10 ms·
Nassim Nicholas Taleb Calls Bitcoin a Tulip Bubble Without the Aesthetics
- paulpauper 5y agothis guy is so tiresome sometimes. BY having no position, if it falls he can still say he was right, but if prices go up he can still say he was right because he did not short it.
- mmmmkay 5y agowhat is wrong with that? Knowing that eventually it will blow up and knowing when that will occur are two different things.
- jacquesm 5y agoA huge asteroid will hit Earth. There. Now are you going to call me this amazing prophet or just some schmuck who stated the obvious?
- civilized 5y ago"Bitcoin will fail, it's just a matter of when" would not be considered an obvious opinion, or even an acceptable one, among most Bitcoin enthusiasts.
- jacquesm 5y agoI think that even the most die-hard Bitcoin enthusiast will be aware of the fact that nothing lasts forever. And for now Bitcoin seems to have outlasted the most recent asteroid impact. Seriously, any 'prophet' that tells you what will happen but not when is not worth listening to because they are just throwing out random stuff in the hope that something will stick. Which of course eventually it does. In NL we have a similar figure, one 'Maurice de Hond', he predicts stuff all the time, forgets his failures and accents his successes and people lap it up. It's embarrassing.
- tartoran 5y agoThe Dollar wont last forever either. If I say “nothing will” it appeases the statement but it is just an obvious generality
- adolph 5y agoWell, are you shorting precious metals that will be on the asteroid or what?
- jacquesm 5y agoAbsolutely. I'll milk that impact for all it's worth. Too bad I'll be too busy evaporating myself to cash in on it but for a very short while I'll be the richest man on Earth ;) And I'll re-invest my riches into start-ups that aim to deal with very fast climate change. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bU1QPtOZQZU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bU1QPtOZQZU Applications are open.
- analog31 5y agoI realize it's an aside from the point you're making, but the red flag for me is that a prediction without a timeline is meaningless. If someone says "the market will crash," and doesn't tell you when, then it's not a prediction.
- jacquesm 5y agoThat's exactly it.
- ashwagary 5y agoWhether he likes it or not, having no Bitcoin exposure is an open Bitcoin short position. That position has been a disaster for anyone that maintained it over the past 12 years.
- oh_sigh 5y agoTaleb made his F-U money by taking a position that very much went against the grain of most investors. He wasn't one of those people that go on TV every 6 months and say a depression is coming, but have very little skin in the game. If he doesn't take a position here, it may just be because he can't figure the timing of when it will fall, not because he doesn't believe it will fall.
- rufusroflpunch 5y agoHe’s incorrect.
- anonu 5y agoPlease elaborate
- rufusroflpunch 5y agoBitcoin is an inflation hedge and a durable store of value. Tulips were 100% pure short term speculative venture with zero durability. Bitcoin has a value proposition outside of day trading speculators. Right now people holding BTC long term is at all time highs. They are fundamentally different and it is a silly comparison.
- anonu 5y ago> Bitcoin is an inflation hedge agreed. but so is any risk asset. Tulips as well... > and a durable store of value. Compared to USD its quite volatile. So in terms of inflation hedge + durable store of value I would much rather be in gold where daily or weekly fluctuations can be stomached. > short term speculative I think Taleb is saying bitcoin is a bubble like tulips were. The tulip mania lasted a few months or so. The fact that the bitcoin "bubble" has lasted longer does not in itself mean it is not a bubble. Only time will tell. > Bitcoin has a value proposition outside of day trading speculators I would argue that the vast majority of the reason for bitcoin's existence today is speculation and trading. We are 10+ years in and we still don't have a viable decentralized infrastructure based on crypo. In fact, the entire value of cryptocurrency is derived from centralized finance. Companies like Coinbase make a big splash about all this - but their market cap is derived from listing on the NYSE and their very business model is predicated on storing keys for everyone and being a central place for trading. Explain to me how Bitcoin is any different than the meme stocks of today? (Gamestop, AMC and many more...). Bitcoin is the symptom of simply too much money on the sidelines. It is the monetary equivalent of the social amplification you get from making a tweet that suddenly goes viral. In defense of crypto, I will say one thing: the creativity in the space is amazing. The pace of innovation, ideas and new concepts is heartening to see. What I expect from all this, however, is maybe 95% of it will disappear and we will remain with 5% of the innovation in the crypto space. I don't know what that 5% looks like - but it will probably be focused on the tech that disrupts existing payment structures and marketplaces - and less so about store of value.
