6 ms·
It's very weird to see human capability factor into it. I mean, a person very well COULD compare two images pixel by pixel, it just takes a rather long time.
by Natsu 15y ago
It's very weird to see human capability factor into it. I mean, a person very well COULD compare two images pixel by pixel, it just takes a rather long time. I'm pretty sure I have done things like that on occasion for very small images, in fact.
- skorgu 15y agoYeah, this is patently (ha) absurd. I can't think of an algorithm off the top of my head that isn't feasible to do manually for small values of n.
- wisty 15y agoThe question is, will doing them for small values of n solve the problem? Page rank may be more or less useless with a small data set.
- skorgu 15y agoIt would provide the correct result of the algorithm which should be enough. Useful is outside the scope of patents (AIUI, IANAL).
- wisty 15y agoI think whole point of patents is they are a registered solution to a problem. So I think usefulness is within their scope. But IANAL either.
- skorgu 15y agoIt's not usefulness as we know it: http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sect2=HITOFF&d=PALL&p=1&u=%2Fnetahtml%2FPTO%2Fsrchnum.htm&r=1&f=G&l=50&s1=6293874.PN.&OS=PN/6293874&RS=PN/6293874 http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sec...
- bartonfink 15y agoActually, utility is one of the core requirements for a patent in the U.S. Whether or not PageRank on a tiny data set is still "useful" would be a ? for the patent office, but if it were deemed not useful, that would be grounds for denial.
- kwantam 15y agoAbsolutely. A method shouldn't be patentable just because it's too boring for a human to perform a mindless computation over and over again. Multiply a 3x3 matrix is simple for me to do by hand; multiplying a 1000x1000 matrix is no different in process but is much more time consuming; should the latter be patentable? (In my mind the answer is clearly no.) I can see where there might be some concern that you could claim anything that could be done on a computer could also be done more slowly by a human with a pencil and paper. Frankly, I don't have much of a problem with this: automating simple tasks doesn't seem like an invention, it sounds like a land-grab. Certainly there are nontrivial tasks that a computer can perform but which cannot be done well enough or fast enough by a person, e.g., closing a control loop in software (delay leads to instability; if you can't perform a computation fast enough, you cannot perform the control function, thus, certain such tasks could not be performed by a human with pencil and paper). It's arguable whether even something like this ("implement an equation... but really fast!") really ought to be patentable, and while I'm a named inventor on at least a few patents in this area, I'm doubtful. Of course, my employer has no such qualms, and is happy to hold said patents.
- skorgu 15y ago> closing a control loop in software (delay leads to instability; if you can't perform a computation fast enough, you cannot perform the control function, thus, certain such tasks could not be performed by a human with pencil and paper). I agree with your point but I find a certain irony in the fact that a pilot is clearly closing a highly delay-sensitive control loop without doing any math whatsoever.
- kwantam 15y agoIt's not delay sensitive on the same order of magnitude as something like a dc/dc converter. The relevant time constants in the pilot->controls->control surfaces->attitude->pilot loop are measured in fractional seconds (and when they're not, e.g., in fly-by-wire designs, the loops aren't closed by a person). The fastest relevant time constant for the control loop of a switching power converter with meager 1 kHz closed-loop bandwidth is measured in fractional milliseconds (you care about poles up to, say, 10x your crossover frequency). For a pretty run-of-the-mill analog circuit like an op-amp, the relevant time constants are often measured in nanoseconds. Heck, even something slow like an audio amplifier has relevant time constants in the tens of microsecond range. Also, don't underestimate the amount of subconscious math you're doing even for a simple task like walking. Your body's subconscious understanding of physics is pretty damn impressive. The problem is that our brains are pretty specific in the types of problems they're adapted to solving. Riding a bike, sure. Induction motor controller, probably not so much :)
- ScottBurson 15y agoAgreed. Even in the case at hand, it seems like the patent holder could argue that a human couldn't perform this task at Web scale.