable to influenza. A bad flu season will see something like 500-600 under-18s die in USA over course of a year (and is your 700 figure for a single year, or summed across both pandemic years?). I am sorry but we cannot shut down society for this.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoMeasles has a death rate of 1 in 1000 children. That's massively lower than COVID, which is some unknown amount higher than 2 in 1000 of the entire population. I didn't say we shut down for 700 deaths. But that number is enough to justify minor interventions, like masking until a vaccine is available for every one, and then vaccinating broadly.
- 650 5y agoAre minor interventions like described in your comment justifiable for 70 deaths? Or 7 deaths?
- mewpmewp2 5y agoIf current vaccines are so effective, explain what is happening in Singapore please, with 85%+ of whole population (not adults) vaccinated.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoYou mean the Singapore with 300 total deaths out of a population of 6 million? 85% would likely be enough to stop the original COVID variant, but Delta is much more transmissible and likely needs a 90% vaccination rate. And that 90% has to be widespread -- pockets of lower vaccination rates can incubate the disease. And until we vaccinate children, every school is an incubator.
- mewpmewp2 5y agoI highly doubt 90% is going to apply as a new goalpost. Yes, it reduces ICU and deaths in risk groups A LOT, but it doesn't explain forcing or pressuring people out of risk groups to vaccinate. There's more information constantly flowing in now, how under reported all the different complications and side effects vaccines can cause actually is now. And why is it under reported? Because of the whole propaganda of "vaccines are safe and effective, can't do you harm, if you believe otherwise you are anti-science moron". People even if they have long lasting side effects they are ridiculed when they go to doctor's and same with their families. No reporting going on about this at all. I've read over 1000 anecdotal stories by now, where similar set of circumstances happen, although if you read those stories it would be obvious that these are not coincidences, imagination of people or anything remotely like that. It's great that a recent video came out where Kyle is interviewed by Dr John Campbell about his experience with doctors.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoIf they were trying to hide vaccine side effects, they would have hidden the pericardia side effect. The side effect rate is close enough to the baseline pericardia rate and the consequences minor enough that it would have been easy to hide. They delayed the vaccine roll out to children a couple of months to further verify that. That really pisses me off, because rolling the kids vaccine out a couple months earlier would have a saved a good number of lives. If you want to talk about side effects, lets talk about the side effects of COVID. I've got a friend with Chronic Fatigue as a side effect from H1N1, a really nasty disease. She's on long term disability and the economy so all of us insurance customers and taxpayers are paying for her support for 25+ years instead of her being gainfully employed. Widespread long COVID is going to cause massive suffering to people and the economy.