8 ms·
Fanbois treat criticism of favorite brands as threat to self-image
- bediger 15y agoThere's also a persistent rumor/concept among Linux aficionados that some or all of the worst profanity spouting, knuckle-dragging, "Sodomize Microsoft!" fanbois are actually paid-for "reverse shills". That is, some vague conspiracy finances trolls to make the rest of Linux advocates look stupid. This rumor seems like an example of "Poe's Law" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poes_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poes_law) in action.
- cooldeal 15y agoYou mean ones like this? http://it.slashdot.org/story/07/07/19/1231216/Mac-Worm-Author-Gets-Death-Threats http://it.slashdot.org/story/07/07/19/1231216/Mac-Worm-Autho... MS could get into a lot of legal trouble if they're caught faking death threats against Mac researchers. There are people who actually believe this?
- rbanffy 15y ago> There's also a persistent rumor/concept among Linux aficionados Never heard such thing and people here can tell you I am a very vocal Linux aficionado. But there are companies who specialize in interfering with forums to adjust brand-awareness for their clients.
- exJMCN 15y agoYou haven't read Boycott Novell or even Groklaw? The articles and comments are full of paranoid people who see Microsoft behind EVERYTHING.
- shabble 15y agoI'm reminded of the recent HBGary hack/infodump which contained a lot of material about creating software to ease/simplify sockpuppeting and plausible background generation for the US government. One article: https://www.infosecisland.com/blogview/12250-HBGary-Federal-Document-on-Manipulating-Social-Media.html https://www.infosecisland.com/blogview/12250-HBGary-Federal-... Dozens of others, including probably the leaked docs themselves via Google.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- krluna22785 15y agoThanks for this. It makes a lot of sense. I even take it personally when a brand I love holds an event or a specific sale that is accessible to everyone, even people who are not in love with the brand as much as I am.
- hugh3 15y ago... don't take this the wrong way, but you really need to change your relationship with life in general.
- athst 15y agoThey use the word "fanbois" to sound pejorative, but isn't this a good thing? It basically means that people are passionate about your company and its products. It means you're relevant. It has always been like that with rivalries like Mac vs. PC, Nintendo vs. Sega, and now Android vs. iPhone/iPad.
- bluekeybox 15y agoIt's not cool to be passionate. It's always been cool to be intelligent though. EDIT: I did not mean to say that being passionate is bad. I meant to say that in most social situations, appearing overly passionate is often bad. Right now, I am struggling to maintain passion for the project I'm working on and I know that I will fail as soon as I stop being passionate about it -- so I know there are hard times when passion is necessary. However I think that my point about appearing "cool" holds -- more people get excited about my projects when I put up an impression of total control and slight lack of passion rather than the other way around. One has to know how to program both oneself and others.
- bgurupra 15y agoNo great thing was ever accomplished without being passionate.Even the research field which is all about intellectualism needs you to be passionate about your ideas and ploughing away at them even though they are just untested hypotheses till it gets proved
- bluekeybox 15y agoProblem is, one needs to be passionate about the right things from the very beginning -- and, paradoxically, the only way to decide objectively which things are worth being passionate about is to start off being dispassionate about them.
- timwiseman 15y agoBut you do not need to be passionate about the right things from the beginning. For one thing, it is possible to move into a field late in life and make enormous advances. Fermat provided a brilliant example of this. Of course, you could say Fermat was an outlier, but I suspect that anyone who is truly, deeply passionate about something is an outlier already. Most people go through their lives with little passion at all.
- molecule 15y agoSelf-image, affiliation? Branding, indeed: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Livestock_branding http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Livestock_branding
- gruseom 15y agoHumans treat criticism of favorite anything as threat to self-image.
- astrodust 15y agoIt's because once you take the time to become discerning, to have an opinion on something, that opinion shapes you.
- hussong 15y agoSo true, and that makes it hard to have a discussion with them. Some people just don't want to get it. Additional information would only increase cognitive dissonance and will be fended off at all costs.
- hugh3 15y agoNot necessarily. Not all humans. Perhaps insecure humans, or humans without enough going on in their lives. For instance, if I tell you my favourite breakfast cereal is Raisin Bran, and you tell me that Raisin Bran suxx0rs and Rice Krispies rulez then I'm not really gonna take that as a big threat to my self-image -- I'll just think that you're a weirdo for having such strongly expressed preferences on such matters. And for the vast majority of the population, the question of your favourite brand of consumer electronics falls into the same category.
- gruseom 15y agoHeh. Is the phenomenon absent in those cases, or just weaker?
