4 ms·
What an ignorant blowhard Cory Doctorow is. "This is a great strategy in light of US anittrust [sic] theories over the past 40 years, during which time antitru
by AlbertCory 5y ago
What an ignorant blowhard Cory Doctorow is.
"This is a great strategy in light of US anittrust [sic] theories over the past 40 years, during which time antitrust regulators promised to leave companies alone as they formed monopolies, provided they didn't hike price after attaining monopoly dominance."
No, Cory, that's not what happened and there was no "promise." The new theory of anti-trust was "consumer harm." Hiking prices is certainly one form of that, but so was forming a monopoly. Microsoft was prosecuted for forming a monopoly and reducing consumer choices.
"Google's true operating costs aren't captured by adding up its salaries and servers – a correct accounting must include the costs of acquiring companies and with them, patents. That's the cost Google must incur, if is to retain its power."
No, Cory, those are not "operating costs," those are called "capital costs." They're treated real differently in Accounting.
I was part of this "acquire patents" effort at Google. I actually interviewed people to be in Legal whose job would be to acquire patents. The theory (since discarded) was that a heavy patent portfolio would give you a better negotiating position if you were sued. There was no thought of actually asserting these patents against Microsoft, or anyone.
I actually used some of our internal tools to assess our patent portfolio. Most of those Motorola patents were worthless.
- saghm 5y ago> No, Cory, those are not "operating costs," those are called "capital costs." They're treated real differently in Accounting. I'm guessing he's aware that's how things work currently; it sounded to me like he was arguing that it shouldn't work that way, although I don't know if he literally believes that accounting practices should change or if that was more just for rhetorical effect.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoAll of this information could have been delivered without also delivering personal insults on the side.
- AlbertCory 5y agoPerhaps, but this is the second article by Doctorow this week.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tessierashpool 5y agothat's not a valid reason for insulting somebody. if I've had to tone down my attitude to fit the tone this site aims for, then I think you should too.
- socksick 5y agoI get his annoyance. It's infuriating to keep seeing the opinions of the ignorant elevated on HN as if they're gospel. It's bad enough that this place is a shrine to Paul Graham, let's not add any more fools to this roster.
- rektide 5y agoOh more undeserved out of hand insults, from another camp, great! Cory is a well networked, fairly thorough, informed blogger. He participates in all sorts of panels on topics of regulation, listens to a wide amount of voices. His views typically reflect & meet with a wide variety of other expert opinions. It's really unfortunate that such easy, cheap character assassination is being done against someone who has spoken so well, with such unvarnished genuine interest & care for what technology can be in this world.
- rektide 5y agoCory is awesome & has an accurate, informed view on techno-politics.
- johncena33 5y agoWell, it wouldn't be HN if people couldn't post angry rants about Google. 10% of HN is just a group of same people complaining about Google again and again. Anytime I see a link about Google, I know there wouldn't be any insightful discussion. Just same people complaining endlessly about the same things. I wish mods would do a better job moderating this relentless tirades.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoExcept in this case it's not against Google, but someone being aggressive against someone taking a position critical of Google. Disclaimer: I work at Google, and I'm used to keeping things polite when the workforce here is attacked on the forum. So not sure why the reverse can't also be true.
- gota 5y ago> I was part of this "acquire patents" effort at Google. I actually interviewed people to be in Legal whose job would be to acquire patents. The theory (since discarded) was that a heavy patent portfolio would give you a better negotiating position if you were sued. Interesting! Can you expand on this topic? Does/has the strategy work?
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThe theory goes like this. The Patent Office keeps granting overly broad patents to your competitors, who then show up to sue you for unintentionally violating them. So you get your own overly broad patents, counter-sue them when this happens, and then they all cancel out. The main problem with this strategy is patent trolls. Some company that doesn't make anything buys up some broad patents. Then there is nothing you can sue them over because they don't make anything so the strategy doesn't work. It also makes the whole concept of software patents pretty useless, because the "defensive patents" could equally be used to counter anyone who tries to sue you for violating a "legitimate" patent. So the whole system becomes a bludgeon for larger companies to use against smaller companies, because they have more patents, even if most of them are low quality, which means they can tie up anyone who actually makes anything in court indefinitely.
- AlbertCory 5y agoSome of that is correct, but patent trolls are only after money. They like to settle quickly for a fairly small amount, and move on. An effective counter-strategy is to resist them (with IPRs, especially) because that ties up their resources. As for big companies suing smaller ones: citations (in the mobile space), please?
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoYou're asking for citations to things that happen behind closed doors. "Big company pressures little company into a buyout/capitulation" is bad PR for big company, so part of the buyout/capitulation is to sign the NDA.
- orangeoxidation 5y ago> The theory (since discarded) was that a heavy patent portfolio would give you a better negotiating position if you were sued. There was no thought of actually asserting these patents against Microsoft, or anyone. Doesn't it kind of prove part of the argument? Google apparently felt threatened by patents, enough so to acquire "second strike capabilities" as deterrence. Seems to me Google though patents aggressive tools with the purpose to hurt other companies or threatening to do so (though defensively in this case). I am really interested in the "since discarded" part, if someone can recommend some reading.
