4 ms·
So, you think it’s OK if the car you own spies on you, using electricity you pay for? I’m rephrasing it that way to show that, depending on details this might
by Someone 5y ago
So, you think it’s OK if the car you own spies on you, using electricity you pay for?
I’m rephrasing it that way to show that, depending on details this might be close to what Apple intended to do w.r.t. child pornography, something ‘the internet’ wasn’t a fan of, to say it mildly.
There’s a difference here in that there’s an ‘investigation’, but you’re also talking of ‘car crashes and accidents’, so this could get reasonably close (we already have cars that call 911 crash; should they also report it when they hear car accident-like sounds that co-occur with unexpected car movements?). Who’s going to decide whether an accident is serious enough to warrant this? Should car owners have the right to disable this kind of recording?
- vagrantJin 5y ago> this might be close to what Apple intended to do w.r.t. child pornography, something ‘the internet’ wasn’t a fan of, to say it mildly. Not to completely disregard your point but its not the same. After seeing a few brain bits splattered across windows and chairs/dashboards, stray limbs...road accidents are in another lesgue entirely. We sort of need accidents to happen so that regulation of technology will use blood as ink/toner.
- torstenvl 5y agoDid you honestly just say "road accidents" are worse than raping children on camera and sending out the video for people to get off to? Seriously?
- GuB-42 5y agoThe car is already spying on you. I think the question is: if data is available to the manufacturer, should it be available to investigators? I am think it is reasonable. Tesla uses these data to protect themselves (for example by showing that autopilot wasn't in use during an accident). It is not really about user privacy anymore, it is about corporate interests, and I think road safety is more important, that's why we have all these regulations.
- 34679 5y ago"Dear Driver, Upon inspection of your vehicular data following the non-injury accident in the parking lot of Piggly-Wiggly on 10/20/21, we have noted the following violations since you purchased the vehicle on 6/1/19. Images from the driver-facing cameras indicate you were the operator at the time of these violations. To avoid further fines and vehicular seizure, please remit payment to: Your All-Seeing Local Government, 110 Main St, Chicago, IL PS: Location data has indicated possible violations outside of our jurisdiction and pursuant to our data sharing agreement, all information has been forwarded to the States of Illinois, Indiana, Missouri, Iowa, and Ohio for further analysis."
- chuckee 5y agoThe car is already spying on you. I think the question is: It shouldn't be spying on you. The data belongs to the car owner. If the owner wants to disable data collection, so be it. If anyone else wants that data, they can ask the owner for the decryption key and access to their car to make a copy. I don't think it's even remotely reasonable for devices that we own to betray us. My car should protect me, not the manufacturer.
- mola 5y agoThis is not what apple suggested. Apple suggested preemptively notifying government of "illegal" material in a users device. This is about facilitating an ongoing specific investigation after a car accident.
- MrDresden 5y agoMy comment was clear and to the point on the availability of local on device data to car crash investigators. Take that as you may.