7 ms·
I have a family, and I'm very protective of my time because failure to, for example, pick my kid after school would quickly escalate to criminal negligence. If
by klyrs 5y ago
I have a family, and I'm very protective of my time because failure to, for example, pick my kid after school would quickly escalate to criminal negligence. If my work demanded that I commit any crime, I would refuse until I got fired (quitting is for losers, in this case: I want my damned severance).
I don't assume that non-parents can or should pick up the slack. I expect all of my coworkers to be protective of their work-life balance and I'm dismayed whenever I see them prioritize work in a detrimental way.
Said differently, if you're upset at parents putting their children's wellbeing before your team's performance, then you should re-evaluate your relationship with work.
- jimt1234 5y ago> I don't assume that non-parents can or should pick up the slack. Maybe you don't assume that, but the system built around parenting does assume that. A clear example of this is "new parent" time off. At my company, new parents can take 4 months off work (paid). So, if you work on a team of a dozen people, and 10 people on the team have children at some point, that means, at a minimum, 2 people are picking up more of the slack than the others.
- klyrs 5y agoAt my work, new parents tend to give 3-6 months notice before that PTO and we hire temporary replacements. What's wrong with your workplace? It's not the parents.
- willcipriano 5y agoAlternatively the firm can take a productivity hit for a couple months.
- hnaccount141 5y agoLet's be clear here, the "system" in question is just exploitative management. If management knows a worker will be taking their leave they can either hire to make up for it or adjust their productivity expectations for a few months. If they don't, that's not the fault of the person taking the leave that they're entitled to as part of their compensation package.
- nybble41 5y agoFilling in for the missing teammate is only part of the problem, though even that assumes temporary (possibly skilled or specialty) help is readily available for a short-term assignment, or that productivity can be scaled back without missing deadlines which in some cases are set years in advance and are essential for coordinating schedules with other teams. No, the real issue here is that everyone is paying for this benefit which only helps a subset of the workers. Ordinary PTO—vacations and holidays—is available to everyone to use as they wish. Sick leave is only for those with medical issues, but statistically most employees will end up using it at some point and they all benefit from having that protection since it's (more or less) a random occurrence. But parental leave is not random; it's specifically tied to the employees choices, and some employees are not in a situation where it would ever benefit them. Logically, then, paid parental leave should be an opt-in benefit which employees pay for, not a default part of the general employee compensation package.
- syspec 5y agoKind of a strawman argument, and a bit dramatic. The parent is discussing parents wanting to leave early and be given less work
- klyrs 5y agoFine. A strictly capitalist take on the situation: your inability to negotiate for desirable hours & wages is not the responsibility of anybody but yourself. Go work in a union if you want everybody to have the same contract.
- lugged 5y agoYou're really just doubling down on making the parents point huh.
- klyrs 5y agoSure, if you insist on reading past the part where I expect everybody to demand better for themselves and I'm dismayed when they don't.
- RNCTX 5y ago[flagged]
- klyrs 5y agoShe/her, millenial, and my employer is only entitled to the time that I consent to giving; literally fire* me if you don't like it. I don't demean union work, in fact, I prefer it; but I know that's unpopular here. * don't have the authority? Then fuck off, you're the entitled one for thinking you can dictate my hours! edit: also, I don't work in a widget factory. When I stop work on a task, work on that task stops. I measure my productivity in tasks completed, and it would take months to train somebody to do my work. If I don't get my work done on time, a larger project deadline slips. I work very hard to ensure that never happens.
- yeahsure 5y agoYour comment clearly demonstrates OP's argument. Parents believe their time is more important than that of people without children.
- davidw 5y agoNo: > I expect all of my coworkers to be protective of their work-life balance and I'm dismayed whenever I see them prioritize work in a detrimental way. I agree completely, as a parent. I don't expect non-parents to put in extra time. Kids certainly do give you "real time deadlines" that can't be moved or pushed out of the way, but I don't expect to work any less because of them.
- lugged 5y agoThose real time deadlines that take you away from your work is what they're talking about. You leaving for those deadlines means someone else implicitly needs to pick up the slack. Or at least that is the argument.. but there are a few assumptions here that aren't true. Namely, someone doesn't need to pick up the slack, the work will be there the next day in most cases. Someone else with kids might be around. If your boss is treating you different it's on you to call it out and move on.
- dleslie 5y ago> You leaving for those deadlines means someone else implicitly needs to pick up the slack. It really doesn't. That's only the case in an abusive work environment.
- stevenicr 5y agoWouldn't this really depend on the job? Maybe there is a assumption up thread that it's a tech office job being discussed? But many jobs, if you had to leave to pickup kids because a bus brokedown, a no-change deadline - and you were working the afternoon shift at a wendys. digging trenches for a sewer line, paving a road, processing a line at an ER - all sorts of jobs - I think there would be no choice but for others to pickup the work being skipped. So I think it's very job dependent. Even some tech jobs probably can't just be postponed till the next day.
- creato 5y agoIt really depends on what exactly you're talking about. If you want to be unavailable for an hour every day during the standard "work day", that goes well beyond reasonable protectiveness of work-life balance in my opinion.
- dudeman13 5y agoI'm a programmer working from home. My manager does not give a shit if I'm randomly unavailable for an hour every day.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- makeitdouble 5y agoIf you’re explicit about it and your manager accepts it, that becomes part of the deal. Just as other people will take 2 hour lunch breaks every day to exercice or leave early for months to go find a new home etc. To your point, these arrangements usually go both ways, and are compensated for instance by starting earlier or bringing some work home. But it’s far from being limited to parents.
