3 ms·
Projecting contemporary morals backwards is fraught for many reasons, not least of which is the fact that we know scientific facts people in Jefferson’s time di
by rayiner 5y ago
Projecting contemporary morals backwards is fraught for many reasons, not least of which is the fact that we know scientific facts people in Jefferson’s time didn’t.
If you were a European in 1780, and you believed that all people were morally equal, would it necessarily follow that all people were factually equal in every capacity? Would you really look at London and New York on one hand, and virtually anywhere else on the other, and conclude that the people who built those respective places were fungible?
How much does scientific knowledge shape moral thinking? In particular, how much does contemporary knowledge of the minimal genetic differences between groups of humans—something that wouldn’t be discovered until 150+ years later—color the conclusions we draw from the obvious differences in civilizations land technological achievement between people of different nations?
> Rather conflicts with the narrative that the US was founded as a melting pot nation.
The narrative is that America is a melting pot, not that it was founded as such. The founders were virtually all of British heritage and the country was founded as England 2.0. But starting with German American immigration in the early 19th century it very quickly became an immigrant nation.