- gaoshan 15y agoFrothing at the mouth over other people's choice of computer or vehicle or clothing, excessive "keep off my property" signage, getting mad at being "looked at"... all signs of the same thing. Lack of self-image.
- ilamont 15y agoI always thought this was an interesting example of Apple extremists being provoked by a hoax: http://www.wired.com/gadgets/mac/news/2004/02/62157 http://www.wired.com/gadgets/mac/news/2004/02/62157 The hoaxer, identified only as "Andy," claimed he received a dual-processor G5 for Christmas. But preferring a Windows PC, he swapped out the insides of the $3,000 machine for the guts of a cheapo PC. The post included several digital photographs to prove the outrageous claim. It generated insults from all over the world, and even threats of violence. bediger also mentioned the possible presence of "reverse shills" being used to pollute the Linux camp. I believe there may be some truth to that -- it's one way to convince on-the-fence tech execs that Linux/Open Source supporters are extremists. I also believe there's a parallel in politics: Many political campaigns, when they take the fight into online forums, blogs, and newspaper comment threads, attempt to make the other side seem as offensive and idiotic as possible. Extremist commenters repel moderates who might otherwise be aligned with the cause, and/or attract other extremists. I don't have proof of this (almost all such comments are anonymous) other than the staggering incidence of idiocy I see on comment threads when politicians are discussed.
- exJMCN 15y agoIt's sometimes easy to check if someone is a corporate shill designed to discredit people or not. For example on Slashdot or HN, you can check their comment history. When you do that for Apple or Linux 'extremists' you always find them commenting normally in other discussions and even going in-depth into the ones that they're passionate about, i.e Apple or Linux discussions. If you think that those threats of violence were paid for by MS, I think you're being paranoid.
- burgerbrain 15y agoAs an extreme example some believe that the Westboro Baptist Church is a group of these "reverse shills". I don't think I believe that myself though.
- AndrewMoffat 15y agoIf it was true, it would be incredible dedication. Lots of people want them dead. To put your life (and your kids' lives!) on the line like that for either cause (legitimate bigotry or reverse shill) is insane regardless
- siglesias 15y agoI don't think this is such a bad finding. Let's look at this from the perspective of the "brand." I make apps. What gets me pumped more than anything is an email in the morning from a customer who says they really enjoy my app and use it every day. Strong customer feedback and loyalty are what drive me to make better products. If we were to take the opposite case, that customers saw brands as interchangeable cogs, then the only incentives out there for the people making products would be money, and that isn't what motivates creative people on a deep level. A base of highly loyal customers creates, if you will, a very, very high bar of "social pressure" that makes it harder for managers to make decisions that screw them over.
- rkalla 15y agotl;dr: we make snap decisions about people because we have to; the world moves fast. therefore we want people to make the right snap decision about us, so we brand ourselves with bits and pieces of all the brands out there that we think convey us to the outside world. the line between brand and "me" get very blurry. when a person says "I hate brand X", because of that blurry line, they are saying/you are hearing: "I hate X% of you!" --------------------------------- We have all seen this online at some point or another... Apple/Windows, iPhone/Android, Xbox/PS3, Vegetarian/Paleo, etc. and unfortunately I imagine a good number of us have experienced this in-person as well. Bumping heads with someone fully ingrained in their brands is frustrating like no other, but why is it so pervasive? What is lacking in a person's life such that they carry around the brand of their favorite product with more pride then their own self-worth/intelligence/curiosity/love-of-life? It seems like a global identity crisis. Advertising tells us we HAVE to be different, we HAVE to be unique. God forbid I be exactly like my neighbor and we understand each other with a little bit of compassion... screw that, he's an idiot, and I am smart. Then you see people so desperately clawing at uniqueness that things like branded clothing and devices just do not cut it anymore and you have explosive growth in body modifications[1]; tattoos to piercings in every other person I see at a coffee shop or walking down the street anymore. I don't actually care what people do; if you need to feel different, go for it. What I do care about is the obsessive need for it in order to live your life. I feel like that is an artificial requirement that does nothing good for any of us. Advertising has convinced us so whole heatedly that unless we are different (like everyone else) we won't be happy. So it isn't much of a surprise that I compose myself, like a Frankenstein of identities, with a dash of iPhone, a sprinkle of back tattoos, a hint of ear-loop piercings, a flick of BMW and a smattering of D&C shoes to properly and completely define myself to the world. A visual finger print of "who I am". All these brands are a giant grab-bag of fractions of identities that advertisers have attached to each one that we reach into and stick to ourselves in order to convey an ideal to the world. I am relaxed, but smart, aware of my self-image, like nice things and care about the earth. Ok, so I have an iPhone 5, I wear trendy silicon valley swag, drive a BMW 5-series and shop at Whole Foods with my flip flops on. It seems to me that this is the fallout from two things: 1. Advertisers dividing and conquering us for a century. 