- torstenvl 5y ago> If you’re explicit about it and your manager accepts it, that becomes part of the deal. I'm confused. What authority do you have to say that something has become part of a social contract involving your coworkers when those same coworkers had no input on the process?
- another_story 5y agoYou're ignoring the fact that in most cultures saying you have a kid related event will get you out of something while usually retaining your standing in a company. Trying to negotiate leaving at 4pm so you can go home and relax is not seen in the same way. As a parent you're bargaining with more leverage.
- dleslie 5y agoEmployee A: I have an event that I must attend and cannot inconsequentially avoid. Employee B: I want to go home and relax.
- another_story 5y agoAs you posted down below, this should all be seen equally if the person is getting their work done, but it's not, and that's the point I was making.
- coderjames 5y agoEmployee B: [to prevent burnout so that I can remain a functioning member of society.]
- sokoloff 5y agoEmployee C: I'm leaving, see you tomorrow! As your co-worker or your boss, why do I care in the slightest whether you're going home to take care of your kid, to smoke a bowl and watch a movie, or because a new video game was released that day? If A, B, and C are all getting their work done in the time that they are working, I think equally of the three of them, as subordinate, peer, or supervisor.
- dleslie 5y agoBingo. A, B, and C should all just leave at a regular, reasonable time. And sometimes each of them has reason to leave early, and doesn't need to justify it.
- mjmahone17 5y ago
- ZephyrBlu 5y ago> I expect all of my coworkers to be protective of their work-life balance and I'm dismayed whenever I see them prioritize work in a detrimental way What does "[prioritizing] work in a detrimental way" even mean?
- sidlls 5y agoIt means prioritizing working over one's non-work life, i.e., ignoring the "balance" in "work-life balance" in favor of doing work for someone else.
- ZephyrBlu 5y ago> ignoring the "balance" in "work-life balance" Is the balance not a personal choice? If I consciously choose to have a 90-10 work-life balance, why is that detrimental?
- sidlls 5y agoNo, it's not really a personal choice the way you mean--which essentially makes "balance" have no meaning. It's detrimental because it's unhealthy for you (c.f. consciously choosing to smoke tobacco products) and it's also unhealthy for your peers--because your employers will always prefer the person who devotes himself to service of the employer over balanced individuals who don't, forcing them to adjust toward the unhealthy end.
- ZephyrBlu 5y ago> which essentially makes "balance" have no meaning Only to you. Someone else may feel that 90-10 is a good balance for them at that particular time. > It's detrimental because it's unhealthy for you Working a lot isn't inherently unhealthy. You can be physically and mentally healthy while working a lot. > forcing them to adjust toward the unhealthy end Only if they want to keep up. I don't think about working more as "service of [my] employer", it's about faster personal growth. I don't expect other people to also work more, but I'm also not going to slow down for them.
- bruce343434 5y ago> I have a family, and I'm very protective of my time because failure to, for example, pick my kid after school would quickly escalate to criminal negligence. If my work demanded that I commit any crime, I would refuse until I got fired (quitting is for losers, in this case: I want my damned severance). > Said differently, if you're upset at parents putting their children's wellbeing before your team's performance, then you should re-evaluate your relationship with work. Who are you arguing with?
- klyrs 5y agoIt's a redirection of focus. In this thread, non-parents are upset at parents because they feel crunched when we have obligations that prevent us from working certain hours. The reason that they feel crunched is not the fault of the parents; it's the fault of management. I'm arguing with the notion that this is some sort of privilege parents have, that non-parents necessarily pay the price for. If management takes this sort of interruption into account, you won't feel the crunch. If management punishes your team because of circumstances outside of your control, that's abusive. If you ostracize the teammates with those external circumstances, you're playing into a divide & conquer tactic. You'll probably end up on the receiving end of that at some point. If you think it's important to be a team player, show some loyalty to your team and demand better of your management.
- Noos 5y agoThey have to prioritize work because your kid gets sick, or gets out of school early, or you have to go to their event. Kids have much more time to disrupt your life, and parents need more accommodation than single people for flexible scheduling. It's single people who pick up the slack for you, the whole "negotiating" thing is BS because its rarely the disruptions are on a fixed schedule.
- klyrs 5y agoGod forbid you get sick, injured, have a family obligation (marriage, funeral, etc), doctor's appointment, etc. If your management is so incredibly inflexible that you get punished for having events outside your control that impact your availability, then that's a problem with management. If you see parents having responsibilities as the problem, then your team/management is toxic. They want you to stay socially dependent on the team, to the point that you cannot have a life on or off the clock. Find another job, that's a sickness. Or, stick it to the parents: go out, meet somebody, have a baby of your own. If that sounds impossible, the problem is almost certainly how you're spending your time. Probably a work/life balance issue.
- nybble41 5y ago> God forbid you get sick, injured, have a family obligation (marriage, funeral, etc), doctor's appointment, etc. This isn't a binary issue. Work/life balance is obviously important for everyone, but where that balance point lies varies depending on individual circumstances. Employees with children have all those same obligations plus the additional responsibilities related to their kids. They receive more accommodation, on average, than employees without children. Performance expectations relative to pay should be the same for everyone regardless of their situation outside of work but that isn't always the case. If you need an excuse to claim time off, those with more excuses will tend to get more time.
- bradlys 5y agoPoint is that the parents have all those things happen to. They just get the excuse of their children having those things happen to them and they get to take time off of work for it too. Whereas the single/childless/whatever people are not going to have that freedom. So, yeah, they’re gonna have to pickup the slack at work as per usual.