12 ms·
How about treating judges and legislators as if they were insiders of every public company and applying Section 16 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 to the
by tzs 5y ago
How about treating judges and legislators as if they were insiders of every public company and applying Section 16 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 to them?
Section 16 currently applies to officers, directors, and anyone who holds 10% of the stock of a company.
These people have to disclose all of their trades, and they are not allowed to make any profitable "short-swing" trades in the stock. A trade is a short-swing trade if it occurs within 6 months of a trade in the opposite direction.
Section 16 is brilliant in how it is enforced. It allows any shareholder to sue the short-swing trader. The plaintiff does not have to have been a shareholder at the time of the trade. They only have to be a shareholder at the time of the suit.
If the plaintiff wins the trader has to return all short-swing profits to the company and pay the plaintiff's attorney fees. Because the people covered by Section 16 have to report their trades, and because there isn't really a defense for short-swing trading, it is an open and shut case.
The data is available from the SEC in electronic form, and there are lawyers who get it and do automated checks to find short-swing trades. Then it is an easy matter for them to buy a share if they don't already have one, sue the short-swing trader, trivially win the open and shut case, and collect attorney fees.
If that wasn't enough to discourage insiders from short-swing trading, Section 16 provides more discouragement by being brutal in how it defines profit from a short-swing trade. Consider this sequence of trades by a Section 16 insider:
Jan 1: buy N shares at $100/share
Feb 1: sell N shares at $90/share
Mar 1: buy N shares at $80/share
Apr 1: sell N shares at $70/share
The person is clearly a terrible trader. That sequence of trades has lost them $20/share.
But Section 16 doesn't look at the overall results. It just looks it individual trades and tries to match them with individual trades going the other way within 6 months (before or after) and if the sell is higher than the buy that is short-swing profit.
Section 16 sees the above trades as a short-swing profit of $10 x N from the purchase on Mar 1 and the sale on Feb 1.
The net result then for the insider who made those ill conceived trades is that they lose $20/share on the trades themselves, and they end up having to pay an additional $10/share to the company, and pay the attorney fees of whoever managed to file first to sue them.
- nerdponx 5y agoI love this idea.
- Consultant32452 5y agoOkay, but first send the judges and politicians who did this to gitmo.