2. Pace of life being magnitudes times faster now. I don't have time to get to know you anymore, so I make a snap decision on who you are, what you believe in and how you live by looking at how you label yourself. Nice suit, nice car, big house, practice law and live in Dallas? Then I guess you are a Republican, don't care about the earth, hate social programs and only care about yourself and your family. See what conclusions I jumped to? Now when I see you cutting your hedge and getting clippings on my lawn, I already hate you and decided you only care about yourself, so my opening sentence to you is "Hey Jerkface, come rake this up!" Nevermind the fact that even if I lived next to you for 10 years, I might never get to know you anyway. I don't know that any of this is "wrong" or "bad", it just is what it is. We jump to snap decisions because we don't have the time NOT to. Because we jump to snap decisions we want to make sure we brand ourselves in the proper way to convey the RIGHT snap decision. So the line between "me" and "my brands" are blurring really badly. If I identify myself with the brands I chose, to some extent those brands ARE me. If you hate those brands, then you hate me... and I hate you. Which is unfortunate. [1] http://images.google.com/search?tbm=isch&hl=en&source=hp&biw=1262&bih=1390&q=body+modification&gbv=2&oq=body+modification&aq=f&aqi=g10&aql=&gs_sm=e&gs_upl=212l2663l0l2838l22l17l1l7l7l0l205l1220l2.6.1l9l0 http://images.google.com/search?tbm=isch&hl=en&sourc...
- kinship 15y agoWorst post ever. So immature. Kids...
- araneae 15y agoTo be fair, the Toyota thing was a grand experiment in human psychology as well.
- njharman 15y agoI thought that was part of the definition of a fanboy, no? Irrational "love" of foo, "hatred" of those that disagree due to psychological issues such as cognitive dissonance.
- podperson 15y agoIt seems to me that passions flare when people are forced to make an expensive, difficult to reverse choice based on insufficient evidence between similar but highly incompatible products. E.g. which car is going to be better? I don't know, there's really no way to find out (history is at best a guide), so I do "research" and make a choice and now I am stuck with it. I'd like to believe I made a good choice, so any evidence that I clearly made a bad choice is hurtful. Brands simply become shorthand for these choices. You don't see Toshiba vs. Panasonic vs. Lenovo laptop wars because the choice there is not so hard to reverse and the deciding factors were fairly clear. But you do see it in Canon vs. Nikon DSLRs (because lens incompatibility forces you to double down on your choice). Probably the worst example of this kind of thing is not Apple vs. (whoever) but religion.
- hugh3 15y ago* It seems to me that passions flare when people are forced to make an expensive, difficult to reverse choice based on insufficient evidence between similar but highly incompatible products. E.g. which car is going to be better? I don't know, there's really no way to find out (history is at best a guide), so I do "research" and make a choice and now I am stuck with it. I'd like to believe I made a good choice, so any evidence that I clearly made a bad choice is hurtful* This doesn't explain why the vast majority of the population seems to be perfectly able to buy a car and not become fanboys, whereas a small, largely very young, overwhelmingly male, sector of the population feel compelled to defend far more minor purchasing decisions. Example: I drive a Ford. For some folks, driving a Ford puts you on one side of some great battle, whether it be Ford vs GM or Domestic vs Imported. For me, it's just a goddamn car, and my next car will probably be something entirely different. I don't feel compelled to defend the decision I made in buying that car, nor to argue that it's "better" than any other car, because (a) there's a lot of cars out there, each with its own advantages and disadvantages and (b) life is too short.
- podperson 15y agoYou're overly focused on iPhone vs. Android without considering all the other kinds of fanboism out there that simply go under other labels, whether it's patriotism, religion, favorite TV show, or brand of camera. Is it all teenage boys? Well, teenage boys are a lot more passionate and vocal about whatever it is they're interested in than other demographics, but you don't have to look hard to find middle-aged Nikon fanatics, or Protestant nut jobs.
- devindotcom 15y agoYep. I compared it to a redirection of angst: http://techcrunch.com/2010/08/21/fanboyism-when-expression-meets-desperation/ http://techcrunch.com/2010/08/21/fanboyism-when-expression-m...
- wtracy 15y agoNext question: What can brand owners do to cultivate (or discourage!) this behavior?