3 ms·
> "both sides" should come together to support reforms that are universally protective When one side doesn't do that, it's not a both sides issue.
by wolverine876 5y ago
> "both sides" should come together to support reforms that are universally protective
When one side doesn't do that, it's not a both sides issue.
- giantg2 5y agoThe first half of that quote (omitted) provides important context that is missing here. The conversation and showing the "other" side why and how it could benefit them, as well as addressing any concerns they have about any one-sided proposal, is vitally important to a healthy and productive process - the main point that I was trying to make. If we just blame everything on the "other" side, we will drift further apart, get less done, and become weaker as a country. I should also add that we are using simplified stereotypes of the sides here as there is a spectrum of positions and willingness to work together within either side. It seems you are implying that only one of the major parties has proposed justice reforms. Do you have anything to back up that? I seem to remember both parties suggesting varying reforms. I also seem to remember one party rejecting the proposals of the other party just because they didn't go far enough - an all-or-nothing mindset rather than an iterative or collaborative approach. We could come together on the common ground and pass the lesser bill as a step in the right direction while continuing to investigate and debate the finer points involved with the further reaching bill.
- wolverine876 5y ago> The conversation and showing the "other" side why and how it could benefit them, as well as addressing any concerns they have about any one-sided proposal, is vitally important to a healthy and productive process That is great, but has a requirement: Both sides operating in good faith. That's just not happening now and hasn't happened in many years. We need to deal with that reality or keep suffering dire consequences, including a possible end of democracy.
- giantg2 5y agoIt can be hard to tell when a side isn't operating in good faith due to differences of perspective and the heavy political rhetoric. If we assume the other side isn't operating in good faith, then we create a situation where neither side will ever trust the other, and the concern for addressing details and edge cases will be gone. This will lead to partisan laws that ignore the needs of a relatively large part of the population. Often times the two major parties want similar end goals, but have different opinions on what the strategy/implementation should look like. I think we can go a level deeper than your prerequisite and say that we should be viewing the proposals of others in a charitable way and assume the best possible meaning - similar to the guideline on this site. Once a side assumes the other isn't acting in good faith (whether right or wrong), then it's already too late for democracy. I don't know what the fix would be, since people continue to vote for the representatives of both sides, and want the things either side fight for. So it seems it would require an undemocratic change, or a complete mindset shift within the population.
- wolverine876 5y ago> It can be hard to tell when a side isn't operating in good faith due to differences of perspective and the heavy political rhetoric. It can be hard, but it's not impossible. I am very familiar with your points and have made them myself, over long years, in other circumstances. This circumstance isn't one of them. If you aren't willing to draw that conclusion at some point, you are facilitating the worst in people, the bullying, the political violence and oppression; the division and hate; by giving them an infinite free pass, by eliminating any opposition. If you give the same answer every time, it's also not rational, intelligent analysis, but reflexive rhetoric. And if you don't see it now, in the US (and many other places), you never will. You will never see stronger signals. People openly say they are out to destroy you at all costs. It seems as if people were conditioned, over a generation of more 'reasonable' politics, to respond this way no matter what. It's obvious what your enemies will do, tactically, to take advantage of that. The world has shifted under your feet; it's like disruption in industry - things have changed, you need to adjust or the disrupters will destroy you. Sometimes, hopefully as little as possible, but sometimes you have to fight.
- 5y ago