4 ms·
Kind of off topic but seeing the current comments, keep in mind that excess deaths due to temperature is but a tiny fraction of the equation. Co2 levels and its
by lm28469 5y ago
Kind of off topic but seeing the current comments, keep in mind that excess deaths due to temperature is but a tiny fraction of the equation. Co2 levels and its impact on our cognitive capacity, ocean acidification, loss of crops, access to water, massive population migrations, warming of permafrost, &c. are all much more likely to cause problems
- georgewsinger 5y agoCO2 is an input to photosynthesis. How does it lead to a net loss of crops? EDIT: Of course, with changing climate: some crops will benefit; others will not. But how do we know in net that crop yields will definitely decrease under global warming?
- WalterSear 5y agoBit hard to plant crops during a hurricane, or water them during a drought.
- goatlover 5y agoHurricanes and droughts are regional. Might make growing more expensive and limited in some places, while others are able to grow more.
- danielheath 5y agoMore extreme temperatures will clearly affect plant growth rates.
- gameswithgo 5y agoDifferent plants have different optimum co2 concentrations, more is going to be bad for some, changing weather patterns and water availability will mean upheaval of agriculture for some regions, rising oceans will put some agriculture underwater.
- lm28469 5y agoIt's one of many variable, o2 is an input for respiration but if I'm sitting on your chest you'll still struggle. And rest assured, co2 isn't a bottleneck for crops
- EdwardDiego 5y agoMore intense weather leads to more crop damage, changes in precipitation patterns and average temperature affect the range and numbers of insect pests, etc. https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/09/warmer-wetter-climate-change-insects-biodiversity/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/09/warmer-wetter-climate...
- runarberg 5y agoI’m guessing among other reasons: droughts, floods, loss of pollinators, extreme temperatures, loss of natural fertilizers, etc.
- Symmetry 5y agoMore CO2 is generally good for photosynthesis. Higher temperatures are generally bad for photosynthesis. Which dominates depends on a lot of factors including base temperature, C3 versus C4 photosynthesis, etc. And then there's the changes in rainfall. Personally I wouldn't be particularly surprised if the first .5 C of global warming was a net benefit for humanity. I'd be pretty surprised if the second was, though, and very very* surprised if the third was. And that's just what takes us to our current target for limiting warming.
- philwelch 5y ago> Co2 levels and its impact on our cognitive capacity This is junk science. The CO2 level of the open atmosphere is ~400 ppm. The CO2 level aboard a nuclear submarine can range between ~2000-10000 ppm. 10000 ppm is enough to cause sleep disturbances and headaches, and we're less sure about the range between 5000-10000, but we're talking orders of magnitude away before we start seeing issues among people who engage in cognitively challenging work on a daily basis. The CO2 levels aboard the ISS are usually a bit lower--they try to keep it under 5000 ppm--but the astronauts there are even more closely monitored for medical issues and also have to perform cognitively challenging work. These are over extended periods of time between 3-9 months. If the CO2 concentration of the Earth's atmosphere went up 10x, you'd have much bigger problems than the cognitive effects of CO2 exposure.
- moultano 5y agoYou'll notice CO2 levels at 1000 ppm. The air will feel "stuffy," you'll feel lethargic, and feel like going outside. This is the primary reason why meetings at work are so stultifying. There's just too much CO2 in the room for anyone to think clearly. Just carry a CO2 meter around and measure it yourself. Once you're aware of it, the feeling is impossible to miss.
- philwelch 5y agoIf the CO2 level of the atmosphere doubles, we are still going to have bigger problems to solve. > Just carry a CO2 meter around and measure it yourself. Once you're aware of it, the feeling is impossible to miss. Sounds like a combination of confirmation bias and psychosomatic placebo effect to me. Plus you’re assuming a specific correlation between subjective minor discomfort and cognitive performance.
- moultano 5y agoI would posit that the level of CO2 you need to cause detectable society wide problems is probably lower than the level that makes a room actively uncomfortable to be in. There's a reason why we already have universal colloquial language to describe a room with too much CO2, "stuffy," "getting some fresh air to clear your head." We all know this stuff intuitively, we've experienced it directly our whole lives.