4 ms·
I wish there were more information about how they were able to "decrypt" the data. I put that in quotes because often times journalists or laypeople don't diffe
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
I wish there were more information about how they were able to "decrypt" the data. I put that in quotes because often times journalists or laypeople don't differentiate between a file format that is just compressed or obfuscated in some way, and true encryption.
After all, it would be trivial for Tesla to provide essentially unbreakable encryption: just encode all the stored data with a public key where only Tesla has the corresponding private key. But if NFI was able to decrypt, they obviously don't do that, so I'm curious what manner of "encryption" is used in the car.
- jeroenhd 5y agoThe paper about it [0] calls it "reverse engineering and evaluation" to the word "decrypt" was probably used wrongly. [0]: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/355202701_Reverse_engineering_and_evaluation_of_Tesla_vehicle_logs https://www.researchgate.net/publication/355202701_Reverse_e...
- warp 5y agoLooks like they published their code and tools here: https://github.com/NetherlandsForensicInstitute/teslalogs https://github.com/NetherlandsForensicInstitute/teslalogs
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoThank you very much. That repo has a detailed description of their procedure [1], and it's clear they just reverse engineered the binary file format. 1. https://github.com/NetherlandsForensicInstitute/teslalogs/tree/master/writeup https://github.com/NetherlandsForensicInstitute/teslalogs/tr...
- orev 5y agoThe word “decrypt” means “make (a coded or unclear message) intelligible”, which is more broad than the IT-specific jargon of using cipher algorithms. It’s perfectly fine to use “decrypt” in the general sense in an article meant for general people to read.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoThe problem with this, then, is it confuses topics that are important for lay people to differentiate. Take the current idiocy coming from the governor of Missouri, trying to prosecute a journalist for "hacking" for the crime of ... reading HTML. While the governor used the word "decoding", not decrypting, he accused the journalist of going through some complicated intentional procedure to access private data, which is of course bullshit. Even in the general sense, "decrypting" something strongly implies the original author had the intention of keeping it private and secure. Was this the case with Tesla's data? It seems like not, because it would have been trivial for them to implement unbreakable encryption. Or was this just a case where someone else figured out their file format?
- 1970-01-01 5y agoNo, the wrong word was written, and that minor detail reveals how technically competent the editors are. They decoded the data.