3 ms·
I really like the Unix philosophy. And even if Linux it is not exactly Unix, it kind of shares the same philosophy. I tried very much to like Linux and to use
by DeathArrow 5y ago
I really like the Unix philosophy. And even if Linux it is not exactly Unix, it kind of shares the same philosophy.
I tried very much to like Linux and to use it on the desktop. In the last 20 years I've tried countless times to use it as a desktop. But it always failed. It always reqyired lots of time for configuration as opposed to "it just works". After some time, it always broke something, which required again time to fix. And it doesn't run all the software I want to run. And even if an alternative might exists to some of the software I need, it is always sub-par. It doesn't do what I need, it doesn't do it well and it will run poorly and/or has a poor user experience.
And I am not even convinced someone should relearn how to do things with another software just to give Linux a chance. Sure, if you are 14 and idealistic it might work. But after 30 your time will worth much more.
Software and drivers written some time ago won't work because there's no stable ABI.
The software landscape is very fragmented.
From my long experience with trying to use Linux on the desktop I can give a very long lecture of why it sucks from both user and technical perspectives alike.
On the other hand it is perfect as an server OS, and I make my daily living writing software that ultimately runs on Linux. But please do not force me to use it as a desktop because I've tried to like it but I couldn't.
I pretty much doubt that Linux will be a decent desktop OS unless some company will release an OS based on Linux, pretty much how Google did with Android on mobile.
For desktop community development simply doesn't cut it. Fragmentation, lack of direction and the reinventing of the wheel kills it.
To have a decent server OS you need a single architect and a dictator which will be the only one to take decisions. This is why macOS, primarily an amalgamation of BSD software with a Next skin succeeded.
- yepthatsreality 5y agoAlot of what you wrote is true for MacOS and Windows and other major operating systems. Linux doesn't want you either.
- rbanffy 5y ago> But after 30 your time will worth much more. Once you know how to start an application and how to find the ones that are installed, the learning curve is within the app. > Software and drivers written some time ago won't work because there's no stable ABI. Not sure what you are doing here. Are you trying to load binary drivers written for an old Linux version on a new kernel? Isn't there a mainlined driver that works? Do you think it's a common use-case? > The software landscape is very fragmented. If I need to install something, I either get it from the distro's repos of its "app store". Not sure what "fragmented" means here. > From my long experience with trying to use Linux on the desktop I can give a very long lecture of why it sucks from both user and technical perspectives alike. It may be worth writing a more detail article or blog post. User perspective is always valuable.
- inciampati 5y agoCould it be that you are trying to use Linux like people use OSX and Windows? For instance, manually installing lots of things to try to get your system setup how you want? Messing around with tons of drivers for your funky hardware? Installing lots of applications from third party sources without checking if they're in the OS's own repo? The secret is to go with the flow, and use company-curated, community-and-history-grounded OS releases. Then you install almost everything using the system's package manager. The odds of breaking something if you go with the stream drop so close to 0 that it's not worth worrying about. And the last and most important trick is to buy from companies which support Linux for enterprise customers.
- gspencley 5y agoEveryone's mileage will vary to some degree and no one but you knows what your specific requirements are, obviously. I use Linux both at home and at work and over the last couple of years have been pleasantly surprised how much the software gap has narrowed. A lot of this has to do with SaaS software which, ironically I don't like, but in a few circumstances it makes sense. Office tools at work, for example. If you're a G-suite shop Google docs and gmail will work regardless of your system, if you're a MS shop then Office, Outlook, Calendar and even Teams will run in a web browser. But even for native applications this gap has narrowed. Zoom, Slack and Discord all have native Linux apps that just work for me. Google Chrome, which I wouldn't use for my personal devices but I need to use for work as a Web developer, has a Linux version that works as great as the Windows version. But the most important part is that all of these tools are cross-platform now. There is no relearning a tool unless you depend on a native Windows app for which there is no Linux version (which you likely do, from the sounds of it). The desktop environments are where the real differences come into play. I can't even comment there since I switched to Linux Mint MATE when Ubuntu introduced Unity years ago. I like MATE a lot but I customize the hell out of it to suit my needs and I'm hardly qualified to have an opinion about what other people should be using. I did, however, recently decide to go with KDE Plasma for a TV streaming device that I put together. It's a small, low-powered machine and I didn't think I'd consider KDE because it's kind of notorious as a resource hog. But I needed something that could give me a good UI for a TV and remembered that Plasma supports desktop widgets and is highly customizable. So I tried it and was pleasantly surprised how performant it was. That's how quickly things change. The last time I tried KDE on a desktop it was sluggish and I didn't care for it at all. But my information and pre-conceived notions became outdated. Not telling you to try Linux again. Use whatever works for you. Just sharing my experiences for conversation.