4 ms·
Drone-sized ornithopters have become reasonably flyable outdoors. But scaling works against you. One the size of a large helicopter, capable of vertical takeoff
by Animats 5y ago
Drone-sized ornithopters have become reasonably flyable outdoors. But scaling works against you. One the size of a large helicopter, capable of vertical takeoff, is tough. Mostly a power problem, like all VTOL.
Dune, like much of SF, runs on Rule of Cool. The skilled knife fighter, even shielded, is vulnerable to many of the standard anti-riot weapons, such as projectiles which throw a net. Being hit by an RPG round with a solid warhead would at least knock someone down hard, despite shielding, from sheer momentum transfer. And tanks work just fine in the desert, as has been amply demonstrated in the Middle East all the way back to Patton.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IJA5C-ghj4s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IJA5C-ghj4s
- ceejayoz 5y ago> And tanks work just fine in the desert, as has been amply demonstrated in the Middle East all the way back to Patton. Probably not against sand worms.
- phendrenad2 5y agoAnd not for covering long distances to where the spice is...
- kortex 5y agoTanks are no weapon of choice. The rhythmic nature of the slats in the tank treads as it drives will surely attract a worm. Heh, they'll never learn.
- gilbetron 5y agoWorth posting just because it is still a fun watch: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQ7z57qrZU8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQ7z57qrZU8
- thrower123 5y agoThis might be from the later Brian Herbert books, but I recall ornithopters having jets or thrusters for VTOL.
- lrem 5y agoTFA is citing jets from the original Dune novel.
- Animats 5y agoThrust-based VTOL requires huge amounts of engine power. Which is why it's rarely seen on anything other than fighters, which are mostly engine anyway. There were some exceptions in the 1940s and 1950s, when jet engines didn't quite have enough power to get aircraft up to flying speed quickly. There were some attempts to use rocket-assisted takeoffs ("RATO" or "JATO") during WWII, and by the 1950s, this worked reasonably well. This peaked with the B-47 bomber, which was basically a jet fighter scaled up to heavy bomber size. Here's a JATO-assisted B-47 takeoff.[1] And here's a jet fighter zero-length takeoff from a rack on the back of a truck.[2] That was pushing it; there were a lot of crashes. Awesome, but impractical, the technology was discarded in favor of aircraft with enough main engine power to get off the ground on short runways. Another dead end was the Avro-Car, which was supposed to be a VTOL for the Army. This is the famous flying saucer.[3] It was supposed to be a supersonic VTOL. It had nowhere near enough power for that, and could barely get out of its own ground effect. Plus it was unstable, although today it could probably be stabilized automatically. The prototype finally ended up at what's now NASA Ames, bouncing around the back lots in hovercraft mode. The U.S. Army was also funding the UH-1 helicopter, which was less awesome, but far more useful, so they cancelled the Avro-Car and ordered lots of Hueys. If you like weird VTOL craft and are in Silicon Valley, visit the Hiller Aviation Museum. Many of those strange ideas from the 1950s ended up there. So, using a booster to get a large ornithopter off the ground is, while not impossible, probably not something you'd do often. Although you could imagine some fortress having such a rig, so the leaders could escape when they were losing. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vKQYG_fA2uM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vKQYG_fA2uM [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uxazX7Z_4iQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uxazX7Z_4iQ [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avro_Canada_VZ-9_Avrocar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avro_Canada_VZ-9_Avrocar
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoThe baron was flying by himself, so in that universe they definitely had other ways to generate lift but trust-based propulsion.
- yoz-y 5y agoMainly if they are going to fight with medieval weapons but with force shields, they should be wearing medieval armor. That combination would make them much less mushy.
- jimnotgym 5y ago>And tanks work just fine in the desert, as has been amply demonstrated in the Middle East all the way back to Patton. Tanks were being used to great effect by Rommel (and less successfully by others) for a long time before Patton graced the desert! In fact the battle of El Alamein where Rommel was severely pushed back was well underway when Patton landed. The Western Desert war began in mid 1940, Patton landed in late 1942. As my companion poster noted, none of this was against sand worms though
- jon-wood 5y agoTanks do work fine in the desert, but if they were rumbling along on tracks they’d quickly attract sand worms and be swallowed. I imagine suspensor propelled tanks would be similar since in the novels force fields will attract worms from far and wide, much more so than just rhythmic noise.
- skhr0680 5y ago> Being hit by an RPG round with a solid warhead would at least knock someone down hard, despite shielding, from sheer momentum transfer. Have you ever seen Elysium?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]