- anm89 5y agoTaleb throws out controversial opinions for no other reason than that his brand is having controversial opinions and it keeps his name in circulation.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Taleb throws out controversial opinions for no other reason than that his brand is having controversial opinions and it keeps his name in circulation. That’s true in general, but not particularly relevant here (except perhaps to demonstrate that this is a statement inconsistent with his reflexive pattern) because “Bitcoin is a tulip bubble without the aesthetics” is a pretty mainstream opinion, if one that a lot of mainstream proponents of have softened on (it is pretty close to Krugman’s position before that softened to a “a cult that can survive forever”.) Actually, given his “not-bearish” line, which suggests he isn’t predicting imminent demise, only that is irrational to be on either side, his position seems like (despite that one line sounding like Krugman’s old position) it is actually identical in substance to Krugman’s more recent opinion: bitcoin has no fundamentals holding it up, but an indefinite supply of cultists that makes it unsafe to predict it going down at any particular time.
- m3kw9 5y agoThe believers propping up btc is actually buying it more time till it gets actually massively useful as promised.
- TomVDB 5y agoDid he say anything controversial?
- tartoran 5y agoI don’t think he said anything new at all. Talking about bitcoin when it hovers around all time high, especially for a personality like NT is a sure way to call for attention. But the message is not something that hasn’t been told hundreds of times
- adamqureshi 5y agoBTC are like casino chips. When you goto Vegas and at the Bellagio you give them $100 and you get back $100 worth of Bellagio chips, those chips only have value INSIDE the Bellagio and if you take those chips outside to a 7-eleven and try to pay for a slurpie and a taquito the 7-eleven guy will tell you to get lost we do not accept Bellagio casino chips. 2-cents. BTC value is an illusion they only hold value inside the BTC network and they are worth what the next sucker will pay for it. Yes you can make money from anyone inside the network who's willing to pay more than you did. Maybe i don't know what im talking about but im not the only one. 2-cents.
- anonporridge 5y agoThis is great analogy, except the "inside" of bitcoin is constantly growing bigger and assimilating more real world realms. It now includes the entire country of El Salvador. The real magic happens when a nation state starts selling it's exports priced in bitcoin instead of dollars. In fact, Putin was recently asked about exactly this for Russia. He dismissed it as "too early to talk about the trade of energy resources in crypto", but my takeaway from that statement, is that the door is absolutely open. [0] Then again, wanting to sell oil for something other than dollars is probably why the US killed both Saddam Hussein (wanted Euros) and Muammar Gaddafi (wanted gold backed African currency), so we'll see if the US still has enough proof of violence (PoV) to maintain security of the dollar as the global reserve currency. I don't know what I'm talking about either, so this is just my 2 sats. [0] - https://www.cnbc.com/2021/10/14/russias-putin-says-crypto-has-value-but-maybe-not-for-trading-oil.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/10/14/russias-putin-says-crypto-ha...
- pkaye 5y ago> probably why the US killed both Saddam Hussein (wanted Euros) and Muammar Gaddafi (wanted gold backed African currency)... As far as I understand the Libya military intervention was a NATO mission and the French and British were early proponents of intervention before the US. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_military_intervention_in_Libya https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_military_intervention_in_...
- H8crilA 5y agoDon't know if you've read his paper on Bitcoin, it's a decent one, it roughly boils down to two points: 1) no benefit in the meantime for the holder (such as a dividend or direct utility from the thing itself - a painting can be hung on a wall to look nice), 2) non-zero probability of perishing over any time period. From those two premises one can indeed conclude that the asset should be valued at no more than 0. On the surface this is right, however I'm wondering if the first assumption is actually true. People do get some sense of fulfillment from participating in this "revolution", sticking it to the "big system", protection of capital from the "insane inflation", or just plain bragging rights (ex: laser eyes). Should this type of a benefit exist indefinitely then the conclusion of it being worth <= 0 isn't correct.
- AnonC 5y ago> 1) no benefit in the meantime for the holder (such as a dividend or direct utility from the thing itself - a painting can be hung on a wall to look nice) That point in the quote doesn’t make sense when you consider holding a stock like Amazon or Salesforce that never pays dividends. Are those stocks then the same as crypto? It seems like an oversimplification. Bitcoin, with this point, is just purely a “growth stock”.