- AlbertCory 5y agoIt only "prove[s] part of the argument" if you rephrase the argument to your liking. You are also conflating "defensive" and "aggressive." Kinda like saying Switzerland is "aggressive" because they have mandatory military service for all males.
- some_furry 5y ago> Kinda like saying Switzerland is "aggressive" because they have mandatory military service for all males. I'm curious: Have you heard of the state's "monopoly on violence" before? It comes up a lot in political theory discussions, and it applies to this attempted rebuttal by analogy.
- AlbertCory 5y agoI've certainly heard of that theory. How is that relevant to "defensive" vs. "aggressive"? You're saying Switzerland is aggressive because they have a military?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Snild 5y agoJust to offer a more benevolent interpretation: I read that "Google thought patents aggressive tools" sentence not necessarily as any implication of Google's intent, but rather an implication that Google were worried about patents being used as weapons against them.
- cma 5y agoI doubt the little guy acquiring patents at behest of some corporate initiative from executives actually necessarily gets told the real reason. It would leave an paper trail for antitrust. "Would give you a better negotiating position if you were sued" is the exact kind of generic motivation you'd want on something that's real purposes could look worse in an antitrust trial. Especially in light of stuff like "Google training documents advise avoiding monopoly language": https://www.theverge.com/2020/8/7/21358441/google-alphabet-training-documents-antitrust-search-legal https://www.theverge.com/2020/8/7/21358441/google-alphabet-t...
- gowld 5y agoThe entire point of the patent system is to provide a legal monopoly, as written in the Constitution. It's not a dirty secret.
- cma 5y agoA limited time monopoly on an invention. But antitrust laws are allowed to break up stuff with too much power if they engage in certain practices, and this can split up a patent portfolio amongst the parts.
- AlbertCory 5y agoYou and gota both need to read the literature on patent strategy in maturing markets. This is well-known and informed everyone's strategy in the 2010 era, Google's and Microsoft's. The literature says that in mature markets, the major players all have cross-licensing agreements sharing their giant patent portfolios, shutting out the minor players. They form an oligarchy, in other words. I may be a few years behind, having been retired for a few years, but I don't think this has actually happened. It's possible that Google and Apple and Microsoft really do have cross-licenses now, but I kinda doubt it. It would be too complicated to negotiate. What they have is mutually assured destruction.
- webmaven 5y agoThe difficulty of negotiating cross licensing deals has led to the creation of large patent pools like the Open Invention Network and Allied Security Trust.
- rektide 5y agoWow uh.... hitting a bit hard there. This seems like a very strong reaction, to something that seems straightforward & accurate to me. So you've found a couple bones to pick to justify these insults you're gunning to fire... here's my view on them. > No, Cory, that's not what happened and there was no "promise." Borkism's "consumer harm" theory has, in almost all cases, been centered around hiking prices. Given the lack of interference we've seen for the past 40 years, whether or not there was this "promise" seems moot: there has been a pathetically low level of anti-trust enforcement. Whether promised or not, there has certainly been a delivery. That you can cite a single 20 year old Microsoft case does little to convince me that there is efficient & active anti-trust regulation. It was a pretty heinous act, by Microsoft, at a time when there was only one mainstream consumer OS. But now that there's two OSes, there's no need for anti-trust, seemingly, and Apple is allowed to engage in far far far worse behaviors on iOS with regards to only permitting Safari technology to run, hampering the web. Social media companies have faced no scrutiny in their bonanza of competitor purchasing. The semiconductor market has undergone a radical vast wave of consolidation, again, seemingly entirely unchecked. Whatever the new Robert Bork "consumer harm" standard might grant it license to regulate, it certainly doesn't seem to be doing much. Proving those harms is much harder & more specific a task than what came before, and has, imo, been enormously clearly for the worse, as Cory continues to rightly argue. > No, Cory, those are not "operating costs," The entire basis of this post is that the accounting doesn't reflect the truth of the matter. The accounting of acquisitions as a one time capital costs isn't really genuine or fair, when a constant ongoing stream of acquisitions is required to maintain the power & position of dominance. The dominant player has to keep feeding the meter to continue operating from a position of power. Each of those may be a one time cost, but the macro behavior is that this is not so different than the grid hookup keeping the data-centers running. It sustains the dominance of the entity. It's an operating cost, the cost of staying where they are. Your point about patents is entirely besides the point. This isn't about companies using courts to try to destroy one another- something we haven't ever really seen at scale in the modern world. This is about Saturn Eating His Son. This is about the gigantic titaneous overlords of the planet insuring nothing new ever happens, preventing disruption. By acquiring all freshness & devouring it, bodily.
- AlbertCory 5y ago
- dang 5y agoPlease make your substantive points without name-calling and personal attacks. You broke the site guidelines badly here. This is particularly important when your view of the underlying issue is actually correct, because if you post like this about it, you end up discrediting not only yourself but also the truth [1], and that hurts everybody. We're really trying to avoid that sort of internet dynamic here. I certainly appreciate that you have inside knowledge about this topic and are willing to share it with us! That part is great. I also understand (believe me) the frustration that comes up when people make glib claims about a situation they don't have first-hand knowledge of. But if you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful. [1] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=truth%20discredit%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...
- AlbertCory 5y agoOK.