- H8crilA 5y agoIf they will never pay dividend or get their stock bought back, or get acquired, or [some other obscure way of paying shareholders] then their stock is worth exactly $0, yes. The key word is "if".
- neom 5y agoI would have said 1) is for sure true till recently, my cleaner started asking to be paid in BTC, and even more crazy I would never have thought (I only took a tiny position recently)... I'd rather pay her cash because I'm worried I'll be that pizza dude in 10 years. :\ I'm not really bullish on btc and I don't really care what it does, but that interaction with my cleaner gave me pause.
- 5y ago
- tuberelay 5y agoFat tony should put some skin in the game and short the orange coin rather than being an intellectual yet idiot.
- H8crilA 5y agoIronic that you would call someone an IYI, yet think that going short is the mirror image of going long. Anyone who has been practicing trading/investing in any form for long enough will tell you that this is very far from the truth (take Buffett as a classic example). When you go long and you're right you'll eventually win. When you go short and you're right you're actually somewhat likely to lose, still. Best example is all forms of systematic, no-matter-what volatility shorting.
- salawat 5y agoTo short is to bet there is not a bigger idiot, or that the world couldn't possibly be okay with something. I don't necessarily qualify that as idiocy, more naive optimism.
- ashwagary 5y agoNo BTC exposure = open short position 99% of the people on the planet knowingly or unknowingly have an open Bitcoin short position.
- m3kw9 5y agoHe does know there is a chance it goes higher before it goes lower, short it wrong and you go broke
- anonporridge 5y agoAlso, if you're wrong, shorts have the effect of not only losing you money, but giving energy to rise when you get liquidated or voluntarily close your position. You must close you shorts at some point, otherwise you go bankrupt, which means buying and driving the price higher. On the other hand, a long position (non leveraged) on a dying asset is something you ride all the way to zero if your pride demands it, without forcing you to feed into the direction you don't want to be true. So long as it's not 100% of your portfolio, you won't go broke holding it into the ground.
- bhouston 5y agoBitcoin has become something people want to happen. It is being propped up by belief. In many ways it is fake it until you make it. And it may well make it eventually. This is similar to tether. Tether has been fraudulent in its claims but it also is growing and can outgrow its fraud so that it becomes mature and fully backed. Again a fake it until you make it. Basically belief and patience on the part of the holders is allowing bitcoin and tether time to become real. Paradoxical to a degree but this is what is happening. People are right it has no intrinsic value or tether is a fraud but over time if they are allowed to grow they can outgrown this. So everyone is right. As long as the government doesn’t outlaw crypto here in the us. This is the main way it dies I think. Given the us gov tends to be beholden to special interest and bitcoin is a rich special interest I think it has at least a chance of survival.
- throw0101a 5y ago> Bitcoin has become something people want to happen. It is being propped up by belief. All "money" is propped up by belief (in its value for exchange). The 'disadvantage' of BTC (and gold) is that it is inflexible and it takes resources to create. Some people—'hard money' folks—think of this as a positive trait.
- rufusroflpunch 5y agoI am one of those hard money people. The work secures the network. In order to alter the ledger, you need to reverse not just one block, but every block after it, means you would have to redo the work for every single block. All the while, the rest of the network keep working along the real chain, mining new blocks. The work makes it impossible to alter the chain.
- AnonC 5y agoFiat currencies also take a lot of resources to create — human and computing resources (to define and create the money out of some calculations, be it a central bank for policy reasons or a private bank for fractional reserve banking reasons), physical elements and molecules for currency bills, infrastructure to handle electronic payments, settlements, reversals, etc. It’s all so widely distributed that people don’t think of the costs. I have seen contrary arguments on the enormous amount of energy used to create Bitcoin. Is there a good comparison showing the real (material) costs of fiat currency vs. Bitcoin?
- tenaciousDaniel 5y agoI came across my favorite description of crypto just a few days ago on Twitter: "imagine letting your car run idle so it can create solved sudokus that you can trade for heroin".
- throw0101a 5y ago> "imagine letting your car run idle so it can create solved sudokus that you can trade for heroin". * https://twitter.com/theophite/status/1030225104234373121 https://twitter.com/theophite/status/1030225104234373121
- _9omd 5y agoHow is this the top comment here! I'd expect better out of HN users. Even if you don't like bitcoin it's ridiculous to attack it with a joke that doesn't actually map to reality. Sure, it's a pretty good joke, but it's a terrible argument against bitcoin.
- tenaciousDaniel 5y agoIt's not an argument at all, it's just a good joke. I'm actually undecided on crypto. Yes we're a professional community and this isn't reddit, but we can have a bit of humor here and there.
- iab 5y agoEmphasis here on “bit”
- _9omd 5y agoOh I get it, I actually think it's a well written/funny joke. I'm just disappointed whenever Bitcoin/crypto comes up on HN that the top comments are usually very shallow critiques of it. It feels like often a lot of people are rallying around a really low effort comment just because it reaffirms their beliefs. Which in general describes social media :), but I usually expect more out of HN discussions.
- iab 5y ago
- loser777 5y agoThere may be similarities with the Tulip bubble but the underlying "asset" seems to not be comparable. Bitcoins in theory are almost infinitely more durable than turnips, and even casino chips as noted below. Like it or not, bitcoins probably have vastly more "mindshare" as a percentage of the global population than turnips or casino chips ever have or will.
- monster_group 5y agotulip != turnip.
- _9omd 5y agoTurnip mania peaked with Super Mario Bros 2.
- kryogen1c 5y agoyes yes. many of us think btc is a scam, others think its revolutionary. taleb is smart. more importantly, what in the _fuck_ is this article from Bloomberg? 1) it is literally more ad than article 2) most of the article is a grammatical rephrasing of the tweet with no attempt to value add. 3) the only non-tweet, non-ad sentence is a vague reference to an unrelated opinion taleb had about btc 4) the citation for 3? another tweet i dont know how to finish this comment. what a sign of the times. journalism bankruptcy.
- tenaciousDaniel 5y agoI tried reading a Forbes article earlier today, and gave up within 5 seconds after the third popup prevented me from reading the article.
- iab 5y agoConsider yourself lucky, soon they will be charging for pop ups
- forgotmypw17 5y agoI'll finish the comment for you: The medium is the message. Certain domains I just don't click the link anymore. Fool me once, and all that.
- ashwagary 5y ago>Taleb is smart Even though he is smart at risk management, can he be an IYI (intelligent yet idiot) when discussing another topic? I personally think everyone is an IYI in some sphere.
- _9omd 5y agoBitcoin is freedom technology, providing the ability for people to opt out of monetary systems that don't serve their needs. It's a technological-monetary-social-political revolution disguised as a get rich quick scheme. The average person is no doubt in it to make money, but in satisfying their greed they are unknowingly fueling a technology which has a good chance of changing the world in fundamental ways. You could also say it's like a trojan horse. Irresistibly beautiful, but inside lies the seeds of destruction that could free people from oppression and allow better and more efficient human organization. A Bitcoin moonboy in the USA fueled by their selfish greed is helping to empower someone on the other side of the world living under an authoritarian regime with hyperinflation and financial censorship. I think this is a beautiful alignment of incentives. We accept that people are greedy, and provide them something that satisfies their greed, which is used to build a better financial system for the world. Slightly tangential, but I'm generally fascinated by the idea of aligning incentives to create mechanisms that do good in the world. Instead of expecting people to be different than their base natures, change the game they're playing such that allowing them to follow human instinct effects positive change in the world. I don't yet have a clear idea how this could be applied to something like environmentalism, but it does make me wonder if it's possible. Is there a way to incentivise greed and harness the power to reduce CO2, clean the oceans, and restore ecosystems?
- rufusroflpunch 5y agoWell said.
- jimmydorry 5y agoThank you for putting this so eloquently. Something like a "Proof of Carbon Capture" would align the incentives of polluters and society. The problem is implementing it in a way that couldn't be gamed.
- _9omd 5y agoYes, a coin that's mined by "Proof of Carbon Capture" would be amazing, but I can't imagine how it would work. Decentralization and neutrality is hard/impossible once you're trying to interface with the real world. How could you verify the carbon capture without a centralized authority? I can imagine it would be possible in the far future with automation/robotics verifying the captured carbon in a neutral and decentralized way, but with current tech I can't see how it could work without being susceptible to being gamed. But maybe I'm just lacking imagination.